--- title: "Stamford Planning Commission — November 11, 2024" date: 2024-11-11 board: planning-commission meeting_id: 2024-11-11_regular session: regular duration_min: 117 audio: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7gMbwVQmzbw audio_source: YouTube (@jgramlin78) minutes: https://stamfordvt.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Planning-Com-Minutes-2024-11-11.pdf minutes_pending: false present: [Daniel Potvin, Alden Finney, Peter Greenbush, Lisa Gramlin, Sheila Lawrence, Marta Miller, Jim Stimpson, David Tatro] absent: [David Saldo] transcribed: 2026-10-21 (faster-whisper large-v3, CUDA; names corrected per data/name_fixes.json) diarization: pyannote/speaker-diarization-3.1 (automated; cluster labels may over-split a single voice; unattributed paragraphs have no reliable speaker) --- # Stamford Planning Commission — November 11, 2024 **Session:** Regular · **Duration:** 117 min · [Audio](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7gMbwVQmzbw) · [Minutes](https://stamfordvt.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Planning-Com-Minutes-2024-11-11.pdf) **Present:** Daniel Potvin, Alden Finney, Peter Greenbush, Lisa Gramlin, Sheila Lawrence, Marta Miller, Jim Stimpson, David Tatro **Absent:** David Saldo --- **Speaker 1:** Let's get rolling, guys. Let's get the camera going. Wait a second. Just so you know, it's rolling. **Speaker 2:** To the flag of the United States of America, **Speaker 1:** to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. **Speaker 1:** Hello, everybody. Dan is going to be a few minutes late today, so I will start the meeting. We are here at the Planning Commission meeting. If you have a matter to discuss that is not included on the agenda, you may do so by addressing the chairperson and stating your name in the press. The call to order. I know Dan doesn't usually do it, but I'd like to announce who's actually here. Here. Yeah, so I'm Peter Greenbush. All of you, Denny's. **Speaker 3:** Lisa Gannon. **Speaker 2:** Martha Miller. Jim Stimson. Jim Lawrence. **Speaker 4:** David Pateroff. **Speaker 1:** Perfect, and for visitors, we have... Greg Marr. **Speaker 2:** Gregory. **Speaker 1:** Gregory. Beth. Welcome, everybody. We'll get right into the hearing of the visitors. Time allowance is five minutes per visitor per topic. Anybody? Do we have anything that they would like to discuss? All set? Perfect. Reading and approval of records, regular meeting minutes from... That must be a typo. It's not July 1st, 2024, that's what the meeting was. **Speaker 2:** Did we have the wrong agenda? Or did I just have to change the date? **Speaker 1:** This is the correct date up on top of the date for the... Oh, I'm sorry, yeah, so... So the minutes will be, do you have them in front of you? I like this. I said I can't remember. October 7th. Okay, so these will be to approve the October 7th minutes. **Speaker 5:** I just have one issue. It was mentioned in there that there was state and local regulations that said that you have to pump your tank every three years. That's not true. Under those circumstances, is there anywhere in the state guidelines that tells you that it's mandated? It's not true. And actually, Kirk used to be the... It's not mandated, I think it's recommended. It's recommended, yeah. So I just wanted to make sure that everybody knows. Because this goes out, you know, could go out to the public and saying things that we're not supposed to say. I would suggest it's wise to do it just to... It is for the maintenance of your tank. But this was in the... It was in our minutes that it was mandated by the state. **Speaker 6:** Okay, so make a motion to adjust. Adjust it to recommended. **Speaker 1:** Second. All in favor? Aye. Perfect. We'll get right into discussion. One topic we'll start with. Actually, I made a motion to go out of order only for the simple fact that Kirk may not want to stay here for the terminating. I'm not quite sure. I just want to make sure. All right, so then I'll back off that. We'll get right into the amendment to the sign by law that I believe a select board member came in looking to have his verbiage that he used. But they wanted to be able to do what they wish without having... **Speaker 2:** Exempt. They wanted to be exempt. Thank you so much. Well, I think in the end they wanted just to be rewarded to sign by law. In general. There's a question on making it exempt or not. I think you speak to the word by law. **Speaker 1:** I don't... I think I briefly mentioned something to you under my breath while it was going on. I don't think our town law or by law is not going to supersede the state's law. That's a state highway. **Speaker 2:** Well, the state highway has its own law. The problem is our town laws are stricter, which is the problem for the sign. So if we want to have in the future a larger size sign, we have to make a private amendment. Because it's 64 square feet according to the state, but it's 12 square feet according to our town. So it's our own by law that's holding us back. Okay. That's why they didn't make an amendment. **Speaker 5:** So we did some... I know Lisa, in her way, she's got some stuff that she's done, and I'm going to talk about the stuff that I've done already too. So with this language... The language that you're referring to that they wanted, it's just something that... Some of you guys were here, Kurt, Sheila, me, I'm not sure. During the whole writing of these bylaws, the sign issue was kind of like we just did it, right? It was like verbiage that was there. And if you look at this, in every rural district, residential district, and forest district, they refer to signs for that district. In the very beginning, I'm just going to go with it. In section four of our bylaws, 4.14A is the first time it is mentioned, signs. And in that language, if you look at the bylaw, in that language, it just refers to... Residential... And there's a... Other... Lisa brought that to my attention. There's another word in there. It's other? **Speaker 2:** I think it just says all other. All other. **Speaker 5:** Meaning they weren't referring to a building, right? A residence. So... But then when it gets to rule, it says the same language. And then when it gets to force, it says the same language again. So, in nowhere in our bylaws does it say anything about business or anything like that. It just says all other. Other than dwellings is the exact word. Other than dwellings. **Speaker 7:** I was going to say, it wasn't an assumption that they needed a sign that was probably a business. **Speaker 5:** Well, no. I think, Kurt, if you remember the conversation or that whole two years that we were talking about, is that we were referring to what our job is as a planning commission. Anybody that comes in here with business or any kind of... I don't know. I can't remember. I think it was a special form of special use. It has to be referred of site plan and it comes here. Which is where we put all the constraints on the building or the commercial property or whatever else. All that was talked about where the sign would come in, the lighting would come in. We have reference to lighting. We have reference... Right. Signage. Like a 12 or 13 step site plan. Right. So I did some research. And I'm just saying... I'm just saying that it was a lot of work. that the commercial type of signage that we're referring to now is not in our bylaws. One could assume that we were referring to that in the language that we have now. But I think it needs to be spelled out a little bit better. And I did do some research, and I found some bylaws that were close to what I think we can use. And we don't have to go with this language, by all means, but I think it hits where the select board wants to be and what we want to be. We don't want to over-regulate. We all know that. But I think this will take care of the situation. We can write the language any way we want. But I say we leave everything in the bylaws as it's written. Now we include under the sign, the initial sign verbiage, exempt signs. Okay. Traffic, directional, instructional, informational, and similar signs which are erected, maintained, and administered by the town of Stamford or state of Vermont. Here. **Speaker 6:** Well, don't... Directional, instructional, informational... I mean, that's a lot... I mean, isn't part of what we're trying to do to change this 12 square feet thing because it's going to be too small? It's going to be too small for people to see? So if we exempt all of those things, it means somebody putting up a sign that's got a bunch of information about what, I don't know, that they sell or something like that. **Speaker 5:** So traffic, directional, is all exempt signs already? **Speaker 6:** Exempt from this language, the 12 square feet? **Speaker 5:** Well, it's not exempt from the signage, but if you want to put other... This is just the beginning of our... Our... Our verbiage that we're talking about today, right now. Okay. Okay, so... But I think the other... The square footage part of it needs to be added. This is just the beginning of what I'm thinking. This is a portion of a... Of some language from other bylaws. Okay. That has passed. **Speaker 8:** I just want to make... **Speaker 1:** Be careful, and this is just my opinion. I don't know if anybody has seen the sign that was put up at Clarksburg Town Hall. Nightmare. Okay. That thing, I'm sure they had great intentions. Right. I know the person that goes across the street, and it's driving her absolutely insane. And it flashes all day, and it puts all kinds of stuff in. Next thing you know, people are... I think we need to be careful about what kind of signs. What about our digital signs? Yeah, you know, digital signs. **Speaker 5:** We do have verbiage for that. No flashing lights. **Speaker 9:** Right. **Speaker 2:** I'm just saying... Exempt. Exempt. Exempt. Exempt. **Speaker 1:** Yeah, I just want to make sure that... And that's just my... **Speaker 10:** No, this is a... **Speaker 5:** This is the beginning. We could put any numbers in there or whatever you want, but... That scares me. What's really scary is go on, for instance, go on Bennington County and look at their sign. It's about 12, 13 pages long. It's almost as long as our bylaws. It's so specific, it hits every page. I mean, it's got a lot of signs on it, it's got a lot of different things. We got to make sure that we don't miss everything and anything that could be. And that's all. I don't think we need to be that way. **Speaker 11:** But we do need to clarify some things. **Speaker 7:** I know that. My stance on the sign, or signs in general, probably all the way back from when we were writing those things, when I first joined up, is that the municipality should be exempt, as should churches. Exempt from signage. **Speaker 2:** We get in trouble with churches, though, because they bow in front of Church of Satan. You know, we get really... **Speaker 7:** Well, that doesn't say anything about the verbiage of your sign. **Speaker 2:** you can put whatever you want in the church okay but do you see where the church can become a prop **Speaker 5:** a danger zone possibly but the church is a bible three there is a place of worship it falls under **Speaker 11:** the same laws that we were talking about and then this whole argument would have been killed two **Speaker 7:** years ago all the time and the money we're on with two signs probably have to go on the three signs but the second sign is not going to work either right because there's going to be half the population pissed off at that sign so we just wasted all this time and resources it's pathetic we got so many other things contrary down the town particularly on the future usage of the land roads all that stuff and we wasted two years on the sign you know if this plan is there for the sign up there or not it's ridiculous um the municipality is exempt period that's it end **Speaker 12:** the conversation game over yeah that's my opinion so that seems like a really simple **Speaker 6:** clear thing to pave the way to resolving this so is there a really simple version of a bylaw amendment that we could create that just basically says i think that's probably already state law **Speaker 13:** right well we have this you know 4.1.7 on page eight of our bylaws has this thing about four **Speaker 6:** square feet blah blah blah blah blah so you know it also says no fashion life so and so on and so forth but is the main thing that we want to be able to number one have it close enough to the road to see it and number two have big enough to see it and what is the language that we need to establish that **Speaker 7:** my guess is the whole sign conversation started in town when velmas became a store it's just a guess but that's what i think it is but the general idea the general consensus was it's a country rural town let's keep it small and concise let's not have a big huge sign with neon lights stuff on it i think that was the objective i mean you can play around with those numbers until you pull in the face but i mean this station should have been closed two years ago **Speaker 6:** you can't have outside lights that flare up into the right way yeah i mean **Speaker 5:** the planning the planning commission it has like you know planning and all the site review and stuff that's something