--- title: "Stamford Planning Commission — March 24, 2025" date: 2025-03-24 board: planning-commission meeting_id: 2025-03-24_public-hearing session: public-hearing duration_min: 74 audio: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a_ULIS4LMBE audio_source: YouTube (@jgramlin78) minutes: https://townofstamfordvermont.org/mediaItems/Planning%20Com%20Minutes%202025-3-24%20pub%20hrg.pdf minutes_pending: false present: [Peter Greenbush, Alden Finney, Lisa Gramlin, Sheila Lawrence, Marta Miller, David Saldo, Jim Stimpson, David Tatro] absent: [Daniel Potvin] transcribed: 2026-10-21 (faster-whisper large-v3, CUDA; names corrected per data/name_fixes.json) diarization: pyannote/speaker-diarization-3.1 (automated; cluster labels may over-split a single voice; unattributed paragraphs have no reliable speaker) --- # Stamford Planning Commission — March 24, 2025 **Session:** Public Hearing · **Duration:** 74 min · [Audio](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a_ULIS4LMBE) · [Minutes](https://townofstamfordvermont.org/mediaItems/Planning%20Com%20Minutes%202025-3-24%20pub%20hrg.pdf) **Present:** Peter Greenbush, Alden Finney, Lisa Gramlin, Sheila Lawrence, Marta Miller, David Saldo, Jim Stimpson, David Tatro **Absent:** Daniel Potvin --- **Speaker 1:** I'd like to welcome everybody to a hearing for the training commission of the Polish change bylaws. Go through and push off what we have accomplished. When that is done, we will open up for discussion. Please keep it civil. I'd like to take attendance, board members that are here. Dave Stoller, Marta Miller, Peter Greenbush. We can do the audience if you'd like. I'd like to let everybody know that this meeting is being recorded for Jed's YouTube. So I'm going to have him pass this off right away to Jim so he can present. **Speaker 2:** So everybody here knows we had some issues in the past. We won't get into that part of it, but we're going through. The issue of the bylaws and having to enforce the bylaws for quite a few years myself, the issue of the signs and locations and all that stuff has always been kind of a sticker. So we decided to delve into this because if you read this older or the current sign bylaw, it references residential rule and forest districts only. It doesn't really get into anything as far as the signs, what's required and so on. But then you would have to make supplements and things and so all the other things you would be so start with the bylaws. So please join me in praising these bylaws. So what I do... I'm going to talk to the other bylaws. I'm going to talk to the first bylaw and then we're going to discuss the other bylaws. bylaw. So we started doing this bylaw, the first bylaw was in 1931. And so the first bylaw is actually the first bylaw in the building code, that was put into action in 1932. It's a really good one, because it seems to have been the first bylaw. And there's a lot of discussion around this bylaw. There's a lot of discussion about the first bylaw. detailed but not too restrictive bylaw and it's kind of the result if you look at our town plan and all that stuff it's written to kind of work with other areas other communities in our general area right so a town plan is not just specific it mentions it should kind of like help out the the next door community or the community well they're kind of like a surrounding community so we felt that getting all their bylaws and requiring like requirements and stuff that they had for signs and we utilized um what was already written so and what fits for us as most people we put together a bunch of bylaws from various communities things that are kind of similar same things like that and you and we added our own little thing we also dove into and researched state law in the exemption for town uh bible three c's things like that and uh so we are presenting that tonight you guys had a copy of it we're printing them out now and um take a look at it it's it's basically just get right into it can i ask before you start no the very first statement you made you said how you had a signed rule but it only applied to **Speaker 3:** or it didn't apply to you seem to indicate that it didn't apply to all aspects **Speaker 4:** of the town yeah it could have been **Speaker 2:** it could have been uh deciphered so many different ways **Speaker 5:** there's three other inspection camps rural residential and sports each have signed sections **Speaker 6:** and it was different for each one pretty much worth the work **Speaker 2:** word for words so it was the same sign by law for every district right but it had no indication as to uh i think and then and then there was another reference here in section seven uh make them off of it that was maybe four or five uh lines sentences were so fast it got a little bit more specific but it never really got into the details so under under the state law the state law basically says if we have a signed bylaw you're good to go but if you don't have a signed bylaw then you would you would basically go off of theirs which you don't want to do because their sizes are huge and they're a lot a lot more larger signs and so on so so this is this is basically the type of uh bylaws our surrounding communities have as well there's nothing really different in here than in theirs **Speaker 3:** is that what is this state law what is this all right so we're going to we're going to present **Speaker 2:** we're going to present and then we'll take questions from the public i was just going to **Speaker 7:** answer a question but since you're presenting it keep going okay so under 7 **Speaker 2:** 16 7.16 the sign we're going to start right there is that right lisa yes we added it as a standalone **Speaker 5:** section we removed it from the forest presidential and we removed each of the three sections and then created a standalone bylaw that's why it's 17 7.16 follows the general regulation so if everybody's **Speaker 2:** got a copy of this uh 7.16 sign uh you can kind of read it right there is not required for a change of copy on any sign like so if you're making a sign and you want to change the label or something there's no permit required nor painting cleaning normal maintenance repair signs structures for which the sign permit has been previously issued so long as the sign is not structurally modified in any way a permit issued by the administrative officer shall be obtained prior to the construction direction replacement of any outdoor sign other