Stamford, Vermont · The town record

Stamford Planning Commission

2026-06-22 · Regular
Unofficial archive
← previousnext →
Stamford Planning Commission · Regular

June 22, 2026

120 min · town drive · audio · minutes (town PDF) · markdown
Lisa GramlinPam TworigMarta MillerDeb BurchardAlden Finneyabsent: Natalie O’Neilabsent: James Stimpson
Regular meeting of the Stamford Planning Commission (2026-06-22). Present: Lisa Gramlin, Pam Tworig, Marta Miller, Deb Burchard, Alden Finney. Absent: Natalie O’Neil, James Stimpson. The minutes record 1 motions (1 approved, 0 with another outcome). Items on the agenda: Town Of Stamford, Vermont; Planning Commission.
On the agenda

Motions (1, 1 passed)

accept as corrected Marta Millerseconded: Deb Burchardpassed
“MOTION by Marta Miller to accept as corrected.”
All in Favor. 3. Community Engagement and Survey Response Reminder that July 10th is the deadline for residents to submit the community survey that will help guide the Planning Commission in updating
Vote: unanimous voice vote
not matched to a paragraph in the transcript

Follow-ups named in the minutes

What the extraction was unsure about

Transcript

783 paragraphs · 0 of the diarized voices in this recording carry a name; unnamed voices stay "Speaker N" and ambiguous turns are labeled "Uncertain speaker(s)". Word-timing uncertainty alone does not split an utterance.
783 paragraphs
Speaker notes & reading guide
underlined words are defined in the glossary
Speaker 1 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 2 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 3 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 4 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 5 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 6 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 7 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 8 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 9 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 10 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 11 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 12 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 13 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 14 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 15 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 16 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 17 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 18 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 19 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 20 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 21 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 22 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 23 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 24 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 25 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 26 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 27 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 28 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 29 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 30 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 31 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 32 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 33 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 34 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 35 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 36 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 37 — no voiceprint match
Speaker 38 — no voiceprint match

Are we going? I guess.

Speaker 1 All right, then that's all. Okay.

Speaker 2 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

Speaker 1 Okay, welcome to a meeting of the Stamford Planning Commission. If you have a matter to discuss that is not included on the agenda, the agenda means do so by addressing the chairperson and stating your name. You'll notice all of our meetings are recorded. This is to aid with the summarization of the minutes and are available to view on YouTube. Visitors are allowed five minutes per comment and 15 minutes per topic. Planning Commission members present are Pam Tward, Lisa Gramlin, Marta Miller, Deb Burchard,

Speaker 3 Aldi Finney.

Speaker 1 Will there be any addition or subtraction of items from the agenda? I would like to add on the attendance policy just to review it because we change when we meet. Sure. And I'd like to move the bylaw discussion to the very end. Great. Okay, hearing of visitors? Okay. Reading and approval of records from June 8th. I move to approve the minutes. Okay, I just.

Speaker 4 I had it correct.

Speaker 5 Yeah, go ahead, Deb. Number six, duplicated.

Speaker 1 Oh, I didn't see that.

Speaker 5 But just, it has to be renumbered. Oh, right, I didn't know about that.

Speaker 1 There were two sixes. That's true.

Speaker 5 Yes, that was, yes. Five meetings.

Speaker 1 No, I did, because I moved the numbers and I didn't do it right. Because I added stuff in in the beginning, because Pam wasn't out recording at that time, so I wrote the first part. I also want to just check Nick Zajac, it's not Nick Zach in there, Z-A-K, but it's Z-A-I-A-C and it's pronounced Z-I-A-C, for any one of you. Z-I-A. Z-A-I-A-C, so it looks like Zajac, but it's one C. Z-A-I-A-C. Okay. Z-A-I-A-C. Okay, so we had a motion with changes from Marta. Any second? Second. Aye. All in favor? Aye. Okay, old business. I just wanted to add that maybe we could put a sign at the dump and or on the school about the survey, because I've been putting it on the Facebook page, but not everyone's on Facebook, so maybe we could do that. That's a good idea. Do we have any idea how many responses we've gotten? It was only 10, but that was two weeks ago. I haven't checked with her since. 10?

Speaker 5 So, oh.

Speaker 1 That was the online responses, too. I didn't.

Speaker 6 Well, I asked, when I was down here for something, I asked Lori, and she said yes, that they'd gotten a bunch in the box. Oh, good. So, yeah. No number, though, right? She didn't have a number. All right. And it is July 10th, we were right about that date. July 10th. Yeah. That should also just be in our minutes, that reminder that July 10th is. Yeah, can you put that in there? The closing date for the survey.

Speaker 1 Sounds good, but we really want to push that so we can get as much information as possible. I'll put it on Facebook again. Does anyone want to put it on the, a sign on the school? All right, I'll put a sign on the school.

Speaker 5 I'm sorry, I was writing down. I'll do, I'll make one for the dump, if you want.

Speaker 1 Thanks, Deb. All right, new business.

Speaker 5 Real quick, is there a form, like, or just, like, okay.

Speaker 1 Yeah, if you could make it a little bigger, Deb, though, you know what I mean? Do you know how to do that? So. If you, I can do it if you want, but you can make it so it prints on, like, four pages and then you tape them together.

Speaker 5 Oh, I'll figure that out. Yeah. That's why I have Nick.

Speaker 6 Yeah, so, just so it's bigger so people see it at the dump. Between the mechanics and the graphic artists at your fingertips, you really have resources.

Speaker 5 I'll do it.

Speaker 1 Okay, new business. I attended the VLCT spring planning and zoning meeting. The main thing I wanted to let the board know is about the next grant coming up. The due date is September 1st with a closing date of 11-2, so we have two months to do that. Last time, the odds were 50-50, if you remember. For us getting the grant.

Speaker 5 And this is for the bylaws.

Speaker 1 For the bylaw grant. If we could go for that. So, I say that we definitely need to do our own bylaw work. I'd say we're going to probably have a 50% chance shot at that again. The odds are, they do give preference to small towns of our size, but they also give preference if we already have an open grant like we do. If another town's applying and they don't have one, they will get it over us. So, that, like, those are the odds. One's in our favor and one's not.

Speaker 3 So, that's the town plan.

Speaker 1 Mm-hmm. So, I think that, like, makes us even again. And it would be Nick that would be working with us as opposed to Callie. Why would it be Nick? I'm not sure.

Speaker 5 I think that's what he said.

Speaker 1 Oh, for the bylaws?

Speaker 5 For the bylaws. Oh, okay. Yep.

Speaker 1 Would he help us with the grant application? Maybe.

Speaker 5 Yeah.

Speaker 1 That would be great.

Speaker 5 Do you want me to ask him?

Speaker 4 Yeah, that would be great.

Speaker 1 We do have until September, but it can't happen. It's going to be hard to find out. September's right around the corner. I know.

Speaker 5 Trees are already starting to turn.

Speaker 1 Really?

Speaker 5 Just the sick ones.

Speaker 1 Okay. The other thing is, that was in that meeting, was about the housing targets from the HOME Act. When we do our town plan, I feel like I have to yell because it's going to rain.

Speaker 7 Yeah.

Speaker 1 We do our town plan. We can include what barriers we would have to making the goals that will be set for us further. We have to include the HOME Act, our goals of how much housing we have to provide for. Such limitations could be environmental, enhanced flood restrictions, stuff like that. So we want to keep that in mind as we do the town plan. We may have reasoning why we can't meet the target goals that BCRC slash the state is putting on us.

Speaker 6 Well, and also no town water and no town sewer. Right. Yeah. I mean, those are the most obvious ones. Yeah. Do you have a memory of the number that you have?

Speaker 8 Do you have a memory of the number that they were asking us to? No. I need to find that out.

Speaker 2 What was the number?

Speaker 6 Do we know what our target is for our town? Our target number? There was a number. Target for housing? Yes. How many houses we're supposed to come up with. Really? Which, I mean, I just have, I'm like, what? Did they come up with a number already? Where? There was a number in one of the. There was. Yeah. In one of the numbers. I think they must be. In one of the. Just somehow coming up with something. Pulling it out of thin air. Well, I don't.

Speaker 2 I mean, what would they base it on?

Speaker 6 That's my question. It's like, it would be one thing.

Speaker 2 Isn't that what we have? Probably base, they're probably basing it on, you know, your, the number of acres in town. And, you know, how, how much housing does the entire state need? And breaking it up into towns. And, you know, Stamford's fair share is.

Speaker 3 We don't have to comply with that.

Speaker 1 We kind of do, unless we can prove out, provide a reasoning why we cannot make that goal.

Speaker 2 Well, okay. But, you know. Well. What do you mean, we kind of do? Are they going to come down here and put a gun to our head and say, build houses? I mean, how do they, how do they. Enforce. Right. How do they force. Right. People. To build homes. Yeah. In. The town. Well, they're, the expectation is there for us.

Speaker 5 But, if there is no incentive, we don't have an incentive for people to move to Stamford. I mean. We're not in close proximity to Bennington or Brattleboro.

Speaker 2 Well, I mean, I think people would be happy to move here and would be happy to, um, live here as, as we see with every single time a house goes on sale, it's gone like that. And there's way more people that want to live here than there are houses available. But that doesn't mean that there are people who haven't moved here. Right. Because they don't have the ability to buy the land and build the house. And we, we can't, we have no control over that. That'd be one thing if the state owned. I mean, as long as we're not stopping them. Right. I think they can say, well, you can't stop people from building homes, but we're not doing that. Right. People can, people can build here. Right. But they have to be able to buy the land and afford to build. Right. Which is crazy. Right. Yeah. I mean, now it's. Yeah. You know, you can buy a house at $200 a square foot and it's going to cost you $4, $4.50 to build. Oh, that's the main question. Okay. That's, that's the issue. That's why there's no building going on because it's so incredibly expensive to build. Right.

Speaker 6 Interesting. All right. My guess is that they're posturing that we have to do this, but I don't see that there's any mechanism. As you say, there's no financial incentive. There's no, it's not as if the state owns land and is saying, we want to build a house on this. We want you to put a house on this.

Speaker 7 I don't think they can technically make us.

Speaker 4 I don't think, I don't know how they would.

Speaker 5 They can open up some of their state forests. I mean.

Speaker 2 I mean, I think that, I think that, I think everyone knows that we need more housing. We need more housing everywhere, but that doesn't mean that we're going to get it. Right. It's just not that simple.

Speaker 5 Does, let me, let me ask, does Stamford really need more housing or is it difficult? Well. To feed North Adam? Well. Or. To feed the other. Well. The second home market. I mean, obviously the state. That's the thing. We don't have anything here. So we don't need more housing.

Speaker 2 Correct. I mean, we as a town. We as a town. The, the state in order to, in order to thrive, if people are just leaving. Oh, you know what? And you don't have. I don't understand that. I mean, in order, in order to drive an economy and to thrive, you, you, you cannot have this, what's happening right now. You, you do, you need it. But that doesn't mean that, it doesn't mean that it's beneficial to Stamford.

Speaker 5 But I think what the state needs is not something we're going to be able to help out with. They need higher density homes. They need the infrastructure that will support that. I'm not saying that. Trust me. I know that's the only way we get taxes. So, or we have revenue is through property taxes. So in a sense, yeah, it'd be great if we had more. I just don't think it's the same thing as the state is thinking of. Right. I mean, it'd be great if we could build a condominium complex. Imagine. Would it? No, it wouldn't. Well. Not a condominium.

Speaker 9 It's not a park.

Speaker 2 Well, and, and, and, and it depends on where you're talking about. Because if you talk about development, so there's a difference between developing all along the state maintained highway and developing up in the mountains where now we have to maintain the roads and it costs us an absolute fortune. I mean, those are two totally different things. Yeah. So.

Speaker 6 Hence, essentially the whole village center designation around a state highway and hence, you know, the. The. Effort to conserve and not overdevelop in the, in the spots where you'd have to be building these roads.

Speaker 2 I mean, it makes sense if you want tax revenue and you have a state highway that we are not responsible for, then it makes sense to try to have that development occur along the state highway.