that we can impose on Another thing that we can suggest is that we keep the language exactly the way it's written, eliminate the or other, and that way the exemption from the state automatically falls in to us. **Speaker 2:** If you say it's just for dwellings and you get rid of or other, I mean, there are things that are between the municipality and a dwelling, like a store. Can we just add an amendment? **Speaker 5:** So the law is who's interpreting it, right? If you're interpreting the law right now, the way it's written in there, then that exemption doesn't work for us. Because one is inferring that that language is reaching out to the municipality as well. It goes for the municipality. **Speaker 7:** I mean, if you're more comfortable. If you're just putting something under there like the state, I mean, the municipality is exempt for the state, whatever, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Exactly. Yeah. **Speaker 14:** Exactly. **Speaker 5:** But you have to change that word. You have to change the word in the bylaw where it says residential or other. What was that, Lisa, remember? That was our little argument. Yeah. **Speaker 2:** Other than dwellings. For uses other than dwellings. **Speaker 15:** Right. **Speaker 5:** So if we just omit that, right, then the municipality falls back under exempt. Just the municipality. I don't disagree, but we want to make sure that it's cut and dry. So we make sure that municipalities fall under chapter, section, blah, blah, blah, blah. Yeah. **Speaker 1:** I think that if we eliminate what you just said, and then put an amendment in there that simply says per the state guidelines. Yeah. All municipality signage is exempt from these bylaws. **Speaker 16:** No, all follows the state guidelines. **Speaker 1:** All follows the state guidelines. **Speaker 4:** Yeah. Right. Yeah. Right. **Speaker 17:** I mean, if you want to be more comfortable with that, I'll give a hold of anything on the regional commission. **Speaker 7:** I know when we asked them this opinion over a year and a half ago, they were of the stance, well, you know, maybe that's true, but in order not to piss everyone off in town, you may just want to leave it in the bylaws, essentially, in a nutshell. Well, it doesn't matter. At this point, we're going to offset 50% of the bylaws. Yeah. **Speaker 1:** We can't continue to beat a drum for, I mean, how long is that? Oh, two years. Hold on, two years. Two years? I mean, we've got to put this to bed. Yeah. And allow the process to continue. **Speaker 2:** We're just going to be left with a hole still. If we get rid of the other indwelling, and we have something for the municipality, we have residential, and we have municipality that's digging out stores and something else not digging out. Sure. You know, we haven't covered that. **Speaker 1:** But I think that within what he was talking about, if we add that, that's going to cover the store. **Speaker 2:** Add what? The store. **Speaker 1:** So when he first started to read, yes, I don't have it in front of me. So if we add that amendment, if we put an amendment in there that specifies everything, it pretty much was lumped into street, street, street, street. Street signs, the stock signs, the whole shebang, we can include stores and or businesses within that format, I think. We don't have a choice, because what's going to happen is if we just leave it for residential and municipality, don't think for one second the guys at Belmont's aren't coming for a sign, because they're coming. Look. **Speaker 5:** They're doing a lot of renovations. State law specifically. State law specifically for municipalities, right? So we leave, we leave, it's as simple as this, I think. Leave the verbiage alone, change that one particular where it says or others. **Speaker 2:** So we leave in the non-residential, keep the 12 square feet for non-residential as well, is that what you're saying? No. **Speaker 5:** Don't put non-residential. **Speaker 2:** Except for municipalities? **Speaker 5:** I wouldn't even put that in there. Just, if you omit anything that makes people to, make people to, infer that the municipal, the municipality are, fall under the others, which is what your argument was, no? Um, not following you. All right. So when we got this legal thing that says that based on the language that you gave them, that the municipality falls under our violence, so remove the language that makes that happen. And then we will write up another, just two, three-liner saying that municipalities, just exactly the way the state law heads it. We'll follow. Exactly what it says, whatever that language is. And I, you know, I could be even more specific. **Speaker 2:** Right. I just, I guess I wasn't sure on all that because it happened kind of late. **Speaker 1:** Right. I think what you're trying to figure out is, and I can understand is that, what about Bill Mott's, what about the golf course? Commercial golf? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. **Speaker 18:** No, there's no zoning for commercial property, but they're essentially commercial. **Speaker 1:** But I think we got to be careful that we still have to keep those in mind because all of a sudden they're going to be like, oh, yeah. Oh, I can put up a sign now, but I just want to make sure I truly believe that we're on the same page. **Speaker 5:** What we have to also understand, Pete, is, is that businesses and commercial, anything that's commercial, have to be permitted as such, has to go through the planning commission for a site plan, any kind of, any kind of, any kind of permit that, you know, if somebody here owns a business and they file for a permit to do X, Y, and Z, it can't be approved by the zoning commissioner until it comes to us. We have to approve it. We don't have to approve any special usage permits. **Speaker 7:** We don't have to approve the limits or anything. I mean, if they come in and they say they're going to have a sign that's 30 by 20, you know, you can say, no, that's, I mean, you'd meet all the other 10 criteria, but number 11 here, where it says the sign of your sign, it all has to be. **Speaker 2:** I mean, Bill Motts, I'm assuming, got, in their permit, something to do with their sign. **Speaker 19:** They did. **Speaker 7:** They must have. Yeah. They did. I think when Bill Motts became a store, that was when all the whole sign, like, you know, people started talking about signs. **Speaker 6:** So what if under signs, what if we added, instead of just adding a sign, what if we added an additional sign? Instead of it just being for residential uses, one sign over, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, and all our positions. What if we said for residential and commercial uses? What do you want to know? I want to know if it's a trust therapy. **Speaker 5:** So what you're reading. We don't? No. **Speaker 2:** Bill Muntz is bigger than a trust therapy, isn't it? Bill Muntz signed it? No. No? No, I don't think so. **Speaker 20:** It's probably too nice. **Speaker 5:** What you're reading, you guys got to keep in mind when you're reading the bylaws and stuff, look at what section you're in. You're reading residential zone, right? You're also, if you go into the rule zone, you'll read the same thing where it applies to rule. And then when you go to the forest district, you're going to read the same thing that applies to the forest district. And as you get into the forest district, there's more restrictions as far as setbacks and acreage and other things. Yes. Remember when I was? When I first started as a zoning administrator, correct me if I'm wrong, that we had an issue at Bill Muntz. They had changed the sign or a light, and it had a flashing light or something at some point. And somebody complained. Yes, it was our neighbor. And I went into my office in there and pulled out all the records and looked at the planning commission's guidelines they put on the store. And we went down and we eliminated that. Mm-hmm. So what I'm saying is we will have the say-so of what a commercial or business is capable of doing here. This will tell the residents what they're allowed to do. And we will refer to the municipal verbiage on the wall and post-its. **Speaker 2:** I know it. I know it. This is awesome. I have the paperwork on the way when we do want to go and do it. There's a specific checklist, and it's quite extensive. **Speaker 5:** So it would be Title 10. We would refer to Conservation and Development Tourist Information Services. That's actually Chapter 10, BSA Section 494, Exact Signs. That's what we would refer to for commercial. And it basically gives you, I don't know if you've read it, but the following signs are exempt from all requirements of this chapter except as indicated in Chapter 4 or in Section 495 of this title. It just goes on, and it's kind of specific signs erected and maintained by or with the approval of the town outside the highway right away, each of which does not exceed 64 square feet. We don't, again, if we put the verbiage on the wall, if we put the verbiage in here correctly, we could also make the town come to us for approval on a sign. Not a permit, but a sign. So in other words, we could put constraints on even the time. What's the state right of way? **Speaker 1:** Is it three rides? 49. **Speaker 10:** Yeah. **Speaker 1:** Sure, 25 feet. Is that in the center one? Yeah. Yeah. So I just want to make sure, because the verbiage, unless I'm completely reading it the wrong way, it says signs erected and maintained by or with the approval of a town outside the highway right away. Right. So we still need to be back from that 25 foot from the center line regardless. Right. I'm just saying. No, no. Because I don't know, honestly, I have no idea what that new sign that they put up, how far away from the center line it was. Right. I don't know. Maybe it was 26 feet. I don't remember. It was not that far. Yeah. Yeah. So that's. It was 32 feet. That, what I referred to, the state law still supersedes the town bylaw. That's what I was referring to. Yeah. That, because we can put anything we want in place. They still got to be 25 feet back. **Speaker 2:** It was 32 feet, so it only had one violation at the time when it went to the ZBA. **Speaker 7:** The assumption was, through the ZBA, that they had to go by the local bylaw. 50. Right. 50. 50 feet, I told them. Which is not. **Speaker 5:** The cover line, 2023. It's not true. Right. So, our building setbacks is what she was reading. Right. Yes. The building setbacks are 50 feet from the center, the front. Right. It's 50 feet. **Speaker 2:** Which is another section when we do stuff, we're going to have to look at that table and make it abundantly clear that it's buildings. Because as a structure, if you take it as a structure, a sign is a structure. And that's where you get into. That's why she's going that way with that. **Speaker 7:** Yeah. **Speaker 21:** Well, we are. **Speaker 7:** The nitpick and the logistics of it all, right? Meanwhile, we're just aware of the fact that it's advantageous. **Speaker 1:** I think, let's get, let's get to that task really quick. Seriously, I obviously want to wrap this up. I think that we need to create some verbiage, okay, that eliminates that and or other. Okay. And then, that's. That's in there that we are going to follow, if we have to cite the verbiage as 10 VSA, section 494, exempt signs, the town will follow the state guidelines for sign permitting. I, I, and that's. **Speaker 5:** Which is actually David's regulations because that falls under the. That's pretty common drive. **Speaker 22:** That's MTC, Mainland Uniform Traffic Control, it's federal. Yeah. So. We don't have any sales. **Speaker 7:** CBA's have a meeting tomorrow about the sign permitting. **Speaker 21:** Right. **Speaker 5:** Right. Sure. Well, all right, let's just finish this one because I want to mention something about that, too. So, it's still leaving out churches and. If it would be, if it would be okay with everybody here, I have no problem with Lisa and I and maybe Marta get together and do some language here and bring it back to us, done, just to vote on and, and do it. I'm okay with that. That's the three of us. It's not a. I'm good with that. **Speaker 8:** No. **Speaker 1:** All right. We'll sit back and wait for the next. So, at least we're on. The sign. We'll have the verbiage for approval. Or denial for the next meeting. You know, once we get together. **Speaker 5:** Once we get together. All the right. We'll send a copy off to everybody just to, you know, have your input. I don't want it to be a meeting. That doesn't count. If I send an email to everybody, look at this, any, any input, no, I'll just leave it open for input at the meeting. Yeah. Okay. **Speaker 12:** Just make an information and say, well, what happens tomorrow? **Speaker 6:** But not emailing back and forth. **Speaker 12:** No, you don't want to email that. **Speaker 15:** You just want to send it out and then have the, I want to, you know, all right, but we can send it out with this. **Speaker 5:** You can send a motion. We, we, uh, redo this. Uh, on this bylaw and we'll bring it to the next meeting. **Speaker 1:** Second, all in favor. No, she will know everybody else. Yes. **Speaker 2:** Okay, no, she look, we're going to do this meeting here. My