than those specific under 716.2 in accordance with the following requirements general sign regulations under 716.1 a no outdoor sign shall be permitted in any district except for those per those proposed purpose of identifying an existing on-premise use no sign shall i'm just going to keep going down with that no sign shall be allowed within the right of way signs identifying any non-residential use shall not exceed a total of 16 square feet so the current one is 12. so we want 16. no freestanding signs shall exceed eight feet in height as measured from the ground and stop picking i'm just kidding that's from the lowest point **Speaker 2:** yes yes from the ground to the highest point 716.1 signs may be illuminated by an indirect constant shielded light source provided that the light fixture is mounted on the top or side of the sign and is directly onto the science surface lighting may not produce undue glare gaze blades hazard glaring hazard or distractions or adverse light Diversely affect neighboring properties, right of way or vehicular traffic. Signs are expressly prohibited from being internally illuminated. The exempt signs, 716.2, the following signs are exempt from requiring a zoning permit. Exempt? What? Exempt signs are exempt from permits, exempt, you don't need a permit. The following signs are exempt from requiring a zoning permit. Signs erected, maintained, and administered by the town or public road are on public roads not exceeding 64 square feet in area per state regulation. 716.2 , signs are bulletin, signs for bulletin boards. No, it doesn't have the same. Read right from the bottom. **Speaker 8:** This is a letter. This is not the same. No. This is a letter. It's an old copy. Oh. Oh. It's an old copy. What'd you give me? I gave you what I had. **Speaker 6:** There's a 1F2 which you can use. Okay. That was an older copy. Oh. That's yours. That's yours. Let's see what happens. It says S, you know. **Speaker 1:** So that's what those mean. So that's what those mean. There were some changes. Yeah, it was just. It's a 7. It's an off bottom. It's a 7. Is that right? What's that? I think I have that. We'll save this up for Ron. It should be section 7. 20, 20, 20. Is that new? Yes. Okay. For you guys that got the right stuff and I didn't, did everything I said match up to what you were **Speaker 2:** reading? Okay. Except the 1F. **Speaker 2:** Okay, let's go back to the 1F. Alright, that's kind of an important one to go through. **Speaker 2:** The total area of a sign shall be the actual square footage of one sign face. Double faced signs may be permitted within the maximum square footage permitted on each side. That means if 16 **Speaker 5:** square foot is allowed, it can be 16 if this is a sign. 16 square foot, 16 square foot. What picture is this? **Speaker 3:** The actual size of the sign. Right. Right. **Speaker 2:** So, exempt signs. That's 716.2. The following signs are exempt from requiring a zoning permit. Signs erected, maintained, or administered by the town including official traffic control signs or by the State of Vermont under Title 10, Chapter 21. Understand. If you've got any questions, just ask. **Speaker 9:** Basically, **Speaker 5:** basically, the state has for the regulations allowing the select board. **Speaker 10:** Is that already in the state law? Yes. So we already had a state law? Yes. **Speaker 11:** We'll get into that after we read this. **Speaker 2:** Hang on. We'll get into that. 716.2b. Signs for bulletin boards incidentally to civic organizations not to exceed 16 square feet in area excluding post and frame or 6 feet above ground level. One on-premise historic or landmark sign not to exceed 6 square feet in area. 716.2d. Temporary signs for banners advertising public or community events to be displayed in designated locations on town property shall be reviewed immediately following the event. 716.2e. Non-advertising signs placed for direct safety or public service purposes not to exceed 2 square feet in area. One residential sign per dwelling unit identifying the occupant not to exceed 2 square feet in area. Residential flags or banners intended solely for ornamental or non-advertising purposes. Remember this is one unlit wall mounted or freestanding sign per written or dwelling advertising a home occupation, home business, home child care facility not exceeding 6 square feet in area. Signs related to hunting or trespassing each not to exceed 2 square feet in area. One unit sign or one unlit sign per establishment associated with farm operation not to exceed 16 square feet in area. One temporary real estate sign not exceeding 6 square feet in area. I had a little bit of a question with 2. What's a typical real estate sign? **Speaker 3:** They're less than that. I think they're probably 24 high by maybe 30 inches ish. So that fits in there. **Speaker 2:** 4 square feet. 716.2k. Temporary auction signs or garage signs, sale signs not to exceed 2 square feet in number and 6 square feet in area for sign which shall be removed immediately following the sale. Temporary election signs to be posted and removed in accordance with state law. 716.2k. One temporary construction sign not to exceed 16 square feet in total area or 10 feet in height to be removed immediately following completion of the construction. Signs not allowed. Signs not allowed. The following signs shall not be allowed in any history. Advertising billboards. Flashing, oscillated and revolving signs. Internally illuminated signs. Signs that impair public safety. Any signs that appears to direct the movement of traffic or which interfaces or interferes with... I can't see. Intonation. Or imitates. Or imitates or resembles any official traffic directional or loop signs signal or address. Any sign that prevents a clear and unobscured view of official signs. Those are the projected proposed new bylaws referring to our signs and a lot of work went into this. I'll tell you that right now. This is kind of a result of, I don't know, half a dozen different bylaws and signs that we've spent hours doing. And I guess at this point we've been... Unless you've got anything to share on top of this. We can open it. Got a question? **Speaker 12:** 17161D and 1716 7161D and 2N. They say the same thing two different ways. 17161D and 2N. The quest and height from the ground. And 2N. And M, the construction site? Yes. **Speaker 5:** How do you feel that they're... **Speaker 12:** They seem to Oh, okay. 