Speaker 10 But you've still got sewer and water problems.

Speaker 2 Well, that, I mean, that's a whole. Yeah. That's. That's a whole different thing. That's the next. That's a whole other question.

Speaker 10 And we're so small, we can't do anything about it. Yeah.

Speaker 11 Right.

Speaker 1 Yeah. I know they want that whole infill thing, but, you know. Yeah. That's not a good idea either.

Speaker 5 So what was your take away from.

Speaker 1 Just that my take away was that as long as we provide while we're doing the town plan our limitations to growth.

Speaker 10 Mm-hmm.

Speaker 5 What we perceive as our limitations. Okay. Right.

Speaker 6 Well, that's good. That's important to know that we need to build that in.

Speaker 12 Yeah.

Speaker 3 And zoning too.

Speaker 6 Yeah. Mm-hmm.

Speaker 1 So that's all I got except that we can't limit people to under 12 chickens. That's the new rule. What is? You have to allow, you have to allow 10, 12 chickens. But you don't have to allow roosters.

Speaker 2 Yeah.

Speaker 6 Wait. Up to 12 chickens are permissible. But no roosters are permissible?

Speaker 1 You don't have to allow roosters.

Speaker 3 We don't have to. This is a state thing?

Speaker 13 Yeah.

Speaker 1 They expanded chickens.

Speaker 10 Do you have all the roosters you want though? Because it's not a chicken.

Speaker 1 No. Unless our town says no roosters. Which, you know, for some people, I guess, could be a noise.

Speaker 5 That would be awful. Oh my gosh. We had our rooster. We loved Rudy, but he just didn't shut up.

Speaker 14 Rudy.

Speaker 6 Rudy the rooster.

Speaker 5 Rudy the rooster. He was, he was the nicest of all. We had 17 chickens, 16 chickens and Rudy. He was the nicest, friendliest guy, but he's so loud.

Speaker 4 Oh.

Speaker 1 What was the previous chicken limitation? I think it was, I believe it was six, but don't hold me to it. Well, you know, it is a food source, so it, I think it's good.

Speaker 3 So you have to have a minimum of six?

Speaker 1 You don't, no. You just, the town can't, the town can't say you can't have, like, the town can't say you can only have six. We have to allow 12. They can have, I guess, more if we say you can have 24.

Speaker 2 Which, which is, for places like Burlington or cities, I mean, that's not, it's just totally

Speaker 1 not, it's not, it's not relevant. I'm just kind of trying to think here. I just wrote it down, so I thought it would be funny. I know. I just wrote it down, so I thought it would be funny.

Speaker 1 All right. And he has a new business?

Speaker 2 What about... Old business? What about the, the Zoom meeting that, did you go to the Zoom meeting? I went to it. I'll be there. I went to it. I saw he was on it. Yeah. I didn't go. Did you go to it, too? Yeah. Did you guys look at the maps?

Speaker 15 Yes.

Speaker 2 The wetland maps? Sort of. So, I mean, I got on there during the...

Speaker 1 I screenshotted everything.

Speaker 15 Yeah.

Speaker 2 I got on there.

Speaker 16 I couldn't go to that, but I did research it after.

Speaker 2 I mean, I went up and, I went up and down the valley, and I mean, obviously I pay pretty close attention because I live on the river. Yeah. But I went up and down the valley, and for the most part, yes, they did add some wetlands where there were not wetlands before, and they did make some wetland areas bigger, but they also made some wetland areas smaller. And I didn't see, you know, like I said, I mean, I've been to a lot of wetlands, and I went up and down the valley, like, looking for, looking for things. I didn't see anything that was just like, oh my God, you know, I didn't, I didn't see anything.

Speaker 3 They're not done with their mapping anyway.

Speaker 2 Well, I think we're done. I think we're, I think... Well, it's still in the draft stage. It's not... Yeah. Oh, because they're used to, they're still comments.

Speaker 5 Yeah. If you want an A&R wetlands map right now, you know, the, it's different from what, what we see as, you know, the conceptual draft. Yeah. They added, so the A&R map, the normal one, or the current one, does not have anything on our property, which we know there are wetlands up there. Now they do. So I was asking Bruce, they never came up on the property, and he laughed at me. He goes, really? He says they have, you know, the thermal imaging that comes down and just...

Speaker 2 Right. Someone asked that question during the meeting, and the thing is, and it makes total sense, that... It's true. ...you know, at certain times of the year, these indicator plant species are a certain color... Yeah. ...and they can tell by aerial photos... It's all LIDAR and... ...that, you know, what... Yeah. Yeah. And the LIDAR, too, is...

Speaker 5 Yeah. So, it, it's amazing. I mean, you, you can't, I don't want to say you want to get away anything, but... This camera's everywhere. You can't.

Speaker 1 For everything.

Speaker 2 I mean, it's... I mean, it's... Well, I mean, I, you know... ...they're, they're, they're spot on... on my property and near my property because I mean I know where they are as well and there they are

Speaker 5 yeah because you know I hike in the woods all the time and I know exactly where the water pools

Speaker 6 constantly so with the um the governor seems to be changing the buffer zone around wetlands

Speaker 2 is there something so that that it just makes me so angry yeah because if you have a wetland and you're trying to protect the wetland and there's a reason to protect wetlands and the buffer was 50 feet and now because we want more housing we're now going to make the buffer 25 feet it's like I I understand they want housing but this whole idea of basically just we're just going to throw everything out because now housing is more important than anything else it's kind of crazy and also I mean you know

Speaker 6 Kurt has pointed out that things like rivers move over the years so if you start chipping away right at the at the buffer zone you're asking for trouble it's in a in a state that has had increased flooding as we chop down trees I mean it's it's at cross purposes so now my next question is are we as a town allowed to ask for I mean just like setbacks are we allowed to create a more of a buffer zone

Speaker 10 around wetlands I don't know you can't make a state law less but you can strengthen it that's

Speaker 14 what I can most hear races I don't know and also how could we find out

Speaker 10 it's the same as overshadowing right strengthen it by moving but sometimes the state wins setback for

Speaker 2 the subject system but there's also the thing to consider usually the way wetlands get protected is via Act 250 because that's when that's when the big guns come in and that's when all the people that this is what they do come in if Stamford were to just try to do our own thing I just don't I just don't see how we're going to enforce that because who's the who's the who's the wetland person in town that's going to do that's going to do the monitoring who's going to enforce that I mean I just don't I just don't know that it's a right that it's a viable thing for us well

Speaker 5 yeah I mean the problem is so if you want to change it back to a fifty-foot I mean if you're going up onto somebody's property how do you know where the wetland actually stops you don't know so what are you going to get your tape up it it's such a fluid boundary literally literally right

Speaker 12 yeah that's why 50 feet is better than 25 well exactly i would agree right now it looks small

Speaker 10 because the water table is down yes

Speaker 5 i mean you can see the the boundaries even if the water has subsided you'll still see

Speaker 1 yeah and the funny thing about scott's thing is like it's only 0.15 percent of the land in vermont is affected by making it you know smaller the boundary but yet if we keep it at 50 that's 35 000 houses so like which is which you know is it just a small amount of land or is it

Speaker 10 You can't get what lands back once you... Right, they're gone. The development takes eons of time. Exactly. A house can burn down and be built back in no time.

Speaker 6 And then good luck getting flood insurance. Right. You know, if you make that boundary smaller and people start building there and then they find out they can't get flood insurance, I mean, it's just setting it up for disaster instead of, you know, smuggling.

Speaker 2 I object personally to the state being so desperate to get housing that they're going to throw out the whole wetland thing. And more importantly, throwing out the buffers that we need because we know that the flooding is going to increase. Yes. And that these areas are actually going to get larger. We actually want people building further away because they're going to get larger. And so, yeah, I think the state's quest for more housing is really, really out of hand.

Speaker 6 I mean, the other contributing factor is the increased logging in the forests because, I mean, when many forks farm, the people across the street cut down all their trees because the farm flooded because trees suck up the water and help manage the water table.

Speaker 10 Did you ever see what they did up in Somerset? No. Take a ride to Somerset sometime.

Speaker 6 Okay.

Speaker 17 What a disaster.

Speaker 10 You tell me that the state did that and that's good logging? That's slap logging.

Speaker 3 That's because it's the state. Yeah. Yes. They'll write it up at you, though. Uh-huh. Yeah, they try.

Speaker 1 I'm not sure how we find out how to get our voice. I haven't heard in that or see if we could put something as a municipality in place. I doubt that we can also.

Speaker 6 But I just wish I knew who to ask. I mean, if someone says, nope, you can't do that, then what about that woman that came and talked to us? What was she? The woman who came last meeting?

Speaker 5 I think Rebecca Chalmers is the wetland. I've spoken with her many times.

Speaker 18 Uh-huh.

Speaker 5 I can check with her again.

Speaker 6 Uh-huh. Or the woman who came last week, what was her name? I'm not last week. Last meeting. It's in the minutes. Yes, it is. It's Jessica Barcelo. The river quarter.

Speaker 1 But does that...

Speaker 6 Floodplain manager.

Speaker 18 And floodplain manager.

Speaker 5 You can ask any of them and they'll tell you where to go.

Speaker 6 Okay. Yeah. Okay. I do that.

Speaker 3 Wetlands and the river corridor are two entirely different things. Correct.

Speaker 6 Yes, but she also does floodplain. But you're right. Wetlands is a whole other topic. So... Yeah. Weirdly, it feels like they should all be...

Speaker 5 Can occur... Up on the mountain. Well, prime example.

Speaker 6 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 1 Okay. Are you going to check with Rebecca Chalmers?

Speaker 5 Yes. Thank you. And that's just to clarify that and to see if we would have any way to...

Speaker 6 Jurisdiction over our own wetlands boundaries.

Speaker 1 Yeah, or even a voice, you know, any input. A voice, right. Thank you.

Speaker 1 That's troubling.

Speaker 3 Thank you. And it comes out of my failures for us.

Speaker 19 Well, there's...

Speaker 5 You guys have probably all read it, but I know you guys don't care. I don't... Well, because...

Speaker 6 They've turned into a political organization that I don't appreciate. It's gone away from the topic at hand.

Speaker 2 Yeah. So, not that... I mean, on that subject, not that there hasn't been potentially overstepping and a... A... A... A drunkenness on power situation that has been occurring. But that doesn't mean that everything that... Everything that has to do with Act 181 or these other things is now 100% wrong. I don't... When people get off facts and they start ranting and raving... Because I've been reading that and I'm just like, what? Are you drunk?

Speaker 5 I would agree with... I would agree with you. However, they did highlight the fact that a lot of stuff has been done in the back rooms without public... We're all... We're all rural. And sometimes you have to be the loudest voice out there to support the people who aren't being heard.

Speaker 1 But I agree. It has turned totally as a political...

Speaker 5 But of course, that's because they have to. They're up against politics. They have to.

Speaker 1 Yeah, but organizing against, like, the Democrats, you know, like, that's... I think that's just taking it too far. But they can say the Republicans... No, I don't think it should be political parties. But, you know...

Speaker 6 The issue is... The issue is, and this should go, in my opinion, across whatever party, the issue is trying to balance the push for housing with the need for conservation.

Speaker 5 Absolutely.