house. **Speaker 1:** Let's see that. I don't just make sure we keep up. Let's make sure we just keep it strictly. We don't. Simple. Yeah. Keep it simple. Stupid. All right. Welcome back. Dan, you can resume responsibility. **Speaker 23:** No, you started it. I think, you know, I could get crushed under a tree. It's good practice for you. **Speaker 5:** Can we bring up the, uh, do you want to wait for new stuff or do you want to bring up? Because Kurt might be leaving. Do you want to bring up the tarp? I'll stay, I'll stay, I'll stay. The CBA meeting is tomorrow. I'm just thinking of the 8th and 9th. **Speaker 1:** Second. Well, okay. I think we should add it with new business. Okay. I don't, I think we should just get through. Draft. Let's get into the draft bylaw regarding overshadowing. Yes. **Speaker 7:** I'm gonna talk now. **Speaker 6:** Yes. **Speaker 7:** Well, there's nothing you're going to do here from a bylaw level that's going to have any effect on this. The statement of jurisdiction, overall wastewater. Um, there's a little sheet I handed out here. Some of the concerning parts which may be covered under section. I don't know if it came on highlighted on your sheet. No, so if you go to the second paragraph, um, you know, it's talking about, it's talking about the presumptive isolation zone and blah, blah, blah, blah, the concerns of what, what can you do or can't do in these zones, right? And so it states, since all the processes are occurring sub surface, you are, you are free to utilize the area and any presumptive isolation zone to work, play or construct homes, garages, driveways, playgrounds or garden beds. That's, what they're going to get rid of. That's present of isolation zones. Freak the extent of the neighbors properties and presumptive isolation zones from your property. Likely it sends out to your neighbors as well. So, um, you know, the state has jurisdiction over all this. There's nothing you're going to do from a bylaw standpoint, as far as setbacks and isolation columns. Um, the way you would tackle some of this from a plane perspective, or example, I'm many of these things, you would have just known ways that you would attack some of this stuff. Or would be, you know, road frontage would be an example of a way to attack it. Acreage is a hit or miss on acreage, right? You could sell them 50 acres of land, but I still may wanna site my septic system right over here, right? Which is still gonna impede on your property. So acreage is a way to go about it, but not necessarily any safeguard to it. You know, road frontage, for example, like the long, narrow strips of land that you had there on the map, that the Riddies here handed out on the Sher Road. Most of those probably existed about, you know, 310, 320, 325 feet of road frontage. So at 150 feet of road frontage, you'd get two houses there. At 175, you can only get one. All right, so that would be another means of attack. Another way is to start and I'm upside the end now, I can tell. I'm not gonna- I hadn't heard the end, I knew it was that. These are just examples. So another way to attack it would be through right-of-ways, private roads and driveways, you know, particularly along long, narrow lots like that where you have 300 feet of road frontage, but you have 24 acres of land, right? So if it's only two lots with the road frontage, right, it's two lots, right? 12 two-acre lots that are deep. But if you can extend a private road parallel to that, you don't have, you know, if it's 24 acres, you don't have 12 lots, right? So that's a concern. That would be a major concern up in the neighborhood that's developed or plotted out and surveyed out like what Short Road is. So those are certain ways that you would attack it. We discussed a lot of this at length when we wrote these bylaws before. There was a lot of back and forth with it, but, you know, we kind of settled out where we settled out. But I'm still not completely comfortable with seven, eight, and 7.2 under private space and private road construction. You know, I don't know how I'd ever be more comfortable with it. I'm probably comfortable enough, but, you know, that's hard to tinker around with too. You know, one of the discussions, for example, that we were having was whether, say you own one of these long, narrow lots like that, and you wanted to construct a road down along the side of them to access this land. Now, should that road be right on the property line or should there be a 25, foot setback from that property line to put the impetus on the person that actually owns the land that wants to develop the land rather than the neighbor that may not want all their trees to die along that trip road? Just for a random example. For example. These are all things that you can argue out and hash out. Trees die. It could work for me. Yeah. I mean, these are all just some examples that you can argue about to your blue-in-face. Whether you want to do any of that or not, I don't know, but you're not going to trade any, bylaw here on a setback for overshadowing that the state is just not going to get appeal from the state and, you know, approve through them or deny through them. **Speaker 11:** What don't you agree about with 7-3? **Speaker 7:** Not that I don't agree with it. I just don't know that I'm completely comfortable. My fear in town here is that we start constructing a lot of private roads and we become very fragmented and sprawled out all over the place. You know, that's the only way reasonable now to access land that is . . . I mean, in some cases, it's probably billable. Maybe some of these, you know, some of these cases, it would work out, but we need to be smart about how and where we're constructing homes. Predicts the onset of being in a river valley and high periods of water. **Speaker 5:** What about public safety in regards to that? I mean, isn't there a minimum . . . **Speaker 7:** There is. I'm not as sure as to what it stated for the development of private roads. I think we put some stipulation in the actual . . . **Speaker 23:** And the big thing was, is making it, so that emergency vehicles can get in there and turn around. Right. But that's the only stipulation. Now, I just want to point out why I like private roads. Because we always talk about the tax base in town. Private road costs nothing to the town. You take a 20, 30-acre lot with a private road and you put three, four houses in there, that's free for the town. It's just tax base. Until . . . No, no. No, no. That's David. Look at the specs for the town to take over a road. It costs a million dollars for my driveway to be brought up to specs for the . . . **Speaker 7:** Until . . . Until you develop this private road, right? Yeah. And you live on . . . You decide for whatever reason you want to live at the base of it, not the back end. But I buy the house up in the back end. Yeah. Right. And me and you are arguing about private roads all the time. We're going to know what to do forever. Well, that's . . . Right. And all of a sudden, you're mad at me and you say . . . And you've got two or three other houses along the way. And you say, well, the heck with them. I'm not plowing the road anymore. You have three or four taxpayers behind you that are no longer getting plowed out. **Speaker 23:** Well, it depends. If you do something like this, the people got to work some kind of agreement out that works for them. I totally agree with that. It's not about oneness on the town to make people . . . You know, you three people live on the same private road. It's not . . . There's no responsibility for the town to make sure you all three get along and you know what it means. Like . . . **Speaker 24:** No, but . . . **Speaker 6:** Essentially, though, you're creating these tiny little homeowners associations, right? I mean, that's what . . . You've got to . . . You've got to . . . But, so, in terms of, you know, valuing your house, like, I wouldn't want to buy a house that was part of a homeowners association. I don't want to . . . Well, it's not necessarily an association. Well, I mean, something like that. It's . . . There needs to be a lease. **Speaker 25:** There needs to be a lease. **Speaker 7:** There's another private . . . That's an example, right? So what . . . So could you stack another private road off of this private road? And can I stack them right up to the top of the range and over to the other top and over to the other side? **Speaker 1:** You know, also . . . My whole thing is, and I've said it before and I've been vocal about it before, when we say, where do we want to be in 50 years, 20, 50 years? Do we want communities in this town? Can our town support communities in this town? Do we have the infrastructure to maintain communities in this town? And we don't. That is . . . It's cut and dry. We do not have the money. We do not have the ability. I think it puts . . . steps us back. I understand where you come from, that you should be able to do whatever you want with your land. Okay? I can appreciate that. Okay? Really, truly can. But we all moved here for a reason. You didn't move here to have 37 neighbors stacked right up to your property, did you? No? Well . . . That's my only . . . That's not . . . **Speaker 26:** That's my only thing. **Speaker 23:** That's . . . But you talked about infrastructure and what it's going to cost the town. I'm saying it's not going to cost the town a penny. Well, actually, it's going to cost . . . **Speaker 22:** Well, it might. If you overdevelop the Shura Road, well, Shura Road's not going to be able to handle that kind of . . . You know what I'm saying? Right now, it's already pretty much . . . I would consider it max without upgrading it. Seriously, the . . . I don't know. It's probably somewhere around an 18% grade with construction. And, you know, the , . . You don't want to have to pay that realistically. You should probably straighten it out and take out some of it. **Speaker 7:** I wouldn't say to abolish all private roads, either. I mean, you have to be smart and strategic about it. If there's . . . And this is where the conversation gets tough when it comes to land use plans, right. Because everyone thinks they have an equal piece of land. Well, I hate to tell everybody that you don't. All right. Some plots are more susceptible to building than others. If you own a whole bunch of wetlands, I hate to tell you, your land's not buildable. All right. But if you're higher up on the tier, like over here, for example, and you'll probably like this conversation, there used to be a road from Fort Jett that went over the basin, and I never really explored your property up that way, but probably through there, basically out to Arcadia, that's a road that's on higher ground. That's the land that probably should have been developed at one time rather than coming down farther into the valley. So that road's been long abandoned, but, you know, if there's a strategic private road somewhere that makes sense and is developed in the right way, well, I think that's good, too. **Speaker 27:** We do need to have some level of small, moderate, rural growth. **Speaker 23:** It always comes down to this when we get in these discussions, is the taxes are too high in town, and nobody wants a loud building. **Speaker 1:** They ain't coming down. I don't care how much building we build. I don't know. I think they're always going to have that argument, too. Our school tax base, that tax rate is going to keep going through the roof. When the state's not done with it, they're going to say, let's reassess the whole state again, and everybody's going to go up again, and the tax rates are going to go up. I mean, I've seen it. **Speaker 28:** I mean, the smallest house is going to come in at $200,000. **Speaker 27:** Yeah, but I mean, it depends on what the town wants to look at, too. **Speaker 7:** If you want to appeal to, you know, middle America, if you want to appeal to family-based people, you're probably going to grow the school population. You're probably going to grow the out-of-street tuition population, right? So your taxes may just go up. If you're trying to appeal with construction in the aspect where you want million-dollar homes to come in here, and they're second-homers, and they live here three months of the year, and they consume no resources, you probably generate a lot of taxes with absolutely no resources at all. **Speaker 23:** Yeah, see, I don't think there's any areas to develop in town that's going to accommodate that. I think it's going to be existing properties that out-of-state people would love and want to come in, right? Right. Like East Road and some of these other big tracks. **Speaker 29:** Mm-hmm. **Speaker 7:** Well, it takes a lot of thought, really, when it comes to, you know, we've kind of just blanket covered the whole town, right? We say, okay, this will be two acres, and that will be five acres over here, and it's like blanket coverage, like all land is equal, which on one term it is, right? We would all think our land is equal. But from a land use standpoint and a development standpoint, not all land is equal. Right. So you have to decide where these private roads may go. You could maybe even break the town down into different segments as far as acres, right? Like, maybe it makes more sense over here. Like, I've argued before, right now, right here in the village, you could go down to one acre. I'm not saying that you should do that or not do that. It would have absolutely no effect on anything. Most of the houses in the village are already at less than an acre or an acre. If you own an acre and a half, it's less than an acre and a half. Other than C.J. or the Christopher Leans right here, you've got a big lot. I mean, both lots are all over the place. **Speaker 23:** I'm working on a 40-acre piece up in Reef Grove, cleared up for the driveway. There's only one spot on the property, 40 acres, you could put a house, right? And I broke my bucket twice with boulders there to get an acre of land cleared. Yeah. You've got stone walls that are, right, it's like a castle in there. The guy loved it. He was in the Marine Corps, right? It's like, it's just a rock pile, and a lot of Reef Grove is like that. So I understand what you're saying about the parcel, you know. In this case, I mean, I hate the patent developments, but in this case, he did make big lots. You know, you're not talking two five-acre lots or all good-sized lots. Yeah. They are narrow, spaghetti stretch, you know, that's the way the patent did it. Well, it's wet in there. Is it wet back in there? I don't know how much. Further down, I cut 37 acres of timber, thanks to... **Speaker 7:** Well, hypothetically, if it wasn't wet, and hypothetically, of course, that neighborhood right there, it's because it's flat for the most part. It basically looked like over by the airport in North Adams, if you wanted it to. **Speaker 23:** How many lots up in there are actually... There's still a lot of vacant lots, isn't there? **Speaker 22:** There's a couple for sale. A lot of people have bought other lots next door. **Speaker 30:** Well, that's what you can hope for. Yeah, right? 