2N. I'm sorry. Yeah, 2N. And what are you referring to? A construction sign. What's the reason for that? **Speaker 2:** One temporary construction sign. Well, you've got **Speaker 2:** construction trucks coming in like let's just throw it out there up on any road a big house. And they've got a house up on the road they need to put a big sign up so people can see it. The dump trucks, the cement trucks. And they have to be taken down afterwards. Why did you make that 10 feet? No, I think all of these are correct. I don't know why it's... They seem to... I think we switched that to 8 feet. Switch it to 8, so it's consistent. **Speaker 2:** I thought you were asking why it was... No, I didn't ask them why they say different things. It's all 8 feet, right? Good catch. We changed 7162 that references 10 feet we wanted to change that to 8 feet. That's a tight one. I would say. Good catch. **Speaker 13:** Yeah, I want to hear about the state law. **Speaker 3:** Okay, so the problem was with the old signs and our sign bylaws **Speaker 5:** was that we did restrict it to 12 square feet. So our bylaw was far more restricted than the state law. Which we are allowed to do. **Speaker 2:** I gave you a copy of that Okay, so that was allowed. **Speaker 3:** The town had more restrictive regulations than the state. **Speaker 5:** And that's why there's a problem with the signs that came in. **Speaker 2:** So that's where the... That's where the issue... There's a problem there because I disagree. I read the law. You can read it yourself. Title 10, chapter 494 and 495. It references everything you're asking. Read it. I feel free to call me or whatever. It's over with. That's why we're doing this. I guess I'm just kind of surprised because I'm surprised **Speaker 3:** that the town actually is allowed to make more restrictive rules than the state rules. That actually surprises me. **Speaker 5:** As long as you do that. **Speaker 1:** It's just like the it's like the select board with the new ethics laws that come out. They have to at a minimum go by the state if they can have a more restrictive policy. **Speaker 2:** But in our former bylaws it referenced residential rule, of course. Period. **Speaker 5:** The other problem with the previous sign situation was that I think that the word permitted and permitted created some confusion with the person who was consulted who said you don't need it because he was interpreting permitted and permitted incorrectly. So one of the things that we were trying to do was to clarify by saying these are not allowed as opposed to because there's a fine point to be determined with regard to there can be a sign but you've got to get a permit first. You've got to go through all of these proper channels. These are guidelines that are to help with that process but some of what we're trying to do is identify which signs you need a permit for which signs you do not need a permit for and which signs are absolutely forbidden. So that's part of what we were trying to do because I think that was part of the confusion. Kurt. . **Speaker 14:** . . . . . . . . . . **Speaker 15:** . **Speaker 2:** . . **Speaker 14:** . . . . . . . . . **Speaker 5:** . . . . . **Speaker 6:** . . . . . . . . . . . **Speaker 3:** . . . . . . . . . . . **Speaker 3:** . **Speaker 5:** . . . . . . . **Speaker 6:** . . **Speaker 5:** . . **Speaker 12:** . . . **Speaker 5:** . **Speaker 16:** . **Speaker 12:** . . . . **Speaker 5:** . . . **Speaker 2:** . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . **Speaker 6:** . . . . . **Speaker 3:** . . . . . . . . . . . . . . **Speaker 4:** . **Speaker 3:** . . **Speaker 4:** . **Speaker 2:** . . **Speaker 3:** . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . **Speaker 2:** . . . . . . . . . . **Speaker 3:** . . . **Speaker 5:** . . . . . . . . **Speaker 5:** . . **Speaker 12:** . . . . . **Speaker 14:** . **Speaker 2:** . . . . **Speaker 2:** . . . . . . . . . . **Speaker 5:** . . . . . . . . . **Speaker 5:** . . **Speaker 9:** . **Speaker 2:** . . . . . . . . . **Speaker 14:** . **Speaker 12:** . . . **Speaker 14:** . **Speaker 2:** . . . . . . . . **Speaker 14:** . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . **Speaker 5:** so would it suffice if you just put it under the sign bylaw to reference the town yeah i would just **Speaker 14:** say something just under the sign ordinance itself like before like they said refer i think **Speaker 17:** that's safer right to do that we don't need to make a lot of changes i mean and then when it **Speaker 2:** gets to you guys if you guys feel like it needs to be in the front with the rest of the definitions that's something you got to look at do you have any other kind of answers sorry but **Speaker 6:** i know you said the actual square footage of one sign is what if somebody wants to put like a nice wide post going up you know a really decorative post on each side to hold the sign we went back **Speaker 5:** and thought about the post so we decided to exclude the post from the square footage because of that because it may **Speaker 18:** be a beautiful post you know and so they shouldn't be writing on the post correct that it shouldn't i mean should we yeah we i mean we went back and forth on whether or not to do the **Speaker 3:** post and you could say though if you didn't want someone you could say though that yes the posts are excluded but there's to be no sign no no work no advertising no words on the sign if you really don't want someone you really don't want that so actually be part of the time yes do we really want to regulate regulate right i mean more and more i mean it just isn't that way what if someone does want to use the post to put like me and they want **Speaker 2:** to vote very close i don't know but if you get a person that does a a 16 square foot sign but he does 15 instead of that and then decorates the post right right you see what i'm saying you are right so um i mean you're not you're not going to stop that because the next guy you got you got to wait with it **Speaker 12:** why can't we we don't want to say that 16 square foot post is a pretty long big post no i'm just **Speaker 2:** saying the sign and that the pulse right if the guy made his sign smaller no well i wonder i wonder **Speaker 5:** if in the in the definition of sign let me just clarify something about that so you know that the the information oh on the side of the post is the sign and the post is the post and the post is