Speaker 6 And unfortunately, people did not feel like they had a voice, or input. And also, I believe that the way it was crafted was burdensome to rural folks. Burdensome to people who have family land, or have family farms, or have a huge piece of land, where suddenly they were burdened financially rather than incentivized to conserve. So now it has become conservation is bad. The efforts... Anybody who tried to come... come up with something clumsily, in the back room, whatever, I mean, yes, incorrectly done, but it feels like the entire baby is going out with the bathwater. And also, why aren't all these people who are worried about their rights on land, why are they not up in arms about data centers? Yankee Nuclear, one of the potential development possibilities, is a data center. What does that do to land value? It's the land near it, right? The land near it. But I mean, after vetoing this, the, you know, the desire to not suddenly have data centers sprouting up on this rural land that people are like, oh, we are good, we can take care of the land, we don't want any regulations telling us what to do with the land. Well, fine. You know, a lot of good people are in possession of land, but they're not all old Vermonters. There's a lot of people who own a lot of land in Vermont who don't necessarily have the best interests of the state as a whole and of a community in particular. So you can say, I don't want anybody to tell me what to do, and then you can have a data center right next to your property or a housing development with a massive amount of people and, you know, it's going to mess up your well and your septic and your... So I just think that, you know, that all of a sudden, it's become this hue and cry of don't tell us what to do, which I agree with at its essence, but I also feel that it's become an anti-conservation push in its effort to be like, don't tell us what to do. There are thoughtful ways, right? There are thoughtful ways to engage with people and there are thoughtful ways to not impose, you know, a money grab from the state on every little thing that you want to do. I think that was a real oversight. And not getting community buy-in and engagement, I think all those things are true. But I would wager that there are a lot of folks who are joining in with the hue and cry who maybe haven't even read Act 181. Just saying. That's the feeling I'm getting.

Speaker 2 It's definitely swung too far and it's just, again, it's when people just start to get foaming at the mouth and instead of, like, looking at facts and talking about facts in a calm, rational manner. And I feel like that's not what's happening. You know?

Speaker 20 Starting in Montpelier.

Speaker 2 Absolutely, because I agree. I agree that I think that these major changes should have, you know, they should have been brought more to the forefront. Now, I will say, myself included sometimes, you know, you've got your own life, you've got a lot going on. If somebody doesn't really, like, you know, slap you in the face with something, you just kind of ignore it. Most people are busy, you know, and they ignore stuff. And this seemed, the Act 181 and the road rule thing seemed to just come out of nowhere. Like, all of a sudden it was here and it's just like, what do you mean?

Speaker 3 It's the first stated, first step of the state taking over the forest. Taking over our land. Not mine, but the people's land.

Speaker 21 Well, I mean,

Speaker 2 I think people, I think, as always, people need to just sit down at a table and have calm, rational discussion regarding facts. And if we all did that, you'd find that people are pretty aligned in their beliefs, I think, for the most part.

Speaker 5 Well, the Act 181 is, isn't, I mean, I've read it forwards and backwards and I agree. There are lots of points in 181 that I agree with. I just don't like a government, I don't, I'm not going to have them mess with my land and tell me what I can do. We're all, I think that's one of the things that Vermonters stand for. We are all conservationists. We don't, we don't clear-cut land. Right. We go in the forest and we pick the dead, the dead and sick to allow the other trees to come through. Most Vermonters are like that. It's the outside influencers, the Montpeliers, the people coming in, the people who want to clear-cut the land to sell the, And that's the state. Yeah. And that's the state. So, I think they're looking at the rural Vermonters as people who are losing their jobs and they're being themselves. I agree with you. Some people are different.

Speaker 6 And I could trust, if I could trust that everybody actually had that.

Speaker 5 I don't trust the government. I'm sorry, I'll be on record if I don't.

Speaker 22 The bulk of people who live in Vermont today came from somewhere else.

Speaker 10 There's that old generation all the way down through. It's below 25% that has traced their ancestry back in Vermont. It's very long now.

Speaker 2 There's a constant push and pull between when you say, don't tell me what to do with my land, and that is a normal human response. And so you can say, don't tell me what to do with my land, but you also understand that you don't want no zoning, right? Right. Because you understand that there have to be some guardrails. So there's a constant push and pull between don't tell me what to do with my land. So those are the things that are not easy. It's not easy to have that.

Speaker 5 But home setting is huge in Vermont. And keeping your family on your land is huge. Yeah. And now, in order to do that, you're having to trigger almost Act 250 if you want more than two loans on your property.

Speaker 2 And I don't disagree personally that at least the instances that I've seen of Act 250, I mean, it is incredibly burdensome. I mean, it's, you know, if you don't... No, if you're not rich, if you're not rich, you probably aren't going to do anything because it's just too burdensome.

Speaker 20 Make your property value go down. And so I'm very sensitive to that.

Speaker 2 I'm very sensitive to sicking Act 250 on people. I do understand there's projects where you need to do it. But I think that people being upset about a road going from, I don't know, what was it, 800 feet? To now anything over 800, whatever it was, was obviously a huge affront to people. And they could see the nightmare of Act 250 getting involved. And now all of a sudden, they can't afford to do anything. Remember the $450 a square foot to build. Now on top of that, that doesn't include Act 250 and the thousands and tens of thousands of dollars that that's going to cost you.

Speaker 9 Because attorneys' fees and everything.

Speaker 5 It's... It's a long, drawn-out process. And only the big developers can afford to jump through those.

Speaker 2 Well, I would hope that people would just sit down and speak to each other together. But note that we've got our two visitors who are here at every meeting. But we don't have any other people here who want to talk about this stuff.

Speaker 5 We've got the folks that came to talk about 181, but I haven't seen them since. I wish... I wish we did.

Speaker 1 They didn't really talk.

Speaker 15 They didn't talk.

Speaker 2 They want to hear about it.

Speaker 1 Yeah.

Speaker 15 I think they just...

Speaker 1 I wish they'd said more about it.

Speaker 2 I think they just wanted to make sure we weren't going to do something, I guess. I don't... I don't know.

Speaker 3 They were here to inform us. Right. Of what it... What it actually is.

Speaker 5 No, I think they were trying to get information.

Speaker 1 Mm-hmm. I mean, I still think that they do need to rework it a bit. Like, to... Because, to Marta's point, like... Like, I... Yes, you can trust people. But... I mean, they're not going to step on their land to a certain extent. But like some other people, they need their neighbors, sort of, to not... To step on their rights. So, I do think that there's some merit to, you know, conservation and revisiting that.

Speaker 2 I don't... So, I mean, what is our... Isn't the group that's supposed to be our representative the Bennington Regional Planning Commission? PCRC? Yeah. I mean, aren't... Aren't they... Aren't they supposed to be the group that kind of represents us? Or...

Speaker 6 My sense is that they represent the state and that they are agents from the state to come and work with us to help... To coerce... To help lubricate... State-wide. The... Yeah. The state's policies. Yes. So, it's hard because... I am...

Speaker 10 The state pays them. If the state pays them, they represent the state.

Speaker 1 Thank you. Don't we pay them also?

Speaker 10 Well... Oh, yeah. We pay them every year. Yeah. But if it's the state handing out the money, they're going to go to whatever the state says. Yes. Yes.

Speaker 9 They're just a pawn.

Speaker 2 Well, I mean, I think that... Well, they're like middlemen. I mean, everyone who's lived in Stamford for any period of time knows that Stamford is pretty protective of their rights and is going to just stand up to... I would agree. I mean, we... Yeah. I mean, the townspeople of Stamford know what it is that they want and what it is

Speaker 20 they don't want.

Speaker 3 Well, until they slip something in under the rug behind your back and nobody finds out about it until it's too late. Yeah. And that's what's happening.

Speaker 2 Well, and I think that's why everyone's so upset over this Act 181 thing. Yes. Because they just feel like they were blindsided with it. And... Yeah. I agree with that.

Speaker 23 I agree with that.

Speaker 2 And... I don't... You know, whether it was on... Maybe it was on purpose. I mean, maybe... Yeah. I mean, they really didn't want people to know. I don't know.

Speaker 5 I wonder if it wasn't because I know two of the people that are on that committee. And I really think they were just doing their job. You know, they were tasked a job and I think they forgot about the rule. Good faith. I think it was malicious.

Speaker 2 I hope it wasn't. Maybe just in their own bubble and they just think in a certain way and they just think that, oh, like... Here's what we need to do. Here's what we gotta do.

Speaker 23 I think that's right.

Speaker 6 I think that's right. Because there was... There was some whole thing from one of the guys who was like the environmental consultant, right, who worked with the legislators. Some talk that he gave, you know, talking about what his goals were. And so, you know, it's probably some guy from Norway or whatever who, you know, who came up with this plan and, you know, and then legislators try to enact it and people feel like it's... You know, directed at... But I don't think it was malicious. I do think the part where the state comes in to get money for stuff. Right. Like, why are these things so expensive? Why aren't there grants for, you know, people who are not giant developers? Why aren't there grants for those people to have help with Act 250? Why isn't there like a legal aid society sort of thing that helps them go through with that? Right. I mean, that's the part that is not respectful of the difference between rural landowners and big corporate developers, in my opinion.

Speaker 24 Right.

Speaker 1 If environmentalism is really the goal, we should make it easier, not harder.

Speaker 5 Well...

Speaker 6 Exactly. And we should incentivize people and also incentivize and reward people for conserving their land instead of punishing them.

Speaker 14 Why don't...

Speaker 3 But grants come essentially from our tax dollars. Right. That's true. Well, we pay to the state. They take our money from the state. They cut out to whoever they want. That's true.

Speaker 14 That's true.

Speaker 5 It is our... It is. But, you know, if conservation is so important... And it is. Why are we allowing... And this is just a side thing. We had to... We drive... We had to take like a two hour drive. Every roadside was just filled with that knotweed. So, all of our native wildflowers and everything, you know, we're so worried about the bees, we're so worried about the bees. and oh my god don't mow your lawn but but the state has is doing nothing about the knotweed

Speaker 2 that is literally i don't think they i i don't i mean now so i know they can't i didn't have a stitch of knotweed on my property before irene and i ended up i had to take right after irene i had to take a a very long trip um right after up there and basically during irene knotweed was just spread over the entire state now it's everywhere there's i mean it is extremely

Speaker 9 we had it on cleft road when we moved here and that was before irene no i know it did exist but

Speaker 2 now it's spread around and and there are ways to treat it with herbicides yeah but it's really hard i mean it's really really hard it's not there's no i mean i think we're gonna lose the i think we're just we i think we've lost the battle and it is what it is we're not even trying

Speaker 5 to trying to slow it down if you cut it before it starts to flower yes i get it the roots can go 50 100 feet 150 feet but if you keep trying to knock it down now it's all going up mill road it's horrible it's all my property i hate it like i keep trying to mow it down one section behind the barn it was just insane the only good thing is is it's

Speaker 2 it's it's really good at retaining bags

Speaker 10 when they ditch there was people asked for the dirt out of the ditch you take it in your yard and you spread it yourself right if you take that dirt out of the ditch that's where all that that weed is so you take it and spread it around wow you know so you can that's how it spreads we do it to ourselves yeah yeah oh free dirt yeah that weed

Speaker 6 anyway that's one for the next week

Speaker 5 the conservation committee yeah yeah how's that going because i didn't read any of the notes did

Speaker 6 they there's not much in the minutes i think there's just getting started okay yeah we went

Speaker 10 to the last meeting i like what we're doing kind of like what we're doing figure out what they can

Speaker 25 do you know make suggestions i mean one of the suggestions for that other uh you know that plant

Speaker 6 the poison parsnip the other the other suggestion for that which i mean maybe we should bring up with dave tetro is to is to do the roadside mowing before

Speaker 25 that seeds yeah because what's that that's what kurt pointed out during the meeting exactly because if you do it after you're spreading it exactly exactly so i maybe we should make a pitch um

Speaker 5 i thought i remember several years ago talking about this at the select board and dave said something about the state won't do it well

Speaker 4 birds are nesting this whole thing came up at the last select board meeting and

Speaker 1 dave was here and kurt was here he didn't mention okay but they did at length already talk about it less oh good okay good thursday so he is okay kurt made him aware again but it can't hurt to

Speaker 26 you know see why he doesn't know it sure i'm sure he's part of the issue is that he's busy

Speaker 2 and he does stuff when he when he can do it how he can do it

Speaker 9 he slips Alison you can't throw they have a third person we know he can swing a weed wicker yeah

Speaker 3 in the end it all comes down to the state regulating what he can do when he can do it

Speaker 18 you mean as far as dave yeah yeah i mean it feels like it's just starting to flower

Speaker 6 up by me anyway and it feels like what already yeah yeah it it's just flowering yeah it's right up

Speaker 14 way up county road yeah all up mill road it's all flowering already and yeah by now i mean i've seen