21. **Speaker 31:** So they just don't want a neighbor. **Speaker 1:** I mean, that's about... **Speaker 32:** The house is up there, and the people that are up there. **Speaker 30:** 21? **Speaker 33:** Unless they start growing like they did, it's, you know, now I want to build a house. **Speaker 20:** That's the most extreme example, Tom. I think there's other smaller examples that have small duct over patent lots, but... **Speaker 7:** Nothing to the extreme like up there. I mean, that road could be... **Speaker 30:** I mean, if you drive, those would be bigger, a lot more fun. Right. In bigger lots. It's more square than that kind. Yeah, yeah. **Speaker 22:** The grade of the property shouldn't matter, you know. You're not going to want a bunch of houses stacked on a steep grade. You start clearing all that when you have the runoff, it's going to be like... It's going to take a bunch of things. Trying to throw road. Yeah, I mean, I have one new house put on the bottom. It's called LaShare Road, but it's in between Jetson and LaShare. And just what they did in there for drainage, they're driving in their house, and when it rains hard now, it causes issues. **Speaker 7:** I mean, you guys can spend months arguing about all this stuff if you're so inclined, or you don't have to tell me at all. There's no mandate on rewriting the bylaws right now, I don't think. No. **Speaker 6:** Some of these things I think are good. I mean, this idea of like how much road fromage. The whole idea of can we limit anything about private road so that it doesn't become this private road on private road like you were just describing going over to Manhattan. **Speaker 7:** What you could do is make, I mean, you could make it more regulated, or you could make it less regulated. That all depends on how many units you want for people looking at it, right? Do you want this whole board to look at every single unit on a private road, or do you want this board to look at maybe anything more than two units on a private road? I don't know what's in there. I don't know exactly what it is right now, exactly what it is. **Speaker 34:** What's the difference between a driveway and a private road? **Speaker 7:** Yeah, there you go. So you're going to spend about six months trying to figure that out, and you're still not going to have an answer. Right. Yeah, well. We've talked about that for a long time, but there does need to be some distinction between. **Speaker 4:** Well, if it's a driveway, then the new person up the driveway needs to work out a deal with whoever's driveway they're using to get to their private road. **Speaker 7:** Right. And never mind what would you think the difference would be. I can tell you what I think it is. So a driveway to me goes to one dwelling. Maybe it's a duplex or something like that. Anything more than that, then it's a private drive. **Speaker 23:** Okay, take Arcade Drive where my sister Denise and Jimmy Rondo live. There's one, two, three, there's four houses on that private drive. **Speaker 7:** I don't know, Ken or Green would think that worked out. Probably back in the day, none. I mean, there's roads like that in town with popular drives. I mean, you were supposed to, way back since the beginning of the bylaws on private roads, I think there was always a number on how many units you could have. I think it was two. Anything more than two had to go some kind of review. Is it Nichols Road, private two? People just did it. **Speaker 1:** I mean, how many houses are on that? There was no. Three, four? Yeah. There was no oversight on it. Just over the bridge on the left. Okay. There was two roads and everything after that. That says private, basically, both. Yeah. But it is. I don't think it says private road. It just says Nichols private road. It's a private road. Same question. **Speaker 2:** Do you take care of those roads? No. No. That's a problem. What did Dan mention? Do you not take care of them? No. **Speaker 5:** The other thing that we got to keep in mind with the planning commission, too, is we could talk until we're blue in the face about everything that we're talking about. But what we need to do as the planning commission, I know I'm just going to throw it out there. You don't have to answer or nothing. But has anybody read the town plan? Yes. So the town plan dictates what we do here. Right? And everything that I pretty much read into the town plan, it doesn't sound like we're looking to bring stuff in and make things there. It's more like what you're referring to in the future, 50 years from now. Being the same as it is now. Although our primary function, the way I read it, is renewable energy. We're looking for stuff like that. We're looking to better the living. We're looking for a vision. Exactly. A vision. That's our job to kind of plan that. **Speaker 7:** Well, we're already writing a whole regional plan right now, which is going to affect the town plan, which you're probably going to have to- Right. I wouldn't re-arrange it all again, but- We'll have to get out of town. Yeah. We'll have to get out of town. The goal is just to keep it rural. Keep it rural. Modest growth here and there to kind of just replace housing stock that we lose over the years. **Speaker 23:** You do know that, and Jim, when we were redoing the town plan and the zoning bylaws, Jim was pretty active in here. We drive into Bennington now, just up in Bennington, and they really like, and I'm sure this regional new plan they're doing is going to emphasize that. They like these little condo units. Yeah. They love that. Okay. Get everybody squished into one little spot. **Speaker 30:** Mm-hmm . **Speaker 23:** They're pushing that. Well, Jim goes all the way. Yeah. **Speaker 5:** He's going to one of the- **Speaker 23:** . That's the point I want to make is they can put whatever they want in their plans. Mm-hmm . Right? The buck stops here. Yeah. **Speaker 27:** Well, there's always the built-in safeguard at Stamford with the storm water factor. **Speaker 7:** Yeah. So, how many units you can actually get in town? Yeah. Unless the state's going to come in and put a whole, you know, it wouldn't be both. I mean, if you put in a water system, fresh water system for, say, if you wanted to develop the village more or something like that, you could put in a fresh water system and you could still have septic systems. Yeah. You don't necessarily need water in sewer publicly. I'm not for this. I'm just talking out loud. Yes. Let's all point downtown. We're going to need- One or the other. But at some point, if you're strapped way out- Yeah. Yeah. If you're in a small, like, piece of land, what's it going to look like 50 years from now? Maybe this is a town that does need a public water supply. All right? If the housing crisis is that crucial, the pressures from the state are going to get heavier and heavier and heavier. You can keep saying no and then they're like, all right, and they come back around and the weight gets heavier. **Speaker 35:** But the only place you can need water is here. **Speaker 23:** In town. **Speaker 7:** Right. Village. In the village. Anywhere up there, there's tons of water. Because the state's not going to- I mean, the whole plan is back to medieval thinking. We're going to need water. We're going to need water. So, we've had these conversations a lot, right, where you have a heavy, high density populated village center. What means the Stamford is pretty much what it is now, right? And then, what they would want outside of that village center district, which is highly, you know, populated, is another area around that, that would encompass maybe a half mile radius around that. That's for development. And then, everything out in the hills and stuff is resources. It's farm land. It's- It should be fine. It's forestry. You know, all that stuff. Just like they did, you know, years ago. **Speaker 23:** No, to fly over Europe is so cool. You fly over, and you see these little villages. And then, everything is farm. Well, that's the way to- Then, you see another one. And you know, when you're looking out the plain window, and there's one here, and there's one here. And you know, they're miles apart, but there's nothing but farm. Of course, it's not as, you know, mountainous as this. It's this. But, I- I- I- It's just... And I've been to those places, and they're... I mean, Jim was just in Ireland, and he was talking about it. It's the same thing in Ireland, right? But it's a whole culture. They've been there for hundreds of years. He's like, you know, every Saturday afternoon, everybody's at the pub. You know, and they serve food at the pubs in those places. And- And- But, everybody goes there. **Speaker 36:** You know? **Speaker 23:** Families, kids, everything. And it's like, it's not like here. You know? I said, well, it all depends on what your vision should be. **Speaker 7:** It's probably not going to happen at the start. That's where communities are based, usually in the center. Yeah, yeah. I mean, we used to have a range. I mean, hundreds of years ago, there was another center here in town where most of the people, I mean, if you weren't by where you lived, it was like, hey, Paul, let's go to town. And you'd drive yours downtown, and you'd come out and it would be downtown. That's basically what the push is going to be, to just provide a small presentation. **Speaker 20:** We're going to have to see where we land in the whole new Act 250, and what tier we're going to be in here in town. **Speaker 1:** That's right. All right, I think we need to push forward here. I think we need to put this on the agenda for more discussion, because we're going to be discussing this a lot. Oh, yeah. And it could happen in the next private road. Well, it just came into the start of the draft bylaw regarding the overshadowing and where we want to look. Yeah. So I think we just need to leave that. I don't think it needs to be so much as overshadowing as it needs to be, you know, land use, I think, is a great. That's me, first of all, but anybody else that's on that. **Speaker 7:** That'll always be our toughest arguments, you know, just, just, you know. Discussing, if you're talking about acreage and things like that. It's hard, I mean, you guys, like I said, aren't mandated to do anything at all, not yet anyway. If you're happy with it, you're happy with it. I would just, you know, read through it all and see what you like and don't like. **Speaker 1:** All right, we need to revisit the application for a building or conditional use permit, which. Is this. She handed out this lovely form out of Stamford. This was kind of, I think, we discussed in the last, or in the meeting, two meetings ago, I think, that she had just made a generic. Lucky day, Dan. **Speaker 1:** Form. No, I'm just saying if I'm wrong. **Speaker 10:** This is this state form with the same form that I have, **Speaker 5:** but there's some things that have been added to this. It's just a generic. **Speaker 2:** No, the problem I personally have with this is when we did complete the application, you know, we had to, you know, come across the gardener's thing with the subdivisions. Like that is my question, number five on the back. Wanting all the information sketch showing the buildings, et cetera. It seems to be required, and none of that was submitted to us, and I just feel like it needs clarification. If that's not applicable, we need a place for that or a separate form. **Speaker 1:** Didn't we get a drawing and a sketch. **Speaker 2:** We weren't supposed to, but we did. And