the post the sign is you know this is is the square footage of the face and that is where the information goes **Speaker 6:** that's well in this um title 10 of the state statutes it says whatever dimension of the sign are specified they shall include panels and frames so if you include the definition of the sign put it there maybe that will maybe ward off right put in one more 7.162d what are the designated locations on town property so temporary signs and banners designated yeah and designated locations on town property well you were designated i guess **Speaker 2:** whatever that is it attempt is that temporary that's for the temporary signs yes so if you if you decide out here everybody wants to put their uh public or their taxi tag sale signs or or or what have you just like the world expanded or something like that out there whatever or some so would this only be for community type events or would it be anybody who wants to or resiliency fair signs **Speaker 19:** have the right designate an area so would this only be for community type if **Speaker 20:** any anybody who wants to have a tag sales going to put their sign on the front lawn where we go i **Speaker 2:** think this is what protects you guys and put you can put what you want where do you go i guess if you want to put national sites along the favela this is what you do whatever ça racon shows on our normal **Speaker 5:** have to say so right so the designated so in other words the issue at hand is this is on this is on town property right so this is the things that people want to put in front of the school so somebody can put a tag sign yeah on the school it's from the school it's yeah this is temporary signs or banners advertising public or community events so that could a public event **Speaker 9:** could be considered commercial well political science is under state law yes yeah no that's a **Speaker 3:** that's a community so who controls i think where the campaign signs go yeah that's part of it regulation but is there is there some other thing where like like we're just brought up like you know like do you really want people putting tag sales signs up and stuff like that who creates the rules of what who can put a temporary sign up on the town so it would be law because it's it's **Speaker 2:** dead this is under the town laws regulations correct lori controls the elections but lori wouldn't control other things she would control who are select basically put designated areas **Speaker 20:** so i guess the the community event matters like if the school is putting on a breakfast with sandra as a school that's one thing but what if i don't know they're going to have a huge farm stand up on county road does that sign go on town property for it might be a community event that'll help the community but it's a private place what i mean there's a lot of **Speaker 21:** different things that could fall in there that feels to me like these these um you know temporary **Speaker 5:** signs or banners for community events should refer to things happening here right in this things that are either happening in the gym in the town hall in the **Speaker 2:** library but it's it references community events it doesn't necessarily have to be here they can **Speaker 5:** still put their signs out however what if there was a that initial that initial um thing about uh signs are supposed to be identifying purposes on existing premise existing on the premise use so you're on your writing **Speaker 9:** this is general this is for like right but so i wonder if there's i wonder if there's some way **Speaker 5:** right i wonder if there's some way to also identify for the town property **Speaker 20:** what signs are going there like only town or school sponsored events because yeah i mean i don't know you could have a big um what's going on a church a church bazaar outdoor theater whatever that would be like a small town or any kind of thing that might be happening in different locations the community event is bigger than a town sponsor event right **Speaker 5:** there should be some i think what's the thing troy is you don't have say right now **Speaker 21:** as the clerk you don't have a say i only have a say in the election which is totally separate **Speaker 20:** okay **Speaker 2:** so this is how i would like to say of like say i wanted to add a I have a drag racing down Main Street down here. Let's say it's not a state road, okay? I go before the select board and basically, hey, can we pay to cut off this road? We wanna borrow this road, blah, blah, blah. Put signs up. I think the select board has the right to give permission to them people to put signs up. **Speaker 14:** Or road racing. Also, it says we have permission from the select board. These temporary signs might be erected on found property with permission from the select board, period. **Speaker 14:** Chief. **Speaker 8:** I'm listening to you say that the selectmen would be able to say yes or no down the road as they have something going. For emergency management, we ended up having, we have people up in Dover are the only ones officially for this area, the mobs, that can come down and shut the road down for these things. **Speaker 3:** But that's not what we're talking about. **Speaker 22:** We're talking about. **Speaker 8:** Well, he's saying that if you put the sign up and you say he's gonna have his drag racing up and down the street and have the selectmen say yes or no and block it off. Can't. Simple as that. **Speaker 2:** We're not gonna have a road race on it. Like a horse race. I know, but I'm just saying. Same thing. The only reason I say that is we have to get the blood from them. **Speaker 8:** I just sat at the block cabin there. And Russell got to talk about it and he called the state, brought the state in, the fire department, the selectmen, everything. And had a fit because I was standing there. I never want to call a person that they had to turn around. I stood there at the block cabin and just watched. So that's why I'm coming up with this. Because the selectmen wanted to come out and ask us. **Speaker 23:** I'd like to throw in two cents here. First of all, I want to thank everybody who's worked on this effort into this. **Speaker 23:** And I certainly appreciate all that you have done. From my perspective, I've been at this for many years. The way I see this pan simply is, it's a scenic highway out there. The federal government and state control everything that's