Speaker 23 nests and i've seen birds and they're they're fledging now so yeah it's the it's the birds that

Speaker 2 are in the um the birds that are in the fields the ones that nest on the on the ground like you have to wait until like the end of july to uh to mow but how many of those birds are nesting along

Speaker 23 the road well i'm yeah i'm i hear you i mean believe me i'm a bird lover i don't want to

Speaker 25 kill any birds but it just feels like that little swath i don't think there's a lot because the

Speaker 10 traffic the bird would not endanger their course you don't need to put in that of course they're going to put it in yeah yeah just kind of a sense yeah a deer is not going to you know bet in plain sight of you because it's trying to hide

Speaker 1 exactly all right okay shall we move on to uh bylaws we needed to vent wasn't there one thing that um oh the attendance thing yes all right oh the so i just um so we had had it at three days or 25 and i just thought we could change that would we want to make it six um so right now it's unexcused absence of any member for more than we had three consecutive or 25 percent of total meetings over a period of one term will be cost for consideration

Speaker 14 for removal right but now we're meeting twice a month so that's that's an unexcused so somebody

Speaker 1 calls in and like for example natalie's out with her baby natalie is totally excused yeah so what's jim's excuse i don't know food poisoning oh whoops really so he said

Speaker 6 all right

Speaker 27 but you know we also had consecutive here i think consecutives is important yeah that unexcused

Speaker 3 consecutive

Speaker 28 so do we want to say six or what do we want to say i mean that would be six weeks so that's

Speaker 5 yeah it's pretty significant yes is that too much is that divine no i'm just saying if you

Speaker 26 don't call in i mean but if you're saying we have it i'm just saying we had it at three but when we

Speaker 2 wrote that someone could just miss six meetings before we start out calling in

Speaker 1 or well I think we would we were looking at past behavior where people missed six

Speaker 26 months at a time and we're not removed so it doesn't doesn't that seem like we

Speaker 1 were being that's why we were being lenient though because we're going from

Speaker 2 the no rules to seems like way too lenient with me for me especially if it's you're not like if you can call in then then it doesn't even count can I I

Speaker 5 think when that was coming up we did on purpose because when we were doing bylaws back in whenever 1920 we were meeting every week well this was what we

Speaker 1 wrote after you Deb just to be clear we did when he was chair I was here yeah where on the board wait I don't think yeah you were because I you're not name wasn't on this form oh okay so this was it just I don't know what happened before this before no no no one because I replaced you I replaced you so we were never on the board at the same time so I wrote this up so that means you were not on the board when we did this but it could have been the same rule for all I know maybe so I'm just all I know is what happened when I since I've been on

Speaker 26 the board like some years ago so so if someone calls up this meeting and says

Speaker 2 up I can't come because of blah blah and then the next meeting comes and they they say oh I can't come because of blah blah and then that keeps going on but meanwhile nothing's been triggered because they're calling in and giving an excuse then why should this with no excuses be so lenient if you can't pick up the phone and say I'm sorry I can't come this evening no that's what was happening I think

Speaker 5 yeah people are just not showing that's that's I think so you're giving them six weeks that's what I'm saying which I do we I just I'm just throwing that out

Speaker 1 there it was just because it was three we had done three minus you two the three of us and whoever else was on the board then heads on three and that would have been three months so yeah so now I just had in my head I left it blank so we can figure it out but in my head I just doubled it because we don't

Speaker 15 have all our meetings but I'm open to whatever I I just I mean it just seems to

Speaker 2 me like when you're talking about someone who's not even calling in that means that they're not they're not doing their job and so why can they also I

Speaker 1 think we have a stronger board than two years ago when we wrote this we were lucky at the time to get what we got you know I think we're stronger now we can make a stricter rule do you know what I'm saying call in call go right here text me let me know that you're not gonna or you call in and be on the phone you can you can email me telephone me text me I'll give you all my information or if you cannot be in a meeting but like physically be here but you want to still participate like Natalie did once because she's sick and didn't want to get us all sick we remember we took the phone and we put it here the tip of the town telephone if you want to participate that way you can I've done

Speaker 6 that I don't know I think you did when I was in California take care of Caitlin

Speaker 1 yeah I don't know I just so what does everybody else think what show are you

Speaker 2 looking maybe we keep it at three that's three yeah that's three times of just blowing it off

Speaker 29 like just not what's an excuse to absolutely have a thing that we you know

Speaker 6 we yeah then we get into the light delegate my homework yeah you know any

Speaker 30 excuse is like Jim has food poisoning so but so you I don't think you can

Speaker 2 legislate that I mean yes you're right you know people can play games and you know but I don't I don't you know people are adults and they've been appointed to this board and you know they're gonna call up and make stupid excuses then you probably just have to accept it that they're calling up and making stupid excuses.

Speaker 1 Yeah, I mean, I don't foresee that on the current board, but we just need to cover our bases in case we have different members added in.

Speaker 6 So why don't we just keep it what it was, which is three.

Speaker 3 Three consecutive and six a year. DEP wanted two, DEP was happy with two.

Speaker 5 I don't think it should be consecutive. I think three in the course of a year.

Speaker 1 Unexcused, okay. Yes, I agree with that. We had that or 25% of total meetings. Total meetings. I forget how we did the math there because I'm not a math person.

Speaker 5 That's a tough one because meetings are gonna vary as we get busier. Right, that's right.

Speaker 1 Well considering.

Speaker 5 25% based on an average of how many meetings per year.

Speaker 1 Considering it's now June, the end of June, so we're talking July till next March before this gets redone. Do you think we're gonna still be meeting twice a month? Or we can just get rid of the percentage. I can't remember why we did. Do you remember why we did percentage?

Speaker 3 I don't know, that's 104, 25% of 104 meetings.

Speaker 1 I don't know, really Aldi? Let's just get rid of the percentage maybe. Yeah. I think that's a good idea. And let's get rid of consecutive also. Yeah.

Speaker 30 24.

Speaker 6 Wow. So unexcused absence of any member.

Speaker 1 So we're just gonna simplify to unexcused absence. Do we want to say two or three unexcused?

Speaker 2 This is now in a year?

Speaker 1 Yes, in one term, so yes.

Speaker 5 Well, I mean I can go for three, I don't. Yeah, I'd do three as long as we get that consecutive out of there.

Speaker 11 Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 10 Should we be required to watch the video when they're not there?

Speaker 5 I think if somebody's home, say, you know, sorry, it sprained my ankle, I literally cannot get in my car and drive home.

Speaker 1 Right, that's true.

Speaker 5 You should call in.

Speaker 1 Yes, call in. Yeah.

Speaker 5 Food poisoning, you can't. No. I get it. Baby. You got a baby, I get it. Baby, no. Yeah. Right. You know, you got called away, family matters. Right. There's things that we're all gonna have to face with. Exactly. And you know, the unexcused portion. You got a closing, you know, sometimes you can't control certain things.

Speaker 1 Would that be considered an excused or unexcused absence? That would be an excused because I would call you up

Speaker 2 and say I'm sorry, I can't be here.

Speaker 1 Okay, then why were you defining unexcused versus, because we had, it was just sickness of a direct family member issue. Either being sick or direct family.

Speaker 2 So you're getting all into this stuff where you're talking, I mean, people are adults. I'm just saying what we said before. No, I know. We made this. I'm just saying that people are adults. Right. And they have to be, they have to act like adults and they have to be treated like adults. How's the rest of it say? I wanna just.

Speaker 1 Okay, so right now we have unexcused absences of any member for more than three total meetings over a period of one year term will be caused for consideration for removal from the planning commission.

Speaker 5 Review, review for like it. Where's review? Consideration for removal, I'd say.

Speaker 6 Or consideration for review.

Speaker 5 Yeah, or their participation would be reviewed.

Speaker 1 Okay, at the discretion of the chair and voted by the majority of the board, such affirmative vote for removal shall be advanced to the select board immediately requesting the appropriate measures be taken. I mean, I don't foresee this being a problem anyway for us.

Speaker 5 No, but it has been in the past.

Speaker 1 Right, that's why we have this. Yes, yes. Right.

Speaker 5 I mean, we had, I think, two people I can think of

Speaker 2 that would just not show us.

Speaker 1 Never come. Never come.

Speaker 2 They're just basically taking up a spot on the board and not, so that no one else could get on. Right. And not showing up.

Speaker 1 So this sets us up to be able to then recommend to the select board that they,

Speaker 6 be removed from our board which i think is good because i think we have to come up with that

Speaker 7 strong response to inspire the select board and if everyone has signed on to it that they

Speaker 1 understand that right all right so i'll retype this up with our changes then okay good all right bylaws right okay i'm just needed to face people come i didn't know those three people's names and i just have a piece of paper ready so that's in case somebody shows up that you don't

Speaker 5 know okay so are we still on roads where would you guys like i think um i was thinking perhaps

Speaker 1 we could look at setbacks would be a good place to start which i have opinions on oh good okay setbacks i feel like we just need to land on one thing and kind of work it yeah

Speaker 3 yeah

Speaker 5 facts are pretty much in the dimensional standards so in each of those you will see like minimum side yards road frontage all right that's that's what's considered so i think um if i can start yeah talking about private private roads which i think are the most i think we need to focus on the most because right now and i keep thinking about what what the problem is is that we have a lot of these unprotected these thin lots we have no way to protect other people's property and and i'm not saying that just because it's you guys but you know you've got trees that can you know you can damage other people's trees or whatever and that is personal property you own those trees i've read other bylaws many of which are really really light but they're Personally, I think a private road has a kind of overall, this seems to be in small towns similar in size to ours, is ten feet. For a private road, they consider, they require you to do a private road for two or more homes.

Speaker 1 Ten feet for what?

Speaker 5 Driveway setback from the edge of the other person's property. Some had 25. I would advocate for 25. Me too. Because you're going to kill trees at ten feet. I would agree. I think driveways and private roads should be 25 feet.

Speaker 2 And that gives you enough for most trees that you're going to be able to preserve them. I mean, yeah, you are going to do some damage for some of the biggest, oldest trees, but you probably aren't going to kill it.

Speaker 5 You're not going to kill it.

Speaker 2 Exactly.

Speaker 9 You're going to give the fringe roots on it.

Speaker 2 Basically, in general, the roots typically go out around as far as the canopy. As far as the canopy, yeah.

Speaker 1 Okay, so I'm looking back at old notes. Let me see. Does this have to do with what we're saying? Sorry, I'm not sure. At least 25, this is a change that was the old Planning Commission, said at least 25 feet with a 20-foot setback from the side property line and approved by the Planning Commission. And that was changed from 20 feet to 25 feet. This is 7.2.1. Is that the same thing? Did you see that you guys had looked at changing it before?

Speaker 6 Yeah, it was 20 feet, and we're saying 25. Okay, so this is 20 feet in here?

Speaker 1 Yeah. So the older Planning Commission, whoever did this, I think Deb's group, wanted to change it to 25. All right, so let's, I don't know, starve that. All right, I'll put it in here.

Speaker 5 Well, this is 20, this isn't talking about a setback.

Speaker 1 It's not? No. Is it?

Speaker 5 No. It's talking about the width of the road. It's not talking about a setback. Setbacks would be, we don't have any, we have no right now for setbacks. We don't have any at all? A road, driveways, nothing, zero.

Speaker 1 Okay, so table this question.

Speaker 5 Yeah, this 7.2 is the width of the road. The width of the road.

Speaker 14 Yeah.

Speaker 6 Okay, so where in the bylaws would that, like where, is there a setback section?

Speaker 5 No, there are dimensional standards.

Speaker 18 But not for the road, right?

Speaker 5 They're not for the road. Or driveway. We would have to somehow insert it in here as probably, I mean, it would be under Section 7, I would think, general regulations. And you would talk about roads there.

Speaker 1 Roads. Separate roads and driveways.

Speaker 5 Yes, and here's why I think we should. A road is totally different from a driveway. A driveway, private property all the way.

Speaker 6 Also, it doesn't have to be wide enough for a fire truck. It doesn't have to bypass. It doesn't have to be. We're not talking about the width of it.