we were told to just go. Okay. So we didn't utilize that when we made the decision. Do we have a file right there? **Speaker 1:** Yeah, the instructions for filing this on our application. It's not pretty. **Speaker 2:** We just got a really rudimentary sketch of this green box, and that was it. And that's all we had to base it on. And I just feel like this applies to a more specific situation. **Speaker 23:** I am right here. I'm looking at home occupations. What the heck is that? Do you have a home business? Yeah. **Speaker 1:** If I had to guess... **Speaker 2:** Oh, it's a creation as in a job. **Speaker 1:** Yeah. I would assume that... **Speaker 2:** Oh, I was thinking, like, if I had to find a house... **Speaker 1:** If we want to use this form... If we want to continue to use this form in your concerns, which I think some other people have said it, but you definitely are stuck on number five. Which is fine. No, it's good. If we're going... I think, personally, again, it's left open for discussion. Maybe we just need to add something or an asterisk underneath where it says instructions for filling out the zoning permit. Every question should be filled out to its entirety prior to... **Speaker 2:** But not if we're not allowed to consider it, then. **Speaker 1:** But my point is, is that it should still be... Like, if we want them to answer the questions, then we need to say, answer all the questions. You know, I know it's left open... **Speaker 2:** But do we really want them to answer? I guess that's my question. Do we want them to? **Speaker 1:** I mean, would you want... **Speaker 10:** So, I think we're doing something... **Speaker 5:** People can hear that we really don't have to. Right. So, what I'm saying is everything that's on here is basically telling the person, you need a plot plan, blah, blah, blah. Which is... That's state law. They have to draw out on a piece of paper, whether it's a rudimentary... You know, a circular wheel. Right. But it needs to indicate where your side, back, rear... That's perfect. But it doesn't... As long as it's... **Speaker 2:** That's like everything in question five. **Speaker 5:** Well, let me ask you a question. Why do you need that? **Speaker 2:** That's my question. I don't know if we need that. But it's on the sheet. That's my question. **Speaker 5:** That's on the application. Right. But I'm just... What I'm saying is, you don't need that. You don't have no... Unless it comes to this select board, you have no reason to have that. **Speaker 2:** Right. Then I feel like we shouldn't... When we're looking at a subdivision, we shouldn't be getting this sheet that has that requirement on it, if we don't need the information. Right. But I'm asking, **Speaker 5:** what do you need? So as an AO, zoning administrator, I have to have... I'm not going to sign any permits unless I have all the pertinent information in my hand. And if I come to you, or you want a permit, you are going to fill out all of this to satisfy me, and you're going to draw out exactly what you need and give me a plan exactly what you're going to do. And then I can either approve it or deny it. **Speaker 2:** Right. question is do we need for a subdivision all these you know interesting and future buildings **Speaker 15:** or so forth so on so that would be part of the site plan and the plot plan it for conditional use right so when we're doing a subdivision and if you're doing a subdivision we're up on sportsman **Speaker 5:** and you've got all the land and you're going to do five or six different knots you're going to come before the planning commission and we're going to do a plot plan the whole we're going to give you the you know the regulations that stamford wants to to put on you for that okay **Speaker 2:** okay say my neighbor across the street she has five acres or six seven acres so she wants to divide that down the road do we need all this information from her for her to do that do we need future buildings her house her septic i mean we didn't get any of that with subdivision **Speaker 37:** or we just need the lines with subdivisions so it's got nothing to do with us **Speaker 5:** she would do that apply for a permit in order to subdivide her property that's a state it's got to be state approved she'll do a permit depending on how many lots because we can subdivide with up to two lots i think maybe subdivide two or three you have to do it to review **Speaker 11:** right i'm not sure what to say right you get you don't have it's not a subdivision if you're just **Speaker 5:** doing two lots somewhere it's pushing each one of those picks in right more than two more than three **Speaker 7:** if it came up we don't forget when you do this math that each house can have an accessory dwelling **Speaker 19:** in it right right but the actual lot division that can do two when i went to three came before us **Speaker 2:** correct my question is did you need to know about the septic the drawings that we got no permit can **Speaker 5:** be signed for no permit can be approved unless there is a state permit for septic design but what **Speaker 2:** do you need so we do we do not need the things in number five just to divide the land yes number five **Speaker 6:** number five seconds a plot line must be drawn on the grid page attached to the zoning permit application a plot plan is a sketch showing boundaries property lines area of the lot all existing and proposed buildings all front rear and side yard setbacks from property lines location of water supply and septic system slash leaf field and a north arrow include a copy of any professionally prepared site plan if available why would you take that out yeah you want that so you're gonna say all that you want we **Speaker 37:** want it so you want all of that i want to know if we want this is what we were told to consider **Speaker 2:** this right we really got sorry we've got this we've got the what all that information that we got the septic we got the buildings we didn't get future buildings but we got cars so you're not going to get future buildings yes but i don't know if we were told to disregard that's what the problem was **Speaker 1:** to disregard because they were not here for the buildings the buildings they were just simply here to subdivide the land so we had to make a line yeah we had to make a decision if we were going if it was so it was able to be subdivided well maybe the decision wasn't really right no but i'm just saying like i'm not saying that we should have done anything i'm not saying i'm just saying it came to us as just a subdivision yes we got some of this information but we could take it into account because it had nothing to do with that specific meeting so we had to make the determination i think we were so green i think we should have pushed it off to review and discuss and i think we made a mistake there and i i i mean that's just my opinion i i mean you want this was i remember at least a second meeting and and i'll apologize to you guys as well i probably should have backed off from that but i was taking somebody's word at that time and i'm not saying that that person was trying to do anything wrong at all i just think that we i should have personally stepped back at that moment and reviewed a lot more and asked a lot more questions um and i definitely will moving forward i i i think that this stuff needs to be in here but i think what he's saying is if they're just coming for the division like the subdivide that's it they only have to make that two-year-old drug right that's it and so we don't need any more i don't know should it be a different so that's a that's where you're going yes i understand so she wants she thinks that the form for the subdivide the subdivide should be should be should have different verbiage or some of that yeah because **Speaker 7:** hey and i'm just seven points let's stop seven point two say um subdivision of lots or buildings so if it says lots is there anything over here so subdivision yeah so the third law would have to go through right here **Speaker 5:** i was just trying to read up a little bit more my older age i'm kind of forgetting a lot of stuff but subdivisions you're right now that i remember it's three it's subdividing in three and it is a permitted you need a permit to do it um i don't think number five leave all of that in there we need it she needs it or whoever will be the zoning administrator will need it um in that application that we're referring to the change or whatever the more information that you can get from somebody it doesn't necessarily mean they have to fill out every single part in there right so they need to what they need to do is make the **Speaker 15:** zoning administrator happy with what they need hang on jim's 7.2.2 it reads at least 20 feet wide **Speaker 2:** approved as part of a site plan review by the Planning Commission or by the zoning board adjustment for conditional use for access to three or more lots so if they put a road in right of way we would have a site plan review for them right of way **Speaker 7:** Which is essentially what they put in. **Speaker 2:** But did they if they just divided into three lots? **Speaker 7:** They named it. It's got a name to it. **Speaker 2:** I mean that should have been part of a site plan review. **Speaker 7:** It's a right of road. **Speaker 19:** That should have been part of a site plan review. **Speaker 7:** Absolutely. If it's more than whatever it says here. **Speaker 2:** Not the division of the lots itself. The right of way. **Speaker 7:** Well the right of way doesn't just sit there. **Speaker 2:** Well it says it's 20 feet wide. They're talking about the right of way. **Speaker 7:** Which for one time we changed that to 25 feet. We've never gotten to a final vote but it's 25 feet everywhere else and that just says 20 feet wide. That's in our bylaws. That's 7.5. Right. So if it says lots then there's some dividing as soon as they start stacking lots. Whether it has a structure on it or not. **Speaker 5:** And the road don't have, the road could be exactly on the line. Right. **Speaker 7:** There was some conversation, I mean those were all conversations. Right. Whether there should be a setback. **Speaker 11:** Well according to the bylaw I went through that. **Speaker 5:** As a matter of fact it was on a road for three years. **Speaker 22:** It makes sense on a lot. And then re-putting buildings and septics and they're just restricting it. And then also drainage. If right on the line is where it makes sense for the drainage to work, the septics to work, the houses to work, then that's where it needs to be. Yeah. Right. **Speaker 7:** Well the argument was to put some on the person that actually wanted to develop the land. Yes. Right. The owner shouldn't be on the neighbor. If you want to develop your land, it's your land to develop. Why shouldn't the right of way be right smack dab on the top of their property? It's not their property. It's not their property if it's on there. **Speaker 1:** But that's where we've had this discussion. I firmly believe that you should be able to do whatever you want with your property, but it should not directly affect your neighbor. Okay. **Speaker 28:** You put a bathtub next to your neighbor. **Speaker 1:** What if it rips down all the trees, which is actually your blockage from there? What if it affects the drainage? Every other tree. That's pretty much. Well just saying. I'm all for you being able to do whatever you want with your property, but it should not directly affect your neighbor. **Speaker 10:** It's kind of crazy. **Speaker 5:** It's crazy if you really think about it. If somebody puts a row right on the line and they're just being . . . That's . . . Dirt. Dirt. Dirt. Dirt. Dirt. Dirt. Dirt. Dirt. Dirt. Dirt. Dirt. Dirt. **Speaker 2:** Dirt. Dirt. **Speaker 7:** Dirt. Dirt. discussed several roads that are already way over the limit without getting any type of determining not that i want anything to happen to these properties it is it's water under the fridge but there's been private roads developed with six seven you know or more houses on them and nothing really it's just not a habit we want to get into nothing since we didn't buy the only number right away right you can't deny reasonable access the other one that really stopped is right over great over here is a good example where they stopped is on whatever they call this mountain new lane over there right it had two houses back there the third house never got built um it's all part of the second house now the road is right on everybody's property line **Speaker 38:** right there's that right there a lot of that block deal by the way is i mean that's **Speaker 7:** that's where they put if you're thinking from an agricultural perspective right on the property line because you want to utilize every square inch of land you have if you're thinking from a development standpoint that may not necessarily be the case because you don't need to utilize all that land pricing other than the most straight lines as **Speaker 23:** well i built a lot of driveways over the years for logging jobs and stuff access and whatnot and most contractors are going to take the best approach you know what i mean if it happens to be way over towards the boundary because they're rock lead rock over here you know that's you