going on. You can't do anything without going through them first, unless you want to give up your fun. Point one, no ands, ifs about it. They sometimes will direct you to the MUTCD. The data's supposed to follow and it's called the Orange Book. You should have it here. I don't think we do. I don't know if you've been going across it, Jim. It identifies everything that you can do and what you can't do. The one thing that was said today is that we can be stricter than what the scenic highway requires, but we even saw stricter- We never mentioned scenic highways. Excuse me? **Speaker 24:** You said state, not scenic. **Speaker 5:** We're stricter. **Speaker 23:** And for instance, Kirk brought up right-of-ways. There's a defined map that shows where the right-of-way lines are. And they're not where the road is. And that presents a problem, because up where I live, it's 66 feet. Down here, it's 35 feet. But yet, when you look where the right-of-way is, and they ran into this when we did the sidewalk. That's why it took so long to put in out there. Because it's a scenic highway. There's specific rules that you have to follow, and if you don't follow them, your funding's gone. Bridge funding, sidewalk funding, roads, anything you can think of. The Select Board does have authority over the town roads. But if you're receiving state funding on a glass door, it becomes a problem, and so in lies the issue. You really need to bounce off anything that you want to do on this main highway. The state, to make sure that we're not violating the scenic highway. And with that said, also, I should let the Select Board know that the sign for the scenic highway, you can't read it anymore. When you come into town. They're replacing it. They were fixing it? **Speaker 25:** They're going to when I call. **Speaker 5:** They additionally said that. **Speaker 23:** Well, I'm just bringing up the point. You can barely read it. But it says, this was the first, this is the longest and oldest scenic highway in the state of Vermont. Route 100. Starting from the Massachusetts border. And it's the longest and oldest scenic highway in the state of Vermont. For a hundred miles. You guys will remember going up the candidates 200 and something miles long, subsequent ones 1966. I think we have 10 now, but it's very restrictive what you can do, what you can't do. It's the one reason that protect us from windmills. Because this mountain range is part of the scene and you just can't develop in a scenic highway without getting the government involved. So that's great that we wanted to change the rules and do everything to help maybe make it better. Mileage. concerned, what we're doing is, one sign came down already because people didn't understand the laws. And I'm not blaming them, they're competent. I've looked at this thing, I've gone through thousands of pages, roads, bylaws, and signs. It's a lot to handle. And these people have done a good job trying to isolate and get it down. The bottom line is, I said it in previous meetings, I'll say it in this meeting, before we do anything, we're getting federal funding and state funding. Get somebody down from the state. They come down for nothing. They're glad to do it. Tell them what you're trying to do. Have them do the job. I already found a section where this coming into the school parking lot is part of the State Highway. So that's what you're talking to do. It's not the State Highway but the parking lot. I also found that parks, you've got to be 300 feet away to put a sign in. so there's all these rules that you know we're trying to do stuff and nobody really understands I think completely the laws that are involved. Get the people down who know. The VCRC, people from the state, you know. **Speaker 5:** I did contact the V-Trans and they were so... **Speaker 24:** Yeah, who would V-Trans? Because there's specific people for this. **Speaker 5:** The main enforcer guy. **Speaker 23:** So he knows the scenic highway and he understands all the rules and regulations? Because there's specific people for this. The whole board just for that. **Speaker 12:** Most of the state. **Speaker 2:** I know two of the towns, two of the towns or three of the towns, three of the towns that we are on board with. So Pono being one, or Reefboro being one of them. And I'm very confident we're... **Speaker 5:** Lisa has talked to people. I don't know what the orange book is that you're referring to, but if you have specific things that are in the in conflict with what we're proposing, let us know specifically what they are. Because, you know, we're doing the research. Lisa's talking to people. We feel pretty confident, but I sense that you have a hesitation. And so if there's something specific, bring it, because obviously... **Speaker 23:** Well, that's really nice that you're saying that to me, and I really appreciate it. But what happened when I tried to bring three meetings about it? **Speaker 5:** I think part of what happened was... Again, people were looking for the specifics that you seem to be referring to. **Speaker 23:** This isn't the time and place to go through it. Okay, so my only point in all of this is I'm not shooting down anything you're talking about here. All I'm saying is that once I got taken down already because somebody read the law completely. And I'm telling you right now, what you have here is in conflict with the scenic highway. **Speaker 5:** And I'll put it to you again, Dave. I will wait after this meeting and listen to you. I'll look at whatever you have, but I can't work on... **Speaker 23:** It isn't what Dave Sello says, right? **Speaker 5:** Right now, it's what Dave Sello says, because you have some mysterious things that I've never seen. And every time I say I'll say it right now, I will stay after and look at whatever you have. **Speaker 23:** You can't find the situational departure. You can't find... **Speaker 26:** This isn't a state park. It has nothing to do with a state park. **Speaker 12:** If you read it, it talks about advertising for a state park. Not for the parking lot. **Speaker 23:** You know? Oh, I'm assuming. But... Are we discussing? Or in general, are you going to shut me down? **Speaker 2:** I'm trying not to shut anybody down. **Speaker 23:** Well, I mean, yeah. **Speaker 5:** I mean, this is probably not the right... **Speaker 23:** No, but I mean, you brought it up. So here it is on your... Let me finish my sentence. **Speaker 5:** It's not the right