Speaker 7 We're talking about the setback.

Speaker 5 Well. Right? Well, right. But are we, so if we're talking about a setback. Are you talking about a driveway setback and a private road setback? Are we, are the two, because most.

Speaker 1 That's what I'm saying. Are we doing them separately or together?

Speaker 5 Then we, if we're talking about protecting, like, route structures, then we should keep it. Agreed.

Speaker 2 Yeah, because why, what difference would it make? Why, why, why would you make one 25 feet and one something different? Right.

Speaker 1 I just don't know if we're going to list them separately. Do you know what I mean? Like, are we going to do a driveway section and then a private road section?

Speaker 4 Then they will be the same.

Speaker 1 But, but the same thing.

Speaker 5 Yep. A driveway will serve one or two.

Speaker 6 Yeah. One or two homes.

Speaker 5 What, what does a driveway? This was one of our things. We did driveway. One or two homes on the same parcel. So.

Speaker 14 Okay.

Speaker 5 Once you separate those parcels and deed them separately, that becomes a private road.

Speaker 1 Okay. We did this whole, this already in February. So, right, right of way, a driveway serves one parcel, which can have an ADU. Mm-hmm. Right of way serves a second lot passed through as if public land. These are my notes, sorry. Road serves more. We will call it a private road as opposed to a private way to avoid confusion with right of way. And Jim had said a private road is a privately owned driveway, lane. So he has driveway there. Privately owned driveway, lane, access way, or similar parcel of land that serves as access from privately, private property to a public road. Take out driveway. So we wanted to take the word driveway out of that. Did that make sense? I'm just reading our notes. I don't know if that made sense.

Speaker 5 I, I don't know. I, I think it's pretty, pretty common sense what the difference between them that I, that, that seems very provost.

Speaker 1 Right. We just didn't define driveway. I guess that was the problem.

Speaker 2 So the, the definition of a driveway is that it serves one or two homes. Right. One. One parcel. On a parcel.

Speaker 9 On one parcel.

Speaker 5 One parcel. Which can have an ADU. So it could be.

Speaker 2 Yeah. So it could be one or two homes because the second would be the ADU. The ADU.

Speaker 5 The, the bylaws that I read are pretty, pretty clear about that. Once you add that third. It becomes private. It becomes a private road because you can only have one ADU on a.

Speaker 6 On a parcel. Mm-hmm.

Speaker 5 So you add a third. You've got to deed it out somehow. So that has to be a private road. And what I'm seeing a lot in, in bylaws for other towns is that they're not going to have a road that's private. And so that's what I'm seeing in bylaws for other towns is that they definitely are requiring that any private road has to be bypassable for emergency. Okay. And brought up to almost standard, standard of a, of a regular road.

Speaker 2 Okay. So. And.

Speaker 16 And.

Speaker 5 Yeah.

Speaker 2 Agreements. Right. Okay. But so. In perpetuity. Let's, let's. I mean what happens. Let's go back to what we were talking about earlier. The farmer. wants to have three homes on his property for his family members why does the farmer have to have a road that's brought up to town standards for the

Speaker 31 boy I'm just telling you yeah but so what so what it's still not it's not a

Speaker 2 town road again so that's putting that is putting an extreme expense on someone and I don't see for what good reason you would do that to get a fire truck up

Speaker 23 there yeah be able to turn around no no no

Speaker 2 no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no

Speaker 30 so otherwise how do you get fire insurance fire truck can still get up

Speaker 2 there it does not have to be brought up to road our firemen go up and do stuff in the woods you cannot legitimately say that basically oh because a fire truck might have to drive up there someday it has to be up you can't I'll stand more

Speaker 5 than according to the state you can't put more than 180 you on a parcel so you are saying that and I agree with you I'm just saying we have to comply with the state you can't do it you cannot put a third home on your property you can't you have to you have to you have to which is then a planned unit development which then

Speaker 2 would require okay but forgive me forgive me because I don't know I'm gonna I'm gonna use that for a long time I'm new but did we not in our old zoning laws and act this thing like this compound thing where people could make

Speaker 16 compounds we never get that you can't do compounds if they wanted to but the

Speaker 2 state doesn't know so that just negates the whole argument against this 181 in the road rule where farmer the whole argument is is that farmers only own 300 acres they want to put multiple homes on this for their family members they're creating a compound and now and you're telling me that the states just like yeah no we don't we don't like that so no and and we're gonna make your road

Speaker 16 cost you a bazillion dollars well even wrong but I'm pretty if people are

Speaker 6 building three homes for their kids that is that is one moment in time right I mean all all Deb is saying is that they're they're requiring that that be a separate parcel you could still do it

Speaker 5 it's a look I'm sorry to keep bringing up your neighbors they had to parcel it out they actually put in a private road they put in a private road they had to

Speaker 9 parcel out so does that road so you have a skinny strip of land and it's only got

Speaker 2 so much frontage how much frontage I think it was 372 feet of frontage what what is our what is our frontage what is our frontage what is our frontage what is our frontage requirement for a lot

Speaker 10 if a lot of frontage 150 150 and that is for that's for residential it's different

Speaker 2 so basically they came to the Planning Commission or they came to the ZBA 150 for all three so so so basically they came to the Planning Commission or they came to the ZBA 150 they had 272 feet of frontage they needed 300 so no they need 150 well they need 150 well if they're gonna make two lots the lots are in tandem

Speaker 10 only on the road they need 150 oh but because they made their own

Speaker 2 private road right yeah so then now they do have road frontage along your own private road because it's long

Speaker 6 problematic yes

Speaker 25 this was our case test

Speaker 10 this was our case test

Speaker 5 And that's, I mean, I don't think they can do more because it really droughts out at some point. But I mean there are parcels out there that you could conceivably put in.

Speaker 10 Yeah, a big flat area.

Speaker 5 Big flat area. Put a road.

Speaker 2 I mean you look at my property. Yeah. I mean I could basically put a road down my property and then probably go north with it and just be like boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom. You'd have your own sewer district. But see, I can see though, I can see where when you're doing that that maybe it makes sense to have up to road standards because they're using it as road front.

Speaker 10 It used to be in the bylaws that it had to be the road standards that were put in. It used to be in the private road but they took it out.

Speaker 2 I don't know. It's weird because I have a visceral, you know, rejection of what I look at as the big farmer's field with him putting up, you know, multiple families and making a compound for and then I see that as different than somebody who's going to be like put in the road and then just start slapping them up.

Speaker 10 You don't go over that. You don't go over that.

Speaker 31 You don't go over that.

Speaker 5 They have to have two acres a piece and they have to comply with the setbacks. So my thought is always just do and maybe I'm contradicting myself. I don't know. Maybe. Call me out on it. I agree with but I always look to the future. You always want to think about what you're doing for the next person. Joe Farmer passes on. Nobody else can. Nobody else can afford it. If Joe Farmer had set up his compound properly, they could be portioned off but if Joe Farmer put his houses right all next to each other for his family, you blow the setbacks. So each house has to be able to contain itself. Self-contained. Yes. My opinion.

Speaker 1 Yes. I agree.

Speaker 5 And that's a planned unit development and that would have to go. You can't just keep adding houses without, that's why the state said more than two. Because.

Speaker 10 It works today but a hundred years from now it ain't going to work is all we have.

Speaker 5 It's not going to work and is it fair for the people that now want to sell and oh my god I can't sell because now this whole thing is a non-conforming lot. Yes. It's a hundred acres of non-conforming block and I can't sell it because the house is not conformed. You know we are all on the same septic. Right. We all have seventeen kids on the same septic.

Speaker 10 And potentially an ADU. Somebody will use it. Right.

Speaker 5 But getting back to our argument from the beginning that is essentially what. So are we, I'm, that's what I said I read it and I didn't see the outrage that came out of it. I don't know. Yes hands off my land but I'm still going to comply with the regulations. And I have a very big parcel most of it's not buildable but I could easily put up there. And we're up high enough that the water is pure and beautiful. I mean and probably someday there will be. Yep.

Speaker 2 You know. I mean the road, the infrastructure is already there. Okay so we're back to. We're back to. Are we going to force people if they put a road in we're going to force them to bring it up to town standards.

Speaker 5 Not necessarily. I'm saying there are some other towns that do that. Not necessarily town standards like not the perfect crown in the middle and ditching along the side but accessible for. Emergency. Emergency.

Speaker 10 If you put in a minimum requirement that they get up is what. That's reasonable.

Speaker 5 And that's where we got down to that 7.2. You know 20 foot wide. Right. Road. That's wide. 20 foot? 20 foot.

Speaker 5 Not really. I don't think it's terribly wide when you've got two trucks passing with their mirrors out.

Speaker 10 My truck's 20 foot long so if I parked it like that I got the whole road blocked off. In advance. Right?

Speaker 32 Well that's a road on a driveway.

Speaker 10 I know.

Speaker 5 I mean how. How do you. How wide is Mill Road? Probably not much more than 20 feet. Le Chouard? Boy it's sometimes.

Speaker 10 Yours might be wider.

Speaker 5 I think.

Speaker 10 Nah. Not really. No? Maybe the tar road. They lined it up with tar.

Speaker 6 Oh yeah. How's that going?

Speaker 10 Have they done that? Did they? Oh yeah. It's all. Oh the hill's awful. They did the hill first and now they're doing Jepson. It's almost. One day they'll probably have it. One day. Probably once they've had it all.

Speaker 10 So is that where it got all sloppy? No. Is that what they tarred? Or no? No.

Speaker 10 Oh yeah. Oh yeah. They got it all.

Speaker 1 So Deb I have your note from way back when. Did you want to expound on what you meant there?

Speaker 10 I have lots of notes down. Reba?

Speaker 2 What Pam? You look perplexed. You look pained. No. I'm just trying to figure out. I mean obviously I'm most concerned about the setback. Um the the the setback and making sure that we get a good setback so people can not. Mm hm. Kill people's trees. Yes.

Speaker 26 Um.

Speaker 1 That's the first step. Yeah.

Speaker 2 But I, but I, again, I, I do want to, so then I do want, I do want to not, I don't, I mean, I just think we should always keep in mind, you know, that we shouldn't, we shouldn't create regulations that add on, bless you, that add on enormous amount of cost to people unless there's a good reason for doing that.

Speaker 6 Right. Yeah. Um, okay. So it sounds like we're, where we're heading with this is that we don't need private roads to be up to these massive standards. So we're deciding that private roads can exist. And what we're also trying to decide is what is the setback for private roads? Are we 25 feet? I think, I think it should be, I would advocate for 25.

Speaker 2 I will tell you that Dave Tatro is, he's against this thing completely. He told me that he, he's pieces of land and sometimes right up against the property line is the only place it can be. And, you know, my, my answer to that is, oh, well, well, I mean, there's a certain, there's a certain, uh, yeah, there's a certain reality to, oh, well.

Speaker 10 If I buy a piece of land and it's on top of a ledge. Right. Exactly.

Speaker 2 When you go look at a piece of land, you look to be, you look, where's the land? Where's the driveway going to be? And like, if you realize, like, I mean, I'm thinking of one particular on Mill Road there, like, man, there's no place for a driveway. Exactly. There's no place for a driveway. Yeah. Just look at it.

Speaker 6 Yeah. That's true. There are certain, and I remember in one of the sort of historic reports, town reports that you brought in, I remember seeing, you know, uh, from Maura, I guess it's like, no, sorry, this lot isn't buildable because it's not perking. There's no. Yes. All the time. So I think the oh well factor is real and it's, it's due diligence on the part of the buyer of a piece of land if they have a fantasy, right, about I'm going to build my dream house here to do their research. Right. Yeah. And that's one of the reasons to make the bylaws really readable and really digestible. Right. Because. Readable and clear.

Speaker 18 Very clear.

Speaker 6 Readable and clear. And, and, you know.

Speaker 5 You almost want to. I hate to say it, but you, you almost want explanations embedded in. Agreed. A lot of, a lot of these little subsections.