you're going to go there now in this you know and i'm going to **Speaker 1:** i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there **Speaker 22:** and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there and i'm going to go there really not solving any problem by coming out 20 feet it's really mostly there you know the reason **Speaker 7:** you would put it in place if you were to would be as a slight deterrent for someone to possibly not develop behind their house right maybe they don't want the road to come out into the middle of their land so they say exactly i'm not going to build back there anymore so that's really the only reason that you would do it like dan said most most contractors are going to cite the best location for a driveway on the property whether it's smack dab down the middle or wherever it might be but it's a it's just a slight deterrent for people with other structures i mean i wanted **Speaker 23:** regrowth like this coming off the road and it went like this and i had to and the boundary line was too close i thought it was another hundred feet up then i could have and i could have gone like this but i couldn't i couldn't do that i had it it's a pretty steep **Speaker 22:** gap i mean you're talking some of these the road front is like 220 feet if you clear the whole thing and i put on the far side of the 220 feet and i got my driveway and it's dry right now the dust is coming to you anyway i mean it's just i can see it not working it's going to have to almost be on one end or the other of it to make everything work out right because you've got where's your house going to go where's the septic going to go like can you start you know **Speaker 7:** these little little things it's why it takes a rewrite like three three years put three different sizes for anything where you start there's a lot of things **Speaker 2:** so to leave this then we should have had a site 10 review when we divide down three locks and in the future we will so we'll leave these questions answered in the future if it comes to **Speaker 3:** us to divide well i think what he's saying is that those questions are going to be answered **Speaker 1:** so i think we just if it's not up to our spot and it's not something that we feel like we have enough information for we can shoot them back and say we need more information okay or we we need to have our during our site plan we need to have **Speaker 10:** more information presented to us so you not to belay this at all but if we wanted to we could **Speaker 5:** design our own form is in fact i just had one here um take that it's just that right there just a generic form that that i would i would bring to the planning commission and have a bunch of information **Speaker 37:** and then want people to go look at it right and we already have a cyclone review sheet okay somewhere right in here somewhere we've got a nicer cyclone some of the bad guys but what i'm saying is we can **Speaker 5:** develop our own form but when people want a subdivision this is the form you fill out so whatever you feel like needs to be on that form which i believe isn't that all it's all on here i believe you're not together like a **Speaker 7:** plan unit development does that have a separate form i know we've never done one but we've **Speaker 11:** discussed that for six months too so so when people come here with a site plan review it **Speaker 5:** would be nice to have our form that they have to do we do have somewhere in here the site plan okay so i mean we can make requirements that laurie hands out the site plan review for a person to fill out and go from there but that's just you know we can talk about that at some other time **Speaker 1:** so i guess the question ultimately is do we want to create a sheet of that because what we currently have is suffice for the information that we need we just need to expect to have the information put out in its entirety when we make a decision and if we don't feel like we have the correct information or we don't feel like we have adequate information we need to be vocal about it and say this is what we're looking for does that cover your visa which you're kind **Speaker 3:** of looking for i know what you want another form not necessarily i i just want to know if i think i **Speaker 2:** came to the conclusion that we didn't do it correctly the first time and we should have had the information that's really kind of what i want to know that like that threw me off that this was **Speaker 3:** here that asked me for it and then not considering it yeah i think pretty much early again i think **Speaker 1:** we were so new at the time that something was thrown right in our face and i'll be the first **Speaker 5:** to say that so when they do these subdivisions just for everybody to know like there's there's plans right they they've created plans they have the plans you can get a copy of the plan that's what we do give us a plot plan give us this uh you know fill out this information and we need a copy of your plans and then we'll set up a site review i think you just need to follow that **Speaker 1:** a little bit moving forward i i don't think i personally don't think we need to create another **Speaker 2:** sheet i think i mean i'm just thinking whatever you know we think we need 751.4 7.14 sorry the site thing developed site development and it's our entire and this goes through all the stuff right here yeah i think that's sort of what you have there that's what you should do for **Speaker 7:** anything more than whatever it says in their units do you guys yeah i do want to go i mean **Speaker 23:** out though and this is this is kind of important because we made sure we put it when we redid the zoning by law if somebody does put in a private drive the fire department has to be notified to make sure emergency vehicles can turn around um well they should follow our own highway **Speaker 22:** ordinance yeah they have to be registered it should be that way i don't think it's written that way but it should be that it should go according to the standard **Speaker 1:** whatever the latest code and standard is no they caught the fortune no not necessarily i mean should we go up it doesn't look like this it just means that our dream has been yeah the bill would be like i i need to i'm going to go personally drive the road because honestly i've not seen it i haven't been up there and i can't say that for a while yeah i'm just saying like but but it takes the fire department because they've got to by view I can look and say if I drive down that road the grass might get shooed out or not. If I drive down that road and I can barely fit down in my truck, there is no way in a fire truck. **Speaker 7:** The dance plane would probably need to call the SEC at the end of it. Right. **Speaker 1:** But I think that at that point we've got something in the Scots. **Speaker 2:** It says the zoning administrator shall recommend that the adequacy of access for emergency vehicles and other factors that may affect public health and safety be considered. **Speaker 1:** I mean, it might be there. I don't know. **Speaker 39:** Is anybody driven down it? **Speaker 22:** I mean, I've seen it. It's not something special, but it's wide enough for a fire truck. I don't know. I haven't been out to the end of it. But there should be, I think in our highway ordinances, there has to be a 100-foot call to say I could turn around. And they should be able to turn around. You have to follow. It just should follow. The road should be built according to the code of the SEC. Where is that? Here? **Speaker 2:** The code of the SEC? **Speaker 22:** It's in our highway ordinance. **Speaker 2:** Okay, but it's not in here. I don't know. I didn't ever read anything about the code of the SEC. **Speaker 7:** The point being, in my opinion, it's the most important thing just not to take your eye off the ball on over the course of time. It's just this whole road development thing. Because people will just try to sneak them in and do whatever. Yeah. They don't have any hardcore adjustments on or anything like that. It's just something to be aware of. And make sure whoever the AO is is vigilant about keeping track of these things. Because they can at some point. **Speaker 23:** If I still owned all the land I used to own in town, I'd be the guy trying to sneak in those things. Oh, we know. That's all. **Speaker 1:** That's all. That's all I would. Yeah. Push back until. Yeah. All right. Well, let's move forward. Do we have any old business that, any other old business that needs to be attended to and that anybody would like to discuss again? **Speaker 5:** We can just give you a quick update on solar. I have gotten two contacts back. The person that I was dealing with before is retired and gone. Laura. So they're supposed to. I'll get some more information as soon as possible. **Speaker 30:** Perfect. Well, we're done. Great. **Speaker 14:** Great. **Speaker 5:** Okay. I did call the Green Mountain Power. They're about worthless as a boar hog with you know what. **Speaker 1:** Do you have any new business that you want to talk about? You said, when you said Kurt was going to leave. **Speaker 22:** You wanted me to leave earlier. **Speaker 2:** You wanted me to leave earlier. Yeah. **Speaker 40:** I think we should. **Speaker 22:** Oh, yes. We don't want to. We like to. **Speaker 41:** I think we should. **Speaker 5:** Seriously, this is really a thorn in my tush, because this should not have happened. One, number two, I think the planning commission knowing what we know now, not saying what we knew then. What we know now, I think we should send a message to the DBA, basically supporting the. the approval of that permit. **Speaker 2:** It's not up to us to... **Speaker 23:** Which permit is that? Signed... Oh! **Speaker 5:** They spent a bunch of money to send the denial which shouldn't have been denied because they denied it for road firm frontage. And the frontage is not to that. I mean, and so I know what will happen at the DBA, but I just want them to know that the Planning Commission supports the approval of the permit. **Speaker 23:** It doesn't hurt to do that. They got to approve it anyway because it meets the thing, but if we want to put ourselves out there, I mean, it doesn't matter either way. Are they aware of the fact of what they actually will stabilize? The DBA? Oh, absolutely. You told them. They pulled the sign out. **Speaker 5:** The fact of the matter is that there was a mistake made and the footage, the setbacks were alluded to being 50 feet and it's not. That was for building. So I think I'd like to make a motion that the Planning Commission goes on record supporting the approval of the permit. **Speaker 1:** Let me ask, let me rebuttal something really quick and I'm not against that at all. Do we want to discuss more about the verbiage that we're going to change through the Planning Commission which could ultimately affect what they may want to put for a sign as opposed to this one? So, for example, they've got this new sign that they want to put up. But like Kurt said, half the town is going to like it and half the town is going to hate it. So, I don't think there's two people that hated the new sign that was put up there that ultimately started the nonsense. Is the process of putting the sign up **Speaker 6:** waiting for you guys to change the weather of the town? So are they going through it anyway? Because everything you change here, is it going to change the fact that they are exposed to that though? **Speaker 1:** Well, this is what I'm kind of alluding to. Do we want to almost ask them to hold up so that if we change it and say that the municipality in the town is exempt from the bylaws and that we're going to go by what **Speaker 8:** the state statute is. **Speaker 5:** But to see that the bylaws we change bylaws. Not only do you have to have a public meeting, but you have to have the approval of the select board. The select board can approve a temporary to use the bylaw, but it cannot be actually approved until an annual meeting. **Speaker 1:** And again, I have no idea. I'm just asking. Do they want to go through and spend the money? I don't know if they've already built the sign and put up a new sign that ultimately could be changed down the road because they don't like the word position. Is this going to be the end all be all sign that the town's going to have for a long time? Is this their ideal sign? **Speaker 8:** I hear what you're saying, Pete, **Speaker 5:** but I think that's a separate matter. This is going to happen tomorrow, right? The meeting's happening tomorrow. They're going to decide one way or the other tomorrow. So they're going to approve. They have to. But I just think it's we need to be united as a town. And we need to show the people out there, the other half of the people, that we're not doing something you know, it's just a couple of mistakes were made. That's all. And we're all back on the same page. And I think it's important that we as a board unanimously... **Speaker 42:** You think it would build a bridge? **Speaker 23:** I just think we've got to start... No, I like that. We've got to work for each other. We've got to work for each other. I get it. I just think it's not a planning commission thing at all. It's in the ZPA's hands. I think