time to look at the piles and piles of paperwork that I have told you I will look at. And I'll put that forth again today. After this is concluded. I'm glad to stay after as long as you would like to show me whatever it is you're bringing. But we don't get to see it. There's only ten bullets here. I know. But those are all my citations. They're just bullets without any reference points. Well, my point is... **Speaker 23:** Well, there's plenty of reference points. It tells you, let's see, BSA 24, Title 10. Any problem? It's all reference. **Speaker 25:** I mean, you have one that says no lights. **Speaker 5:** And it just says no lights. And it has no reference point where you found that. Or... I don't know how to work with that. **Speaker 23:** Chapter 21. Tourist Information Services 495 Regulations. You can look this up. Just like me. That's exactly what this references. Well, then, how did you miss... If you said you didn't find anything, tell me how you missed this part right here. Notwithstanding any other provision under the title, a person from or corporation shall not maintain an outdoor advertising structure or display within the limits of the highway or, however the limitation, shall be under Section 494 . Then you go and read those things. And all of a sudden, there's all kinds of restrictions. Within the limits of the highway. You've said it. Period. **Speaker 27:** That's what you said. **Speaker 23:** That's what I already said. The scenic roadway or byway shall not be reconstructed or improved unless the reconstructed or improved is conducted in accordance with the agency of transportation design standards. Signs along the state scenic roads and byways shall comply with Federal Highway Administration M-U-P-C-D. That's within the right of way. **Speaker 23:** The M-U-P-C-D only is within the right of way. They're talking about for the scenic highway, you have to follow their rules. **Speaker 26:** So, do we know if our signs that they're trying to implement follow? **Speaker 12:** They're not in the right of way. They're not allowed in the right way, so absolutely. **Speaker 23:** Okay. **Speaker 12:** All that, yes. All that is the only thing that applies within the right of way. The M-U-P-C-D only addresses the right of way. The orange book is a basic guideline for municipalities to follow. It shows you how to get, I haven't bought three or four copies of it. **Speaker 23:** And there's none in the town. **Speaker 12:** There should be one word. There's probably one word. There probably is one there. It used to be. **Speaker 23:** There's a new way of looking at things. All I'm saying is that with a scenic highway designation, the rules are different. We should be having somebody that knows, from the state and the federal government, because we get funding from that, if we want to do something drastic, let's find out if what we're doing is right. I know, for instance, the right of way in this town is 12 feet in the direction of the school. So right off the bat, the sign that we're looking at, that they got a permit for, is going to be in the town right away. **Speaker 10:** Yeah, but when we looked at it, it looked like the sign might have been right there. Right there. Right on the edge. **Speaker 23:** You've got to be 25 feet from the, listen, you have to be 25 feet from the center of the road. Yeah, we might. You're not listening to me. The center of the road comes this way. **Speaker 3:** Oh, you're saying. Yeah, but Dave, remember, we looked at it. I know I looked, but after I looked. We looked at it with our apps, and on the app, I think that old sign was literally, wasn't it right there? **Speaker 23:** But don't you have to be 25 feet? 25 feet from the center of the road? **Speaker 3:** But the line that we were using, that the app picks it up, is the actual line. **Speaker 23:** It is the actual line. **Speaker 3:** Because, for instance, at the church, the right of way is like this much, and over here on this side, it's like this much. **Speaker 23:** We're talking the same thing. Do you understand my point? **Speaker 3:** I understand your guess. **Speaker 23:** We're going to be dropping the sign in the right way. **Speaker 3:** So I do understand what you're saying, and of course, that's a whole other thing with who's looking at these signs, and that you can't just measure 25 feet. Because, first of all, the rule is not, as I found out, the rule is not 25 feet from the center line. The rule is a minimum of 25 feet from the center line. It's 33 in places, and 33 in places, and in some other places, it shows that it's less than 25 feet. **Speaker 23:** I handed one extra to Dave three weeks ago, showing that the school parking lot is in State Highway. **Speaker 26:** Yeah, it's not. **Speaker 23:** And he's saying it's not. Did you get that? **Speaker 28:** The center line was surveyed in 1770. **Speaker 14:** Oh, beautiful. It's different than the Faze Road. **Speaker 3:** All I'm saying is that, so like, I have an app that shows me where the lines are according to all the new lines that were done. **Speaker 23:** Yes. **Speaker 3:** And they're not necessarily where people think they are. Right. But how, if you didn't have that app, you would not know. The state's got it. **Speaker 12:** Your truncated laws that you showed me. You said that if basically you're advertising a state park here, this parking lot can be considered part of the highway roadway, and we should sign it accordingly. But we're not advertising, nor is it a state park. **Speaker 23:** It was two different things, Dave. **Speaker 3:** Well, Dave. **Speaker 23:** It was two completely different things. **Speaker 3:** Dave, so I will say, I will say that these guys, whoever it is, whoever the little subcommittee here that's doing the signs, if one of them looks into the scenic highway and calls someone at the state and asks the questions, then, you know, what are you supposed to do? **Speaker 2:** What are you supposed to do other than... We've done that, and... That's what I'm saying. We've done that, and... That's all I'm saying. But it's never... Anyway, so just, I'll leave it alone. **Speaker 3:** As a board, if you... **Speaker 2:** We're very confident as to what we did and brought before the board. We're not going to bring something before the board that we know is wrong. **Speaker 3:** All I'm saying is, obviously, as a board, you pick a few people. The few people that are on the subcommittee, the