Speaker 10 Agreed. Well, it's like setbacks. You'll have a setback with something, but it doesn't tell you the setback right there. Say a setback for a barn. It doesn't say barn and the setback is say 25 feet. There's a lot of places where it says it requires a setback, but then you gotta go fishing to find out what the setback is. Yeah. What is the setback? Yeah. Should be together. Should be in a fireplace. Yeah. And that's a fireplace. Yeah. Open, uh. Fire pit. Fire pit. So there's a setback for it. Right.

Speaker 2 So what's a setback?

Speaker 15 Right.

Speaker 1 You gotta go search it for yourself. You have to know what means that.

Speaker 2 Yeah. I think that, I think that it would be good for, you know, like people like yourself, um, um, to read these, these bylaws and really be able to point this stuff out. I mean, I just look at them and I'm just like, ah.

Speaker 6 Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 2 These just do not. Yeah. They're not, they don't read well at all.

Speaker 6 Agreed. Agreed.

Speaker 2 Um, there has to be a way to make them more digestible. You gotta read the rules.

Speaker 6 Also Rochester. Rochester. Rochester is also one in which part of what happens as they're going through in terms of letting you know when you have to get something, you know, approved or permitted or not permitted, um, all of that, is it keeps, it keeps. It keeps referring to this is the town law, but there is also a state requirement. And therefore, you know, this is not, you know, what I'm saying in this sentence, you know.

Speaker 14 Is because of.

Speaker 6 Is because of something else and it being okay on this level doesn't necessarily mean it's okay on this level. Wow. So it's, it's really a sequential, um, reminder again and again. Right. That is not apparent in these.

Speaker 2 So, so I love that. That sounds great. The, the, the issue that I can see with it though is if the state, if first of all our bylaws in theory, once we write them, shouldn't be changing all the time, but also this, but also the state laws can change. So I, I guess I would be concerned about who's gonna make sure that once it gets, once our bylaws and. And, and those explanations get set up, who's gonna make sure that that's kept up to date? Do we have the ability to do that? Us. I think the planning commission. Yes. The planning commission. That's a good job. Do we have, I mean, is that.

Speaker 1 Pretty, pretty. That's why we keep up with BCRC and keep up on the new laws. There's an advocacy chat every once a month that I do that always talks about the law changes. So. Like the 12 chickens.

Speaker 6 Great to know.

Speaker 3 Gotta know these chickens. So how does right of way fit into all this?

Speaker 5 Oh, I, I know all about right of way.

Speaker 18 Tell.

Speaker 19 Yeah.

Speaker 32 Somebody does.

Speaker 5 Well.

Speaker 33 An expert.

Speaker 10 I'm new.

Speaker 5 A right, a right of way. So no, no parcel can be landlocked. Correct. That's a law. Correct. So if a, if a parcel is quote unquote landlocked, you have to have a deed of right of way over another parcel to get to yours. That is deeded. You. It is owned by you even though it's owned. So it's. It's on both. It's utilized. It's on both. It's on both deeds. Yes.

Speaker 1 Should we define right of way? I'm just saying in the definitions.

Speaker 5 Should we?

Speaker 1 Yes.

Speaker 28 Sure.

Speaker 1 Okay. I know it's not there. No.

Speaker 5 No, it's, it's not defined, but we probably should. Okay. We should define right of way roads and. Private road. Private. Right of way driveway and private road. Yeah. Right of way. Private road. Yeah. Okay. Yep. But it's just. Okay.

Speaker 3 Well, that would take some of the computer.

Speaker 5 And the right of way can be, as opposed to an easement, an easement is more like you. Where's the right of way.

Speaker 3 I always thought the right of way.

Speaker 5 No, no. I mean, they're similar. They are deeded.

Speaker 6 And does the person who is looking to unlock their landlocked land compensate the. Nope. It just becomes an agreed upon, and is there a determination, who determines where the access is going to go through someone's land for someone to unlock.

Speaker 5 I don't know of any recent, I mean, these are old, old parcels. Mm-hmm. That are up in a lot of camps. Mm-hmm. The only way you can get to it is.

Speaker 10 Stagecoach, road, and partly a builder's private land in the middle of national forests.

Speaker 22 Oh.

Speaker 10 They have. Yeah. They have to have.

Speaker 33 They have to have right of way over the national forest.

Speaker 10 Yeah. Yeah. They have to have. Mm-hmm. They can come out for the national forest.

Speaker 5 A right of way is usually, it has an end point. Mm-hmm. Whereas an easement is more of a. Passing through. Yeah. Like power lines and stuff. Uh-huh. Okay. Like our back of our property has an easement going through for the power lines. It's not a right of way, it's just an easement. Everybody has.

Speaker 3 Access. Yeah.

Speaker 6 Okay. Yeah. So, we want to.

Speaker 3 So, we want to make definitions for all those? Yes.

Speaker 27 We want to define those.

Speaker 1 So, all I have for driveway is serves one parcel, but what serves one parcel? I just need another word there.

Speaker 2 Driveway serves one or two homes on one parcel?

Speaker 15 One parcel.

Speaker 1 Yeah. But it can be an ADU.

Speaker 3 Well, a second home's got to be an ADU, right?

Speaker 19 Yep.

Speaker 5 So, do you, like, do you mean like a gravel surface or is that what you're asking?

Speaker 1 Well, it's just. I'm saying, um, just saying serves one parcel. I feel like it needs, yeah, something like that. So, what your team did, a minor private travel way serving up to three parcels. I don't know why it's had that. Which proves vehicular access from an adjoining road to a parking space, garage or other structure. I don't know why you guys said that. That's what was said. I, I don't, that's. I don't think that's what we're trying to get at now.

Speaker 28 But travel way, that's what I'm looking for.

Speaker 5 Is that the highlighted? Yes. I don't think that was adopted.

Speaker 1 No, none of these were adopted.

Speaker 5 Oh.

Speaker 1 These were the changes suggested in 2023. What I was looking for was travel way for driveway. I think I was looking for a now.

Speaker 6 I honestly don't think we need to come up with another word for driveway. We need a new one.

Speaker 10 It's just another term. I can't wait to say driveway.

Speaker 6 Just say a driveway serves one parcel. Yeah. A driveway serves one parcel containing. No.

Speaker 5 A driveway doesn't have to have any. A parcel doesn't have to have anything on it to have a driveway.

Speaker 6 But don't we need to say not more than two?

Speaker 5 Well, yeah. That goes with parcel, though, right?

Speaker 1 That should be understood from the word parcel. Because you're only allowed one. You're only allowed one home per parcel except for the ADU.

Speaker 3 Which means a definition for parcel.

Speaker 6 So, okay. But if I were someone moving to this state. I know what you're saying. If I were someone moving to this state, how would I know that a parcel only means a dwelling and an ADU? How would I know that? You can't just assume that parcel means that. So why not say that it leads to with not more than.

Speaker 1 With a, I mean. It's being redundant, but I'm okay with that.

Speaker 10 Yeah, expand the explanation.

Speaker 1 Just, do we want to do that? Yeah, just because. So, serving, serves one parcel which may contain, or what were we saying?

Speaker 5 Which can contain no more than two homes. Do we need to specify that one's an ADU? Yeah, one home and an ADU. Then, yeah. Thank you.

Speaker 1 So, does it say home or residence? Dwelling. Dwelling, thank you. I knew that we needed a different word there.

Speaker 6 One ADU. Boom. Great.

Speaker 1 Okay, so now on. Okay, private road. Onward and upward. Private.

Speaker 2 Road.

Speaker 6 And, given what you were just saying about adding things right away, do we want to put the setback on the driveway? Now that we've just said let's combine these things, so let's go back. We don't have that anywhere. Where were we going to put that? In the table, or no? Go back to the definition. Why not include the setback with the definition?

Speaker 10 Yeah, that's, well, the set. Because otherwise you're looking for it.

Speaker 6 Otherwise you have to look at another section. They assume they can put it anywhere. Oh, the only thing about.

Speaker 5 We can add to the dimensional standards.

Speaker 6 Right, that's what I mean.

Speaker 5 And then put in setback for driveway, 25 feet side yard.

Speaker 6 But what's the objection to having it right away?

Speaker 5 No, I agree. Yeah, it should be in more than one spot.

Speaker 1 It should be in more than one place. But I don't think it belongs in the definition. I don't know.

Speaker 3 The setback is from the row.

Speaker 1 If you open up a dictionary. Because all of these things need setback, so we can't put the setback on every single definition.

Speaker 2 That's the problem with this, is that it sounds good to add this stuff, but it could be just like this never-ending thing.

Speaker 1 Yes, a restaurant, 25, you know, and how many feet back and how many.

Speaker 2 Right, so that's the problem with adding this extra stuff, because it just could become unbelievably burdensome. And then it would just be ridiculous.

Speaker 6 Okay, does that make sense? I take your point, yeah.

Speaker 10 So the 25-foot setback, the row can't be started until it's beyond the 25 feet. It's not, like the town row, people, you know, when they talk about the town setback right away, it goes from the center of the row. See, people might think that you're thinking for the center. You might want to. Explain this, look. The row starts 25 feet from the edge of the property. I hear what you're saying. Right. It's from the middle of the row.

Speaker 2 So that is, I mean, that's just a road thing. That's just a road thing that they do that. What? From the center of the road.

Speaker 34 So for driveway.

Speaker 10 From the center of the road. You might want to say the road.

Speaker 34 So you've got it.

Speaker 2 So you either have to do it. You either have to say that. It's a 20-foot road with a 35-foot setback from the center of the road.

Speaker 34 Or you have to say it's 25 feet from the edge of the road.

Speaker 10 Right. I mean, from 25 feet from the boundary out, you start a row.

Speaker 6 I'm in favor of edge to boundary. Because. Well. Finding the center of a dirt road.

Speaker 2 Well, that's what Clark says all the time. He's like, all these things that you measure, he's like, where is the center of the road? Exactly.

Speaker 30 First of all, it moves all the time.

Speaker 6 Exactly. It's wider in some place. Right. That's right. So I would say you can't start a row. 25 feet. Right.

Speaker 10 You can't start a row 25 feet from the edge of the property.

Speaker 6 I think that that is a better, clearer description.

Speaker 7 From edge of the, from property line?

Speaker 1 Right over there.

Speaker 8 From property line to the edge of the road.

Speaker 1 Right. Makes sense. What about the setback from the paved road?

Speaker 3 The dirt road.

Speaker 10 Well, those are from the center. They're from the center. Yeah, the line rows are from the center. 25, how do you say, 49.5 over there.

Speaker 11 This is driveway, right?

Speaker 6 This is driveway.

Speaker 10 So. Right, it's 49.5 over there.

Speaker 6 And it would be the same, right, for a private road?

Speaker 3 The setback would be the same.

Speaker 1 Yeah. The setback on the side, right? Yeah. Yeah. Okay. But do we want a width for the private road still, though? It doesn't matter. For the passable vehicles? It doesn't matter.

Speaker 10 It doesn't matter because they can't build it for the 25 feet.

Speaker 1 No, but the width of the action.

Speaker 2 Yes. Yeah, are you going to basically, again, we go back to this. Is it, are we going to require that somebody make a 20-foot road?

Speaker 15 That's not that, I don't think that's why, that extraordinary.

Speaker 2 I don't know. I'd have to go out and measure mine. I feel like 20, I feel like 20 feet is wide because my garage door, my garage door is 90 feet where I drive my car, until, I mean, there's like this much space, at least, on both sides of my car. I've got a little dinky car. I know, that's true. You don't drive on roads when they're turning up. I know, but it's not a road. It's a trailer. But it's not a road. It's a driveway. Not on a, no, private road is not, it's a road. Private road is a road.

Speaker 5 So, so. So if you have cars, see, so you have five homes on the road.

Speaker 2 Yeah, no. You wouldn't even have backed up the whole way. No, no, no, I hear you. So, but, so, is the driveway also 20 feet wide?

Speaker 5 I think it should be, but that's, if you are doing a private road, you should have that.

Speaker 2 But what if I'm doing a driveway to my house? I guarantee you my driveway is nowhere near 20 feet wide. It's your own personal thing. That's what I'm saying.