it's a set-up. I think that she just wants to set up **Speaker 1:** his vibe. **Speaker 2:** So no vibes work in laws? **Speaker 6:** You know what I mean? I don't know. Well, the thing is though, Michael G. Denault came to this board, it's been tossed around like a hot potato from being, is this a select board decision? No, it's a planning board commission. No, then it has to be approved by the ZPA. It's been passed around like a hot potato. And I agree that to signal to them that not only has a member of the select board come and said, can we resolve this? And that we are now coming up with the way to resolve it, ultimately. The special meetings and the town meeting and the... Moving forward with the idea that there was an incorrect assumption of 50 feet. **Speaker 43:** I get the sentiment at all, **Speaker 2:** but when Michael G. Denault came here he did ask us to amend the by-law. So that's why he was coming. Right, and we are. **Speaker 43:** We are going to do that. **Speaker 2:** They should know that, but you don't know what he's doing tomorrow. **Speaker 5:** So I guess I don't... Look, this is important to the town. It's important to this committee. This committee is responsible for the hiring or the recommending of the zoning administrator. That is our responsibility here. We will recommend a zoning administrator that's part of our job to the select board who appoints it. So, we feel, we need to feel a sense of responsibility. Our zoning administrator made a mistake here and she knows it and she admitted to it and it's getting fixed. I think the Planning Commission here needs to, I don't know, to support that. **Speaker 23:** Lisa, from your argument tell me the downside. I won't say the downside. I just feel like that is their business now. It's been handed to them. **Speaker 2:** It's out of our hands. **Speaker 23:** It's a recommendation of a board whether it's the select board or the zoning DOE. **Speaker 2:** Are we a recommendation to them as well? **Speaker 44:** Oh yeah, we recommend **Speaker 23:** everybody. We don't really have any authority even when we rewrite zoning bylaws or town plans. We just... **Speaker 2:** I didn't know we advised the zoning board. I thought we only were advising... **Speaker 15:** The zoning board **Speaker 5:** of appeals are direct, basically they're there to oversee permits, denial, and all of that stuff that the zoning administrator. They basically oversee any denials and they do waivers and variances and stuff like that. They're directly involved in us. We are directly involved in the town plan. We write the town plan. We write the energy. We write... We do all of that stuff. We're responsible for all that and get sent to the select board for them to approve it. So we're a pretty busy group. So our recommendations should go somewhere. **Speaker 2:** I mean, I'm not opposed to it. I just don't see... It's too separate in my mind. They're two separate boards doing two separate things. **Speaker 23:** They actually kind of work together by laws. In this case... By the way, does anybody know what the town requires for business signs? How far from the center line? **Speaker 2:** We don't really have a business. It would fall under the 12 square feet unless it... **Speaker 19:** Right, it'd have a setback from the road. **Speaker 7:** It'd have to be... To establish a business, you gotta have a site plan review. **Speaker 23:** No, I'm talking the distance of the sign because we set the sign size three by four. **Speaker 5:** It would not be in the highway right away. That's it. But you would get that information **Speaker 2:** in the site plan review. We don't have anything about distance. Yes. **Speaker 5:** Under the highway. **Speaker 7:** The state statute is 25 feet. The state is 25 feet from the sign. Yeah. **Speaker 35:** So it's really... **Speaker 23:** It's a mood issue. They're deciding tomorrow. I mean, we could make a recommendation, but it's kind of late in the day now. **Speaker 2:** That's all I'm trying to say. Yeah. **Speaker 1:** Let's just go through his motion. He's made a motion. Restate your motion for it. **Speaker 5:** I make a motion that we send a message to the zoning board of appeals to... We recommend that the permit gets approved and nullified. One of you could be at the meeting **Speaker 7:** and state that. I'm going. **Speaker 21:** So that's the motion. **Speaker 1:** I'll second it. All in favor? Aye. I'm going to step away from this one. So either way, you have one, two, three, four. You're good. Right? No. **Speaker 45:** You need five. **Speaker 7:** Three, four, five. **Speaker 2:** No. **Speaker 23:** We don't have it. We don't have it. No, we do. Yeah. **Speaker 5:** So you lead. **Speaker 1:** I still don't think that it would go on... **Speaker 4:** Decided to change the bylaw to address the state law. Yeah. **Speaker 1:** Which they're going to bring they're going to have a pow-wow and they're going to come up with the amendment for the signed bylaw. So doesn't that take care of... What Jim's trying to do is just send a good faith from the board that says, hey, we support you. Is what it is. I mean, it's just like somebody supporting a politician. I mean, it goes as far as you want to take it, as far as you want it to go. I mean, I'm kind of **Speaker 39:** on the fence with it, so I apologize. **Speaker 22:** All Jim is saying is we've hashed this out for hours **Speaker 23:** Who is on the ZBA? Don't waste your time. Who's on the ZBA? **Speaker 2:** Jean Carpio, Sheila, David. Who else? Sheila Picor. Someone's missing. Teddy Potter. **Speaker 23:** The old man or the son of Teddy? The old man. **Speaker 2:** What else? Any business? **Speaker 1:** I think I'm going to make a second motion if I'm allowed to. To have somebody from our board be present at the ZBA meeting that will let them know that you're on board with their decision. Or not. I know, but I'm **Speaker 23:** trying to reword Well, their decision they're going to make is to allow it. It has nothing to do with disregard. **Speaker 5:** I'm just saying this board just voted that down to support it. That's all I wanted. **Speaker 15:** I'm not supporting it either. **Speaker 7:** If they reject it tomorrow I say the town office will sign up anyway. We're dictating all this stuff to ourselves. All right. **Speaker 1:** Do we have any more new business? **Speaker 2:** Yes. **Speaker 1:** Okay. **Speaker 2:** As was previously sort of brought up VCRC is redoing the regional plan. They're having a meeting on March, November 21st and as far as I can tell as I sent you all the trying to change the rules on the turbines. Sorry, David. I didn't get a chance. Do you have the paper now, though? Okay, that's what I sent out. One of the things they're changing is the buffer. So instead of it being a one kilometer buffer that we were dealing with with the last turbine they're reducing it to a half a kilometer buffer zone. The other thing is they're looking at the Hoosick mountain ridge that runs from Northam's back here. They want that so what we can do about it the biggest problem with this is they're planning on passing this through on the meeting on November 21st. I will be going through it and speaking but we have to write letters and I can send everyone the address. We need to get people to write letters. There's a Zoom option to participate in the meeting from home or we're going to go up to Manchester because I know I have a quiet voice and I'll never be heard on Zoom. **Speaker 7:** I would make sure when you go to ask them if we still have substantial deference on this range. We should have that. **Speaker 30:** What is the implication on this range? **Speaker 5:** The implication is basically wind. They're the best wind and that's where they're targeting. That and the southeast. **Speaker 2:** That's not what we identify as the best wind. The state tells us. **Speaker 7:** That's the most desirable ridge in the entire state. This is why we went through this process. It's in our energy plan. I would make sure that no plan that they're writing doesn't abolish that substantial deference and we don't have to go through the whole process again. **Speaker 2:** Our energy plan makes the most prime wind in the Green Mountain Forest. **Speaker 23:** We put it in our energy plan. We do not want windmills here. **Speaker 7:** We have to make sure that's still there **Speaker 11:** and ours don't change. **Speaker 5:** We're still in the southwest corner. **Speaker 7:** If that is still there I would ask them directly why are you advertising it straight up here in this regional plan? We have substantial deference on that and we don't want development there. Why is it your lead marketing point? **Speaker 2:** I have been speaking with Annette Smith again. **Speaker 46:** Can anybody go? **Speaker 2:** I'm going. **Speaker 7:** You want to go? I'm going to go. I'm not sure if I can commit to it yet but I want to. We definitely need to make sure that that is still in place. **Speaker 5:** It's a slight warning. I don't think you're going to see wind turbines anymore for a long time. **Speaker 2:** I don't know about that. The biggest problem is they're planning on passing it even though they have until March to do this. They're planning on passing this. The BCRC. **Speaker 46:** The other thing **Speaker 7:** and I know why we have the best resources for wind, but why is it always Stamford that's in the direct line of fire for all this wind energy? Most of this wind energy is going to end up in municipal areas. So why don't they develop it there? Why don't they develop rooftop wind? I think the answer is as simple as **Speaker 23:** it's already been developed so they... **Speaker 7:** And it's not... Oh well there's already some there. Yeah, so that makes us... Take this term around a little bit. That makes us an environmentally justice community because we already have them here. It's not we already have them here and we want more because they're here. No, we already have them here and we don't want any more because, you know, where's our environmental justice? **Speaker 35:** It is the third Thursday **Speaker 23:** so you have a slight warning. **Speaker 7:** But I'll go. Those are some of my thoughts that I want to ask you. **Speaker 23:** You got my email address, right? **Speaker 27:** Yeah. **Speaker 5:** They have to rewrite the energy rules and regulations like when we were doing it here. So they have to rewrite them again because they are actually nowhere near what they were **Speaker 30:** looking to do back then. They're actually worse. **Speaker 47:** If they need you to want to go up, this is going to be a good place. **Speaker 7:** If you look at the chart they have in there about what resources are supposed to come from where, they're dependent on Stamford a lot for wind. **Speaker 23:** But if you can send me your bullet points, then I'll just copy it and bring it with me. If you've got some points that I wouldn't think of. If I don't have your email, **Speaker 7:** I'll just text you. **Speaker 2:** Well, it should be in the next email. I'll put everyone's email there. **Speaker 7:** Okay, I'll write it right in the group. And yours is in there. It's in the group. Yeah, it's got my email. What time is the meeting? In where? Oh, the Zoom call? **Speaker 2:** There is a Zoom call. **Speaker 46:** No, I don't want to go into person. **Speaker 7:** I mean, there is rooftop there's such a thing as rooftop wind development for, you know, municipal areas that have higher buildings. Why not put it directly where most of that resource is going to be used? Burlington? **Speaker 23:** Here's the thing. The land that went over the mountain is now owned by the Fed. **Speaker 27:** Why do they like Stamford so much? **Speaker 7:** Because we have a three-phase connection that they can get into. They don't like to be far away from the lines that are going to distribute all the energy. **Speaker 7:** Well, you've got two major systems **Speaker 5:** right here on this thing that would all have to be upgraded anyways. Right. **Speaker 2:** So what Annette Smith, I don't think you know about Annette Smith. I don't. She runs this thing called Vermont Vermont is a clean environment and she tackles kind of all this stuff. I worked with her with the last turbine and she really helped us. **Speaker 23:** Is she going to the meeting? **Speaker 2:** I'm not sure. **Speaker 23:** So at 6 p.m. where is the location? **Speaker 2:** I'm going to send it to everybody. She's a lawyer for the BLCP, right? But it's at 210 South Street UCF, the conference. I'll email this to everybody. **Speaker 23:** I've been to their headquarters before. **Speaker 2:** I'll email this to everybody. Great. Is that in Manchester? Wait, this is Bennington. Sorry, I'm going to be in Bennington because this was the October notice. It's down in the October notice. It's going to be in Manchester somewhere. **Speaker 7:** I would petition to get this statement right out of here under wind if you guys read it. Like Judd was saying, Stamford may be a prime location for wind development. Oh, yeah, great. There's already some there. **Speaker 46:** It's in Massachusetts. **Speaker 7:** It's not rainy. It's the rain on the coast. They're trying to appeal to the aesthetic nature of it. We see it in the dirt. **Speaker 