few people do their due diligence, they make the phone calls, they do the things, and this is what the subcommittee has come up with. **Speaker 5:** And then the next process is for us as a board to decide, yes, now we bring it to the select board, where there may be other concerns before the select board says yes or no. So it's an ongoing process. It's an ongoing process. **Speaker 12:** You can what-if this thing from after the last minute. **Speaker 5:** Yeah, yeah, I mean it... **Speaker 12:** If you make a mistake, somebody will let you know. **Speaker 5:** Yeah. Right. Yeah, they make you take the sign number. Yeah. Again. So, Dave, I mean, I understand your concern. I understand where you're coming from. **Speaker 3:** But what are you asking? What are you asking that... What are you asking that to do right now? **Speaker 23:** I'm not asking anything. I'm just saying that we should be concerned about treating a new bylaw. Without understanding the ramifications. That's all I'm saying. It's nothing they've done. They've done a good job. He's confident, he just said, that they're within those standards and that there's no issue. So be it. I can't argue with that. I don't... I'd have to talk to somebody from the state. I just, from my research, have seen enough to say I have a concern. **Speaker 29:** That's all I'm trying to do. **Speaker 23:** I'm not trying to... **Speaker 3:** How do you think that your concern could be... I mean, how... What could happen to make you feel more confident? **Speaker 23:** If somebody from the state comes down, from the scenic highway board, and tells us what we can do and not, and how it's going to affect our funding. We're not putting any signs in the scenic highway. Nancy, just on what other is the scenic highway. **Speaker 6:** I like all the definitions and details that you went for the sign, and I wish when the zoning bylaws were passed in 2022 or whenever, that there was that much detail and explanation without just giving the board, this is the new bylaws. And there's a lot of them I don't agree with, but there was not enough detail, but it was during COVID. We met out under the tent there, and especially like accessory use, you can have three little buildings, and if you connect them, then you got one big building there, but three little buildings. You didn't need it. Or something like that. So I wish there was a lot more detail eventually to the rest of it. **Speaker 18:** Yeah, yeah, one down. **Speaker 5:** I think it was good, but with the sign law down, they need to go. **Speaker 23:** We learned. I can see what we're doing. **Speaker 6:** What's the, what is the process next that I was asking? **Speaker 2:** So we're going to take a motion to send this to the site. **Speaker 6:** Are you making the corrections? **Speaker 2:** Yeah, what we discussed tonight, the add-ons or whatever. And then we will... I'll put them together as an item, and then we'll go through this again, I believe. **Speaker 8:** And we'll send it to the board. You mean you want to approve everything that's on here right now? Yeah, that's what it is. You know, Lisa said that, yeah, that every day they go over some things, go through those, what everybody's been talking about and everything. But yet you're going to get it approved first? **Speaker 30:** No, we got to send it to Nancy. **Speaker 2:** We got to send it to the select board. We're not approving it. We're just... We're agreeing to send it to the select board. That's all. We get our card. And we'll send it. And we'll send it. We, we are, we, we get our card. We'll send it with these. Under intelligence. **Speaker 5:** We'll send it with these. We'll send it with these. How come... Here are the rules. **Speaker 23:** It's very confident, there is a rules pertaining to that. They're not trumpeting. **Speaker 6:** Somebody from the planning commission be at the select board hearing to answer questions too? **Speaker 31:** Sure, I think we all can do it. **Speaker 6:** We'll all come. Those are the functions. We can't move. **Speaker 23:** The select board has the ultimate decision. We can move. If you control what goes on in the votes, the state is going to . **Speaker 2:** So if everybody out here is ok with what's going on so far. **Speaker 1:** Jim, I just, I'm calling over and I think it was Nancy, rightly if I'm wrong, that brought up the 716 signs that are in the exempt signs. She was saying that the signs that go up there. Right. **Speaker 1:** I almost feel like that could be rectified if it was pulled from exempt signs. and actually inserted into general sign regulation so that it could go 7.16.1F and it would be controlled by the AL. So somebody's actually regulating the sign because we only have the state law. I just feel like if you take those signs and put them in, they should have to abide by all the signed regulations that are set forth in the bylaws. So the only person that's going to regulate that would be the AL. So that would wipe out, I think, that initial concern of who's monitoring this because right now, you're right. There is no demonetization. We're monitoring it. It's just like, okay, you know, Lori's doing her due diligence with the political sides and stuff like that. But, you know, we only have that town or the school side. I think it's the school side. It's over by the crosswalk over there that they can put stuff on that's been there that's affixed and how that got put there. That's another freaking ball of wax. I haven't been thinking about what's across that board. But that's there. So I've never seen, I mean, I might have seen some other like random sign. But I vaguely remember. But I've only ever really seen the sign that was initially there. **Speaker 23:** It's been extremely strict in this town. **Speaker 32:** Then the new sign that was put up and taken down and then a temporary, you know. **Speaker 23:** We talked about two different things here, too. We talked about signs in the right of way. Right. And we talked about signs, for instance, if I want to put a billboard up on my property, which I can't. Plus if I want to put up any signs in the senior highway view. **Speaker 1:** That's what I'm talking about. I understand. But I was specifically talking about signs. Who's monitoring? Putting up the signs out there. On town property. On town property. Other than the political signs. Everything else. **Speaker 33:** But we're talking about changing town and state, right? **Speaker 