Speaker 5 It's not a private road. We're talking about private roads.

Speaker 10 You have a driveway. She's talking about this. Okay, I'm just, that's what I'm asking.

Speaker 5 Are we, are we going to have requirements for driveways? Yes. No, I don't think we have to regulate driveway widths. I don't either.

Speaker 18 I mean, my driveway is probably 10 feet.

Speaker 6 Yeah, if that.

Speaker 18 You can drive over your lawn. Yeah, you can park on your lawn.

Speaker 10 You don't have to have a driveway. I mean, you're assuming everyone has a car. Maybe they have motorcycles. Yeah. Or a horse. Or a horse.

Speaker 6 Okay, so. Well, our posted.

Speaker 5 Can I ask a question? Do you have the, do you have your bylaws? Yeah. Just go to any of the dimensional standards. I don't know why I'm, I'm feeling really stupid about this. Where are they? Oh, they're any of the, any of the grids.

Speaker 6 Just start.

Speaker 2 Why does Marta's bylaws, why does her bylaws have like maps and mine don't have any maps?

Speaker 21 That would be the back for.

Speaker 3 That would be the back for me, yeah.

Speaker 2 The back should, what should I have? Maps and maps.

Speaker 9 No, I have no maps. Hmm.

Speaker 3 Not for me either. There you go. Oh, here we go.

Speaker 5 Okay, down at the bottom where it says. Page 10. For everybody. Minimum frontage on public or private street.

Speaker 6 Minimum frontage on public or private street, yes. Yes.

Speaker 5 150 feet across.

Speaker 6 Mm-hmm.

Speaker 14 That's not page 10.

Speaker 5 By a right of way of at least 25 feet.

Speaker 6 What does that mean? I don't know.

Speaker 5 That's, I just read this. I'm going, why is that? Why haven't I seen this before? Where are you reading? Page 10. Page 10. Any of the pages. 4.4. 4.4, okay. Down at the minimum. Page 10. What does that mean?

Speaker 6 That's so funny. I have no idea. Because you know what? In my previous reading of this, I had flagged, pointed, and had the same question.

Speaker 5 What does that mean? I get it, 150. The lot has to be at least 150 feet, but what does that 25 feet mean?

Speaker 10 I should know. You probably need a lawyer for that.

Speaker 6 Does this, do you think this has something to do?

Speaker 3 With setbacks.

Speaker 5 That's what I'm wondering.

Speaker 10 Are you reading a state thing?

Speaker 5 Well, that doesn't make any sense. No, because if it was a setback, it would say setback. Exactly, but what, by a right of way, and how are we defining right of way?

Speaker 10 You're going to get to that. Of at least. Oh, oh, oh, yeah. If you have a piece of property. It's the landlocked issue. Right, if you have a piece of property, you're going to get the landlocked issue. If you're selling land, and you want to sell land behind your land, you'll have to give them 25 foot strip to get into that landlord's landline. So they have to have a 25 foot... Okay, that should be explained better. Agreed. Yes. Okay. Yeah, it catches you at first going, what?

Speaker 1 Okay.

Speaker 28 I get it.

Speaker 1 Yep. Do we need to change anything there then?

Speaker 5 No. I get it now. I just, like I said, I read this all the time and I just looked at it and I'm like, wow, what's that mean?

Speaker 10 It allows you to sell the land behind you as long as you give them 25 feet of right

Speaker 5 So we had that question earlier, how wide does a right of way have to be? Now there's... There it is. 25 feet wide. 25 feet wide.

Speaker 6 Okay, good. But someone previously noted that 150 feet is a smaller amount than what it used to be.

Speaker 10 It used to be 200 up there.

Speaker 5 Are there any lots that are... Smaller. Smaller than 200? Smaller than 200? No. Are there any lots?

Speaker 5 I mean, maybe in the village.

Speaker 10 Yeah, in the village.

Speaker 5 But I think rural and residential. Okay.

Speaker 10 I don't think there's anything... Because most of the lots sold on my road at the time they were developed was 200. So this is 40 years later. Okay. So now somebody owns a 300-foot wide lot, if you split it up the middle, they get your 150 feet. Ooh. But... Twist them down. Twist them down. And I found this on the side. K-1-2. No. Think about it. ...could not make that. So that's why they go up the edge of the property and build off of it. So... And stack them. Oh, boy.

Speaker 2 So if I don't have my map. But since... Do we ever talk about the actual zoning districts and what they are now compared to what they were before, and do we want to make changes in the zoning districts? Do we want to add different districts?

Speaker 1 Do you want to talk about the zoning districts, and I'm not sure if they're effective or not?

Speaker 15 about adding a village district we didn't see the point see I seem to

Speaker 2 remember years ago I felt like there was a big difference between the Forest District and we used to have conditional use and I feel like I feel like the whole the Forest District got really relaxed yes why but why would that why would you do that the whole point of the Forest District was to protect to protect the forest and the watershed right and for what it is I don't know

Speaker 5 why it changed

Speaker 2 right right so let's change it back well I'm not even saying that but but but and I think it's hard for us to sit here talking about setbacks when we're talking about setbacks when we're talking about setbacks when we're talking about setbacks when we're talking about setbacks when we're talking about setbacks when we really haven't actually looked at the big thing the the map the map the zoning districts and and and say do we like these do we not like

Speaker 10 these are you guys in rural or rural okay about a thousand feet back it goes in the forest that's when you have a property run into a problem because just

Speaker 31 past that dip it goes in the forest yeah I mean I just think it I mean I don't

Speaker 2 see how you can look at the zone and see how you can look at the map and see if zoning bylaws without really looking at the districts and saying is this what we want is this not me we need to start we're right now we're just I mean setbacks are going I think are going to be universal right I don't know maybe the setbacks in the forest district or in the rural district should be larger I don't know because you're trying again because residential right now we're

Speaker 5 almost identical yeah see it's not much yes

Speaker 2 and so that does not make any sense to me something is right so something is not right we just need to we just need to look at this because if you're if you're if your goal let's just say that the goal was to preserve the character of Stamford then you want the zoning laws to have things in place that are not in place so that you're not gonna have up there where he lives a it doesn't preserve the character of all the people who live there and also it's overshadow

Speaker 23 creating all kinds of issues with our water roads sewer and the roads yes so

Speaker 6 so so maybe one thing that we really need to focus on is restructuring

Speaker 30 here I mean here's the map well I mean at least I mean at least looking at let's

Speaker 2 just look at yeah I don't know what it is because I haven't looked at it but I but I just I just have this sense that a long time ago the forest was this protected thing now it's not for some

Speaker 10 yeah exactly

Speaker 2 , I don't know that the bylaws that you sent me do not have that

Speaker 10 you know nobody wants to read but if your likes it too much then you get violations what page does, sorry that map

Speaker 8 this is the very back page

Speaker 35 yeah the very

Speaker 6 the very back page of this other version of the bylaws which is the fatter it's just right before the flood right

Speaker 1 yes okay I have a side question that sorry it's gonna take a little while yeah it's a topic but on these tables are identical mostly except maximum building coverage the residential is 30% and then for rural it's 20% does anybody know why that is um yeah it shouldn't be

Speaker 5 that just seems weird right it does because I don't know if that's an oversight yeah

Speaker 1 did that just get looked over

Speaker 2 it's hard for me to tell on this black and white copy yeah we need a better

Speaker 31 am I having color do you want to see it on my laptop

Speaker 10 it's like that what's the part you might find two little things let me get something else and you eventually yeah well there's that much difference you want it bigger yeah

Speaker 6 well to your guy's point like why is why is it two acres for rural

Speaker 2 screenshot that and send that to me

Speaker 6 which is the same as as the village and the residential

Speaker 10 because somebody changed it I mean

Speaker 5 because it worked for somebody yeah it worked for somebody

Speaker 6 it worked for somebody yeah do we need to go back to

Speaker 10 I would say so greater but then you have to also grandfather anybody that's less done it during the change

Speaker 6 okay so they're grandfathered but it just keeps it from

Speaker 17 right

Speaker 25 getting worse and worse and worse

Speaker 6 I mean rural

Speaker 31 I mean

Speaker 2 so let me just say me too let me just say that we might want to consider waiting until we get the surveys back before we start making changes okay I'm just wondering if the surveys are going to tell us things tell us okay well let's why don't we put okay what

Speaker 6 oh why don't we put for future for future topic for future discussion on five acres for rural district back to five acres for rural

Speaker 1 I think we need to look at the districts again I think we need to review the districts in general but I think Pam's right maybe we wait until the surveys come back

Speaker 8 yeah but I mean this could be a topic for after the surveys come back yes yeah okay

Speaker 6 so maybe I'd be interested I think review the districts yeah

Speaker 36 yeah

Speaker 1 so this and by review the districts what you meant though wait there is for example five you said no you need yeah

Speaker 8 so for example um we forest is five forest is five that would be ten we need to look at all that yeah

Speaker 6 and I think it used to be ten yeah it used to be ten yeah and and when we say review the things we don't have the capability to change what is what we're going to use to review my photos

Speaker 24 ah

Speaker 1 I think we could like Jim Wanda Adam Village we could do that yes thank you

Speaker 6 okay

Speaker 1 we can change the lines okay

Speaker 6 so that's another thing well that's what you mean by review the

Speaker 37 I'll get

Speaker 12 review the

Speaker 6 I will the boundaries the boundaries of the here's what you're talking about yeah so also review the boundaries of sure okay the zoning districts

Speaker 7 it should be

Speaker 1 in your

Speaker 6 I believe that's what they are okay the oh wait Matt what's your you should have your

Speaker 18 email address

Speaker 6 in two thousand one if you see it has to do that

Speaker 3 I'll be Fanny A-L-D-Y

Speaker 6 oh I always wondered if it was an I at the end or a Y

Speaker 5 F-I-N-N-N-Y F-I-N-N-N-Y

Speaker 6 I'll do the store right

Speaker 2 I mean if you just look at this and you look at residential and you look at it being residential all along the main road here mhm but then if you just look at this but then but then you look at for instance let's look at thank you um Fort Jett um and you know where Jen Jen Hughes um yeah whatever that is

Speaker 6 same urge Fort Jett up here um

Speaker 2 you know is is is is that necessarily the same as a long main road I mean it seems like a long main road along the highway especially want to be the same as these other places that are

Speaker 15 well my question

Speaker 1 or Marta and I were talking about is who draws these boundaries for the residential the map says BCRC so is this up to BCRC to draw the boundaries or are you

Speaker 28 you mean as far as forest

Speaker 5 and everything

Speaker 1 residential is that a town thing I mean I think we did I mean I think we did that and that does say BCRC on the bottom

Speaker 26 no but maybe they just did

Speaker 6 it's just printed it up

Speaker 2 of Sumner Hill Road is the end of Sumner Hill Road the same as no right down here in the village I mean I would not say that those two things are I mean they have a great different feel they're a different thing agreed like you're you're doing the town yeah yours yours has a different feel your area has a

Speaker 10 different feel it's complicating this town is 60% is federal that's right so much forest right you're saying well where's the rural it doesn't look like there's a lot of rural because it's mostly forest right right that's not all

Speaker 5 like our property there's a lot of it is in the forest district no no no I'm not saying the Forest Service our property is in the forest district

Speaker 18 I'm here

Speaker 5 I'm here there's Maltese I don't know how they determine the forest

Speaker 18 it says Old County here but it attaches to this because that's sparse so depth is like here

Speaker 5 if you look where the forest starts on my property it's not 2,500 feet yeah so

Speaker 2 how did they determine I think that the planning board is the one who has been

Speaker 15 do you want me to call but here's

Speaker 2 made

Speaker 4 here's my question we see our CNS how big there has to be how did they

Speaker 5 determine that on my property half is in the forest and where is that line and why yeah yeah so a great question because when we were building they tried to stop us oh you guys are building that forest

Speaker 19 no you built that not here

Speaker 5 I said well show me the line yeah there is none like there is no defining boundary because we're at 1790 elevation yeah we're not at 2,500 so how did that make it into the forest

Speaker 10 I think what you said the planning cause the only thing the state had done in 2,500 to preserve the scenic beauty and wouldn't allow you to build a bump

Speaker 33 No I get that but I'm wondering how they drew that line

Speaker 28 Right. I mean, I'm going to call BCRC and ask.