2:** It's actually in the park house. Park house? Park house. **Speaker 7:** If you're going to email that to us, I'll have an address so I can get there. I would put one caveat on this. Don't get me wrong. I don't want wind energy but at some point the state's going to keep kicking down the door harder and harder to this region and we can't keep saying no to everywhere. So I would find some locations that need to be in our energy plant. **Speaker 2:** It's the Greenmount Forest. **Speaker 7:** Greenmount Forest isn't going to do it. The town is not going to get any money if the windows aren't Greenmount. **Speaker 5:** Where we said southwest or the southwest corner we were all sitting here laughing because it was all forest property. We knew it. We were basically saying no wind though. Right. **Speaker 23:** Northwest was in your area for good wind and I know the northwest section because I had tons of land bordering that. Now they own it all. I didn't own the land. That northwest was in the zone that was not as good as this but it was still the color shade they had was a good deal. National Forest don't want it. Yeah well they can come solo. They ain't coming here. Can they force themselves on private property? No. **Speaker 7:** I mean even that we have substantial deference out there that doesn't mean we win. It just means we have a seat. They could still say well sorry we're going to put them out. **Speaker 23:** Yeah that is the term we may use. **Speaker 35:** You'll have a seat at the table **Speaker 7:** so your Dave and then everyone else will vote too. So you'll have a voice but I mean you could still lose. It would probably be a pretty good chance. If we don't have that substantial deference **Speaker 30:** it doesn't make sense that they can force **Speaker 23:** themselves on my property. But somebody told me that the governor had turned sour on wind. He did. So what's up? **Speaker 5:** He just got reluctant so I don't see wind coming. One of the other arguments too **Speaker 7:** is that it's a scenic byway. **Speaker 2:** That's what I was going to say. Dave sent me an email and said that it has been identified by the state of Vermont as a scenic view in a highway with protection from infringement to be industrialized for any reason. I was hoping he would come and I could ask him where he got that from. So my argument I would say is **Speaker 7:** stop ruining the aesthetic view of the rural communities and put these fricking things down where the views are already destroyed in the city. Where the electricity goes. Where you're going to use all the electricity. That's part of what's crazy. **Speaker 48:** Neither of that will have **Speaker 22:** any energy for life. **Speaker 23:** You may want to check the... You're good on this subject. You may want to talk to the select board and see if they suggest you go to this versus the select. I'll make it aware. **Speaker 2:** They're going to make a decision on this on the 21st. What was suggested to me is we go in with clear language and pages of the plan 260 pages, but that doesn't matter. This is like page 231 about when we have to go in with the page number with the language we want to say and ask them to replace it on the spot. Because they're going to have a meeting after this meeting and sign it. **Speaker 23:** I just wanted to bring a copy of our energy plan. **Speaker 5:** I think that's what they're doing. They're rewriting that whole thing. They can't re-write ours. **Speaker 21:** The language is already there. **Speaker 7:** Next time that you have to rewrite it, you have to follow these new plan guidelines. Which, once they write this, they'll probably try to kick us out. We don't have to follow nothing. **Speaker 23:** We don't have to follow their five year plan. We don't have to follow nothing. We don't have to do tax maps **Speaker 5:** either, do we? That we had to do. Oh, we were supposed to do 10 years ago. No, we were supposed to, but they couldn't force us. **Speaker 23:** It wasn't an appeal, Jim. It wasn't an appeal. The way it went down, they said we should get tax maps, and we said we ain't gonna. They finally held it to the school budget. That's exactly how it went down. And we pushed from the select board, we pushed until there's a roadblock you can't push anymore. And that's the exact same thing we'll do here. We'll push until we can't push. **Speaker 5:** This is fine, but I think that created more tax issues for people. Yeah, but we were **Speaker 23:** forced at that point. **Speaker 7:** We didn't have a choice. So anyway, you can push back to a point, but at some point the state's just gonna keep coming in with heavier and heavier weight. And they're gonna disregard you more and more because you're not willing to play along at some level. And they're just gonna go here's your windows. **Speaker 44:** If the federal government, **Speaker 23:** that whole thing is owned by the bridge line is owned by two landowners. One of them's the first sitting here. And the rest is federal government. Where the high pensions are. That's all federal land. **Speaker 49:** So I imagine they'd be **Speaker 20:** approaching private landowners. **Speaker 7:** I mean, if it's a suitable location, like I said, we can say no for a long time. And maybe that lasts 30, 40 years. I don't know, but at some point you're not gonna be able to keep calling them no. **Speaker 20:** They might have better technology. So if it has to be developed anywhere in town, private land would be the way to go because that's the only way that the town reaches that kind of benefit. We've got some of the best places on the map. We've got some of the best places on the map. We've got some of the best places on the map. **Speaker 2:** We've got some of the best places on the map. We've got some of the best places on the map. We've got these big fat studies that you all have studied. But one thing I want to get clear is when we go to that meeting, at least if we keep our one kilometer buffer that we already have, they want to reduce that to half a kilometer and make it ridiculously close to people's homes. At least if we can get that and have them remove Stamford, the language about Stamford from their plan, and get those two things. **Speaker 7:** We don't want Stamford to be a shining example of where wind energy is at. **Speaker 2:** From the professional themselves, we don't want that. **Speaker 6:** So I propose that you send whatever information you have to our group email before this meeting, and I propose that you send whatever information to the entire group about what we should do, what page we should look on, let's get prepared, and then let's go. **Speaker 23:** You're going to go? I think I am. I know. And if anyone from the internet, Sheila, if you can get **Speaker 2:** any information about that being protected, **Speaker 2:** you can email me. Well, that would all be I've seen a few how it is. **Speaker 2:** I'll send it to our own IGN. I think that's all federal government now. If it has state protection, I just want to know that. **Speaker 23:** I had two six-point-acre rods that wrapped over the mountain. They started in Stamford **Speaker 7:** A lot of this, keep in mind this may be no specific thought from any one person and maybe just a lot of generalizations they grab for their plan. Like, oh yeah, Stamford is prime wind territory and then they just put it in there, you know, without, you know, maybe there's no interest in developing it at all. But the fact that it's in there, we definitely have to address it. **Speaker 23:** Is our energy plan a separate document here in town? **Speaker 7:** It's chapter 10, I think. It's in the town plan. It was a separate document that we added into the town plan in order to be compliant with Act 174 for energy, basically the energy site. **Speaker 11:** Did we actually write the town plan? **Speaker 7:** Well, we did write it from scratch. It's been built on over the years. A lot of the language is different. It's just paper cut language that they use on all their stuff. But it's got to be done every seven years. And then there's a little more specific stuff that you put into your column. It's every five years. I'm not sure when it's due. It's probably coming up soon. **Speaker 5:** I think it's seven. I don't know. I read seven, but maybe Dan's right. **Speaker 7:** Generally, once it's written, it's usually only minor tweaks to it. **Speaker 30:** Well, you're laughing at it. You write it. I know, but at least it's a little bit more time. It's a, yeah, it's a five year plan. **Speaker 7:** I would say regardless of what you hear around town, too, there's a lot of chatter. The bylaws we worked a long time on, I think they're really pretty good bylaws. There's probably a few small nitpicky things that you can sit here and argue about for months if you wanted to. We're just going to keep finding things like that. Yeah, they're generally pretty good. I mean, there was a lot of compromise that people did, and I think it's pretty right down the middle. **Speaker 1:** I think the 50 feet setback from the center of the road to build a point. I mean, I can understand if you were going to build a living, a livable space. That becomes a safety issue in my eyes. Right. If you put a porch, you're almost reinforcing the front of your home. Well, if you want to bring up. I'm just saying, that's one of the things where I feel like it's a gray area. **Speaker 7:** So a porch, for example, in the Village, I've never been denied because I can pull up old photos. Every one of these houses had a front porch on it. They were just taken down over the years. Porches were the first form of social media, right? That's how everyone related back then. So, yeah. **Speaker 1:** I mean, again, I wasn't denied. **Speaker 18:** There's a whole line of argument where the center should be closer to the road. **Speaker 7:** Yeah. Right. **Speaker 23:** Zoning bylaws. **Speaker 7:** Well, you've got to have a 50-foot step back. I had to go for a variance when I built it. I put my front porch back on the house. My house is 46 feet from the center of the road. So I needed a variance for the front porch. **Speaker 35:** The house itself is 46? **Speaker 7:** 46 feet from the center. Yep. I'm exactly 50. Anyone that complains about traffic flying by their house or this is too loud or that, try living 25 feet from Route 100. You learn to block it out after a while. You do. **Speaker 5:** You do. I live 65 feet from the breakdown ramp. And I live 65 feet from the main of Route 20. Yeah. **Speaker 7:** But a lot of the houses might come even the closest. I mean, Jensen's house is closer than mine, even. Yeah. I don't know. It's all right here. It's like, maybe, 10 feet from... **Speaker 20:** I've learned over five years who drives what way, and I know. I mean, I'm gonna always go by. Oh. **Speaker 7:** I had someone pass me... You don't know where the power is going, do you? The other day I had someone pass me right on the bridge over here. I understand. He's going by me on the bridge. That's what he did. When I see, I mentioned this at the slide party the other night, and some people all some people, but I had to imagine this. I was driving through Amherst with my wife last week, right? We came into town pretty hot, you know, coming out of the car, whatever. And I didn't have a sunny side to set the speed bump or anything, but they had speed bumps, and we hit the thing and caught some air. So I just tried to imagine what these things would look like on Main Road and Stamford. Coming down just airborne right by my house. I mean, and I noticed one, I noticed a couple in Pittsfield the other day, too, so they seemed to be catching on. But they don't work good enough. You're right on that thing. Boom, boom. You should have a couple in front of the school. Yeah, one right after the bridge where they come off the flats at 70. You'd be flying by your house, literally. **Speaker 1:** The amount of counties that come off Mill Road, peeling out to head up towards the flat. Oh, yeah. I mean, I just... I mean, being six people right off the top of my head. So in the 70s... I mean, they folded more. It's like... **Speaker 7:** In the 70s here, when my brothers were both still on at home, and they were a bit wild, and we drew a lot of attention to the house, and everyone had, like, muscle cars, Chappelle's with Paul and stuff. The Arnold. Oh, yeah. There was a patch of rubber that came out of our driveway, literally, at times, right up past the school here, past the bridge and everything. They would just get out there and, like, power break. **Speaker 1:** Straight up to town. I mean, I don't want to stall the party chat. It's going to be a massive... That's another talk. We don't need that. Does anybody have any other new business? So have you decided you're going to come up with some verbiage that you're going to send out to us via email? Or specifically for this meeting that you're going... **Speaker 2:** I don't have to... I have... I have... You already all said it. I will just get out. There's also going to be a link in the email if you want to write a letter. Perfect. Right. Because I'm actually really under the gun with it. All right. All right. Any other new business? I'll make a motion to adjourn. Second. All in favor? Aye. All in favor? Aye. Thank you.