5:** Agreed. I still need to be able to look by sign. **Speaker 1:** Who's doing that right now? I agree. You know what I'm saying? I agree. I think it starts with AOT. I don't see anything here. I don't see anything here. I don't see anything here. That stands out. **Speaker 3:** The only thing is there's this one section where it refers to this one section, which I don't have, so I can't tell. But most of this is referring to things that you wouldn't, that we wouldn't be doing anything. It's referring to signs for illegal activities. Signs for things that happened before but don't happen anymore. I mean, there, I mean. **Speaker 23:** Big time . **Speaker 3:** So, I don't know. So, like. **Speaker 23:** No, my point is you're talking about lighting and they're saying you can't. That's what that's saying. It's funny. I mean, I don't know. **Speaker 23:** So, I don't see it. **Speaker 3:** Nothing is, nothing is glaring to me with this. Not that, not that there couldn't be things. But most of it seems to be referring to the things that you're just like, oh, yeah, like, yeah, of course we wouldn't allow that. Like, no, no signs for illegal activities. No signs for things that happened 25 years ago but no longer happen. I mean, that's. **Speaker 23:** So you know all the federal regulations? **Speaker 3:** No, well that's the one thing, where it does point to that one thing that you have to go and you have to like look at every single little thing. **Speaker 23:** That may affect the allocation of federal highway and benefit of state . So anything that you do that violates their regulations, you affect your . That's all I'm trying to say. I understand your concern. I understand your concern. I understand your concern. It's not . **Speaker 23:** Obviously somebody . . **Speaker 3:** But . **Speaker 23:** . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . **Speaker 5:** . **Speaker 1:** . . . . . **Speaker 1:** . . **Speaker 6:** . . **Speaker 1:** . **Speaker 34:** good definition and we're going to have something that refers to where to look up the right way **Speaker 23:** so you have this regulation because you're clearly concerned about the scenic highway **Speaker 3:** okay so you have this regulation that the board has written up and we're getting very close to the end here where it's basically pretty much ready can we not submit that to the to the whoever it is that you know at least if they want to see that **Speaker 23:** i got you know what i'm saying i i have to i've called every agency in vermont i can get one answer you know one answer you have to be a lawyer in the cyber and i've done pretty good which leads **Speaker 1:** me to think we're good i have full faith in the conversation that we had and i want to make sure that we're working at a level where we're not sacrificing our votes for the the that's exactly what i'm saying is i think when we put forth to the select board i think the select board is going to go through and do their complete due diligence and it's going to progress that's right shot shot back from there so that's right you know so just let's go yeah so we already have a motion we have a second we have a discussion and more for discussion all in favor five nine five perfect any names any names nope okay now let's move to the select board now we have to negotiate Yep. I know it says old business and new business. Wait, Nancy had something. Sorry, I didn't see your hand again. **Speaker 6:** So, with this new sign regulation. **Speaker 35:** You just keep this from me. **Speaker 6:** I know, but at least, can I raise my hand? **Speaker 2:** It's my chance to, you know, I'm sitting in your chair. **Speaker 6:** With this new sign regulation, if it gets approved, so the sign that was previously up, the one made by McCann students, that cannot go back up again. **Speaker 5:** Well, legally it could. Why? Why? **Speaker 6:** Well, that's what I'm asking. Why wouldn't it be able to? I don't know. That's the point. I think I'll apply one button. **Speaker 6:** So, it's got to be turned the other way so it can be seen from both sides. It's got to have another thing. Some more letters in it. **Speaker 8:** And it's going to say. I would say once it's gone out because of the ZBA, you have to put another print in for it and for that sign if you want it to come back. Oh, yeah. We'll follow that. I certainly thought about coming back. **Speaker 12:** Yeah. **Speaker 8:** Well, I'll just ask you, could the ZBA, the K-N-S-O-N. But you can't just go and put it up. But they could, Sheila. No. Yes, they can. Once it's been taken down by one committee of the town, you can't overrule that. That has to be a whole new permit. **Speaker 5:** But they don't need a permit anymore. **Speaker 25:** First off, they were sent again. **Speaker 23:** That's the whole new bylaw. Even with an exemption, though, there's still restrictions. Yes. But there'll be a very good job. And if it does that, I would like to see the ZBA going with the lawyer on this. **Speaker 8:** Because we have the signed letter from the lawyer. Just take it down. **Speaker 30:** That's why ZBA should not be sitting on this board. **Speaker 23:** I absolutely disagree on that. All right. Well, hey, look it. He started it. I'm sorry, guys. You have no business shutting down. I'm not shutting down. **Speaker 1:** I'm shutting the balls down. He started it. I just said I'm shutting the balls down. I'm not going to get into that. I'm not going to shut down. This isn't a discussion for this table right now. We're not discussing this right now. Really not. We're really not. Okay. We want a discussion at our meeting or at a small board meeting. Okay. Does anybody have any old business or new business that they want to discuss currently? Perfect. Motion to adjourn. **Speaker 5:** Second. **Speaker 1:** I'll move. Second. **Speaker 23:** Do we have any discussion for it? Yeah, I do. **Speaker 23:** I have an issue. When somebody said, if you're going to shut down your business, you have to shut down stating conflict of interest or laws without knowing what they're talking about. Just my opinion. Yeah, well, I have a lot of opinions, too, among each of us. So, anyways, I'm just letting you know. And I'm just telling you what we went through. And without knocking it down, I would like to come back. All those in favor? Aye. So, we're going to need some, like, you do, like, I would need some, I would need some interpretation.