Speaker 27 Somebody must have gone there.

Speaker 5 And I want to, I mean, there's...

Speaker 3 Well, that hill behind your house could be 2,500.

Speaker 5 Oh, that, actually, even to the top of that, I've walked it and I have my compass and everything with me. I look over on Ezra's, so I can get up to that elevation, and that's still not 2,500. Really? 2,500 is really, really high.

Speaker 6 Mine's 1,925.

Speaker 5 Yeah, you're a little, you're...

Speaker 6 Right, and you're slightly uphill from me. Yeah. So it's maybe 2,000. Yeah, he's, I think he's 2,100. Sounds right.

Speaker 5 Because when I get up to that and I can look right over, it's right above.

Speaker 2 All I know is that you have zones, and one zone would be the zone where you would expect the densest home, housing. Yes. And then another zone would be a little less dense. And then another zone would be... Do we maybe need a fourth zone? Potentially. Yeah. There could be five zones. I don't know, but I look at this and I just look at, because I know the terrain and I know, and I'm like, this whole residential thing is just this giant area and it's not all the same. And you would think that you would not want it to be the same. Because if it was, eventually you're going to lose the entire character because...

Speaker 1 That's a really good point.

Speaker 2 I mean, that's what the zones are supposed to be doing. They're supposed to be controlling what type of development that you want in a certain area. And this does not do that. This is just way too broad.

Speaker 6 Yeah. Which, as you pointed out, may have just happened because it was...

Speaker 14 Well, I mean, you look at...

Speaker 6 Oh, yeah, I looked at the color of that.

Speaker 5 Maltese.

Speaker 18 Yeah.

Speaker 6 That's insane.

Speaker 5 That's rural.

Speaker 6 Yeah. It should be forest.

Speaker 5 Yet mine down here, where our house is right there, where the two brooks converge, that's where forest starts and that's so much... I don't know. Yeah. Doesn't make sense to me. You're right.

Speaker 14 No, this is valid.

Speaker 6 Yeah. This is valid.

Speaker 2 So, I mean, I really think that that is the actual starting point. The starting point is looking at the zones and trying to figure out, is this, does this match what the people stand for? Well, the first, the very first starting point

Speaker 1 is me calling BCRC and asking if we have the ability to change that, right?

Speaker 2 Well, how can we not?

Speaker 1 Because... It's a tick one day and it's a spider now.

Speaker 2 I know. We have... I mean, these are our zoning laws. BCRC doesn't tell us what zoning we're allowed to have.

Speaker 1 I don't understand enough about it, so I'm just going to call and get rid of it. Yeah.

Speaker 2 No, I hear you.

Speaker 1 Yes.

Speaker 15 Yes.

Speaker 1 Yes. Marv is probably right. Their name is probably down here because they helped us do that. Because they helped us do that. I'm just going to ask just to get us... Don't put it near me, though.

Speaker 5 Oh, I'm not going to just watch him. Put him on the side. Put him on the poor thing outside. Put him outside. Oh, my gosh. I wonder if he's an indoor spider. Are you sure he's not a tick? No, that's not a tick.

Speaker 14 Okay, good.

Speaker 5 Sorry. He wouldn't be an indoor spider.

Speaker 10 Bad spider.

Speaker 1 Oh, he's hanging up. I know he was hanging. Oh, my goodness.

Speaker 38 All right.

Speaker 10 Okay. This is what you do.

Speaker 1 All right, so I'll call BCRC. I feel like it's pushing 8 o'clock, so maybe we end it there.

Speaker 5 So who is going to call BCRC?

Speaker 1 I'll call BCRC just to clarify that we do have the capability of moving that boundaries on our own. You're going to call Deb Chalmers about the wetlands. Rebecca. Sorry, that's what it says, too. And make a sign for the jump. I'm going to make a sign for the school, call BCRC. With a few questions that we'd come up with.

Speaker 5 And I'm going to check with Nick regarding the bylaw grant.

Speaker 1 Okay.

Speaker 5 So I have four.

Speaker 1 I want to put all this work on your desk.

Speaker 6 And our next meeting is July 6th.

Speaker 10 The thing that makes rural and residential seem different is elevation. Mm-hmm. The faster you rise in elevation, the more rural it seems. Yes. But this whole valley was bigger and flatter. Right. We'd have a bigger residential. That's true. Because it's a small valley. But it's... So that's why it looks, you know, in with the rural.

Speaker 2 But it's also just where you want... For instance, let's just say you had a whole area and it was a big aquifer. It was a big water source for the town. Well, certainly, you're not going to encourage 50 million houses in that place, right? Right. You're going to try to zone it so that there's, you know, much lower density to protect the water. Was that considered in this? Do you think?

Speaker 10 If you break it up and you're zoning... Are the aquifers considered in this? If you have a house like that, you could make a fifth zoning area. Or six. Yeah. Right.

Speaker 2 It doesn't matter. I mean, there's probably... I mean, I don't know how many. I mean, there's got to be eight or ten of them down in North Adams. I mean, it's all broken up into all different things. That's true. Based on R1, R2. Yeah. We don't... I mean, we don't need all that. But this seems to be...

Speaker 6 Well, this is also another interesting question. Is there such a thing as a... Is there a map that contains aquifers and watershed?

Speaker 2 There is. There is in that. In the wetlands? I don't think it's accurate. I just looked today. Interestingly, in the... And something that I came across recently, I just noticed that there's all this watershed water source up above the north end of East... Right. Like where Jen Hughes lives. Yes, yes. That whole area in there is marked off as, you know, water sources up there.

Speaker 6 Yes.

Speaker 2 And I don't... I feel like it's not on that map that I logged into during that meeting.

Speaker 5 It's not because Roaring Brook is supposed to be a watershed for the town. And it's not... It's not on that map. Yeah.

Speaker 6 See, that's not good because...

Speaker 2 So I think if we're looking at all of this, that we really want to know where the aquifer... Again, there's Clough Road, that whole Clough Road area south of where Deb's house was. So we need to know where the aquifers are and where the water sources are. Absolutely. I don't know. It should be on the wetlands map.

Speaker 6 But it's not. It is. But it's not, right? I'll find out. Okay. Because, you know, the other thing about that is, going back to the earlier part of this meeting, if they are going to try to say, you have to build here, here, and here unless you have these reasons, protecting our water is a really good reason.

Speaker 2 Protecting our water has got to be one of the, literally, the top number one things. Because that...

Speaker 6 Agreed. Agreed. Agreed.

Speaker 2 Because people of the town have got to have the benefit of that water. Yeah. Look at how they moved to Reedsboro. Yeah. It's... Exactly.

Speaker 31 It's becoming a global provider.

Speaker 2 And it's only going to get...

Speaker 6 No. How many times do you see on the North Adams chat, is your water brown today? Yes. My water smells funny. Okay. Motion to adjourn. Second.

Speaker 1 What time is it? Really? It's 8.01.

Speaker 7 8.01.

Speaker 1 Oh, did they fix the clock? No.

Speaker 1 I guess so.

Speaker 5 They did. Motion to adjourn by... It'll go fast again. So... Second. We've got a lot of things stuck in our hall of fame. Yes. I know we're kind of off record, but... This is... So just turn it off. Pam, you just do this again. We really need to figure out this all. Yes. I've got to stop that. I believe that the board must be the ones that do this. I can't see where the state would get involved. They don't know. I think they should. They don't know. I don't know. If we don't even know how... How can we... There's nothing we'll know. No, it's...

Speaker 2 I'm, like, so focused on this, and I try to... Let me just tell you. I'm going to tell you. Can I come on? I could not do this. Properly. I need...

Speaker 26 I can't turn this off. Why can't I turn this off? All right. Can we do it? I don't know. Right here.

Speaker 2 It's always working before. All right. So... That says on. And I can try to stop.

The minutes as written

69 lines, copied from data/minutes/planning-commission/2026-06-22_regular.txt. Line breaks are the district's -- its exports put one word on a line in places, and nothing here is reflowed. The transcript above is what was said out loud; this is what was written down. Where they disagree, the decision record says which one it was read out of.

TOWN OF STAMFORD, VERMONT

PLANNING COMMISSION

Meeting Minutes — 6/22/2026

DRAFT — Pending Approval

Members Present: Lisa Gramlin, Chair, Pam Tworig, Marta Miller, Deb Burchard, Alden Finney

Members Absent: Natalie O’Neil and James Stimpson

Others Present: Debra Righi, and James RIghi.

1. Call to Order and Hearing of Visitors

Meeting called to order by Lisa Gramlin at 6:02 and opened with the Pledge of Allegiance. There were no

comments from visitors.

2. Reading and Approval of Minutes

Corrections: Fix error in numbering, correct spelling of Nick Zaiac’s name. MOTION by Marta Miller to

accept as corrected. SECONDED by Deb Burchard. All in Favor.

3. Community Engagement and Survey Response

Reminder that July 10th is the deadline for residents to submit the community survey that will help guide

the Planning Commission in updating the Town Plan and The Zoning Bylaws.

The commission emphasized the need to increase community participation for the ongoing survey to gather

meaningful data.

4. Bylaw Grant Opportunity and State Housing Targets

The commission discussed applying for a bylaw grant and the impact of state housing targets on town

planning.

 The grant application to help with updating the town’s bylaws opens September 1st

o The grant would provide BCRC support updating bylaws, which the Commission agreed was

necessary

 State Housing Targets under the Home Act require the town to address growth barriers to building

more homes in the upcoming Town Plan.

o Barriers include environmental constraints and lack of town water and sewer systems

o The commission recognized the need to justify inability to meet targets due to these and

any other potential factors

o They questioned enforcement mechanisms and incentives for actual housing development

in the town

 Economic and demographic realities shape housing feasibility with local market constraints

discussed

o High building costs limit new construction despite demand

o Lack of town water and sewer infrastructure reduces capacity for higher-density housing

 

o The state’s vision for housing growth differs from local realities and infrastructure

limitations

.

5. Wetlands Protection and Environmental Concerns

The group debated the impact of state changes to wetland buffer zones and local capacity for

environmental enforcement.

 State reduction of wetland buffers raised concerns about increased flood risks and habitat loss

o The Commission expressed frustration with state prioritizing housing over conservation

o Concerns included increased flooding, loss of natural water absorption, and erosion

problems

o They highlighted the difficulty in enforcing buffer zones locally due to unclear wetland

boundaries

6. Attendance Policy Revision

The commission reviewed and proposed updates to attendance rules to reflect current meeting frequency

and maintain accountability.

o The updated policy will be rewritten to reflect changes proposed to current policy

7. Bylaw Definitions, Setbacks, and Zoning District Review

The Commission focused on clarifying definitions, setbacks for private roads and driveways, and reviewing

zoning districts for alignment with town goals.

 Clear definitions for driveway, private road, and right of way were prioritized to reduce confusion

 Setback requirements for private roads and driveways discussed

 Zoning district boundaries and regulations require review before or in conjunction with bylaw

updates

o The group agreed to wait for survey results before making major zoning changes

o Focus will remain on refining definitions, setbacks, and district boundaries with clear

rationales

o They plan to improve bylaw readability and include explanatory notes for public clarity

8. Next Meeting and Adjournment

MOTION to adjourn by Lisa Gramlin. SECONDED by Marta Miller. All in favor. Motion APPROVED. Meeting

adjourned at 8:01 p.m. The next regular meeting is scheduled for June 22, 2026 at 6pm.

Respectfully submitted,

Pam Tworig, Secretary

Stamford Planning Commission

Transcribed 2026-10-21 (faster-whisper large-v3, CUDA; names corrected per data/name_fixes.json). Names corrected against the minutes. Diarization is automated and may split one person into several labels. Raw model output with timestamps: SRT.